- Joined
- 31 Aug 06
- Moves
- 40565
20 May 14
Originally posted by vivifyThe plan was to buy Brunhilde's freedom at a price they could afford. Had they simply
This movie was great. However, there was one huge, glaring plothole: why didn't the German simply offer to buy the slave from the Leonardo DiCaprio character outright? Why the pretense? Why go through a whole ruse? Doesn't it make sense that a German would want a slave that speaks German? Instead, they needlessly come up with some sorry about a fi ...[text shortened]... n as the fastest gun in the South. "
One of my favorite westerns is "The Quick and the Dead".
asked Calvin to buy Brunhilde, he would have immediately realised she meant a lot to them,
and being a businessman he would have set the price accordingly. Instead, when the deal
was to buy a ridiculously expensive mandingo fighter, Calvin offered Brunhilde at a low
price as part of the deal. The plan, then, was to buy Brunhilde at once, and then go to fetch
the money for the mandingo fighter, but never return.
20 May 14
2 edits
Originally posted by C HessBut he (the German) clearly had enough money, even at the inflated prices they had to pay anyway, when they were found out. He was also going to buy that slave who was torn apart by dogs. So money couldn't have been too much of a concern. Furthermore, earlier in the movie, He is shown making deals to buy slaves, so hee should be used to negotiating prices.
The plan was to buy Brunhilde's freedom at a price they could afford. Had they simply
asked Calvin to buy Brunhilde, he would have immediately realised she meant a lot to them,
and being a businessman he would have set the price accordingly. Instead, when the deal
was to buy a ridiculously expensive mandingo fighter, Calvin offered Brunhilde at a low
...[text shortened]... Brunhilde at once, and then go to fetch
the money for the mandingo fighter, but never return.
I dunno. Still a great movie, though not actually a western.
- Joined
- 31 Aug 06
- Moves
- 40565
20 May 14
Originally posted by vivifyWhy pay a lot when you might get away with less? And shooting the man you're making a
But he (the German) clearly had enough money, even at the inflated prices they had to pay anyway, when they were found out. He was also going to buy that slave who was torn apart by dogs. So money couldn't have been too much of a concern. Furthermore, earlier in the movie, He is shown making deals to buy slaves, so hee should be used to negotiating prices.
I dunno. Still a great movie, though not actually a western.
deal with (as in the beginning) is not usually considered good negotiation tactics.
Your last sentence is just blasphemous. 😲 Not actually a western. Pffft...
20 May 14
Originally posted by C HessHe only shot those men because they threatened him, and pointed guns at him.
Why pay a lot when you might get away with less? And shooting the man you're making a
deal with (as in the beginning) is not usually considered good negotiation tactics.
Your last sentence is just blasphemous. 😲 Not actually a western. Pffft...
And yeah, it takes place in the south, not the west.
22 May 14
3 edits
My favorite westerns:
Good, Bad, Ugly
High Noon
Once Upon A Time in the West
Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid
Sadly under-rated and little-known is John Ford's "Darling Clementine," with Henry Fonda, Linda Darnell, Victor Mature, Walter Brennan, Tim Holt.
Haven't see Django Unchained, and won't--not after Pulp Fiction (I walked out of it).
Not quite a western and not easy to classify otherwise: Treasure of the Sierra Madre. First-rate film by any standards.
22 May 14
Originally posted by moonbusTreasure of the Sierra Madre
My favorite westerns:
Good, Bad, Ugly
High Noon
Once Upon A Time in the West
Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid
Sadly under-rated and little-known is John Ford's "Darling Clementine," with Henry Fonda, Linda Darnell, Victor Mature, Walter Brennan, Tim Holt.
Haven't see Django Unchained, and won't--not after Pulp Fiction (I walked out of it).
Not q ...[text shortened]... not easy to classify otherwise: Treasure of the Sierra Madre. First-rate film by any standards.
just watched it - awesome movie.
22 May 14
Originally posted by Great King RatTarentino is Tarentino. People go to his movies expecting exactly that, plenty of swearing and over-the-top violence.
Yup, one day I'll watch it. I'm a bit Tarantino tired though. I think he should stop trying to be Tarantino so much. Must every movie he makes contain over-the-top violence and ridiculous amounts of swearing?
If I were his close friend I'd challenge him to do something wildly unTarantino-like. Maybe a romantic comedy or something.
Or porn.
I take it you're not a Robert Rodriguez fan either?