Go back
Is a World Order a bad idea?

Is a World Order a bad idea?

Debates

jb

Joined
29 Mar 09
Moves
816
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by USArmyParatrooper
That doesn't address what I said though. Oppressive regimes often do have uprisings, just like what happened in Iran. Sometimes they're succesful and sometimes they are not.

Such uprisings would be very difficult to squash on a global level, so I believe the government would be forced to adhere to the will of the people.

It's an interesting scenario to contemplate.
That is where their kill off plan comes into effect. Those slaves that are left will be monitored 24-7.

utherpendragon

Hy-Brasil

Joined
24 Feb 09
Moves
175970
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by USArmyParatrooper
That doesn't address what I said though. Oppressive regimes often do have uprisings, just like what happened in Iran. Sometimes they're succesful and sometimes they are not.

Such uprisings would be very difficult to squash on a global level, so I believe the government would be forced to adhere to the will of the people.

It's an interesting scenario to contemplate.
Instead of using Iran as a example,Stalins U.S.S.R. is more like it. A good book that describes how he was able to control such a huge population is "the Gulag Archipelago".I think this could be repeated on a much bigger scale,perhaps in our hypothetical world order/one world government.

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
19 Jul 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by USArmyParatrooper
Those checks and ballances are of course important but that's not what I was saying. I was saying it would be very DIFFICULT to maintain an oppressive regime on a global scale.
it would be difficult to hold a whole global state together anyway.

there would always be separatists somewhere, plus, some groups of people just hate each others guts, either because of their religion, ethinicity, cultural differences, etc, etc.

a world government would be short-lived, as some groups will eventually break away, and we would in theory go back to having different countries.

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
it would be difficult to hold a whole global state together anyway.

there would always be separatists somewhere, plus, some groups of people just hate each others guts, either because of their religion, ethinicity, cultural differences, etc, etc.
If the U.S.A. can exist without seperatist movements worthy of mention, I see no reason to believe the world cannot exist without such movements.

jb

Joined
29 Mar 09
Moves
816
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by utherpendragon
Instead of using Iran as a example,Stalins U.S.S.R. is more like it. A good book that describes how he was able to control such a huge population is "the Gulag Archipelago".I think this could be repeated on a much bigger scale,perhaps in our hypothetical world order/one world government.
In case I don't get around to reading it right away can you elaborate a little on the book and how it describes controlling the masses?

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KazetNagorra
If the U.S.A. can exist without seperatist movements worthy of mention, I see no reason to believe the world cannot exist without such movements.
the USA is one country, saying that because it has successfully kept itself together the same thing would happen to the whole world is a big stretch.

the usa is just one country, other regions in the globe are much more divided.

jb

Joined
29 Mar 09
Moves
816
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
the USA is one country, saying that because it has successfully kept itself together the same thing would happen to the whole world is a big stretch.

the usa is just one country, other regions in the globe are much more divided.
What if the other countries were to become like states of the global government?

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
the USA is one country, saying that because it has successfully kept itself together the same thing would happen to the whole world is a big stretch.

the usa is just one country, other regions in the globe are much more divided.
Yes, it is just one country. But a very big one at that. I'm not saying there is never going to be any civil wars, should there ever be a single world government. I'm just saying that it's possible that such a state would exist without civil wars.

utherpendragon

Hy-Brasil

Joined
24 Feb 09
Moves
175970
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by joe beyser
In case I don't get around to reading it right away can you elaborate a little on the book and how it describes controlling the masses?
in a nut shell,a massive secret police state was set up. The entire populace was encouraged to inform on one another w/ a paranoia not knowing who was kgb and who was not. A total fear never to speak out,because you dont know who you are speaking to.Any one viewed as a threat to the state was quietly disposed of.Any person vaguely related to that said person disappeared as well.The middle of the night ,a knock on the door by the authorities for questioning."you need to come w/us".The residents of the home comply because they are law abiding citizens,they are never seen or heard from again.And so on and so forth.Tens of millions were disposed of this way.
the book goes much in depth and this is one example of how a massive group of people were ruled and controlled w/ a iron fist and no rebellions come to mind

s

Joined
06 Aug 05
Moves
11712
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

No, it's a great idea, but we are not advanced enough to do it.

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by joe beyser
What if the other countries were to become like states of the global government?
well, like I said previously, it would be very short-lived.

and very ineffective,there would be a lot of bureaucracy, and all the other problems you get in a big state.

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by utherpendragon
in a nut shell,a massive secret police state was set up. The entire populace was encouraged to inform on one another w/ a paranoia not knowing who was kgb and who was not. A total fear never to speak out,because you dont know who you are speaking to.Any one viewed as a threat to the state was quietly disposed of.Any person vaguely related to that sai ...[text shortened]... assive group of people were ruled and controlled w/ a iron fist and no rebellions come to mind
In other words, it would be a living hell.

I don't see how anyone would like to live in such place, its better to stay as we are now.

jb

Joined
29 Mar 09
Moves
816
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by utherpendragon
in a nut shell,a massive secret police state was set up. The entire populace was encouraged to inform on one another w/ a paranoia not knowing who was kgb and who was not. A total fear never to speak out,because you dont know who you are speaking to.Any one viewed as a threat to the state was quietly disposed of.Any person vaguely related to that sai ...[text shortened]... assive group of people were ruled and controlled w/ a iron fist and no rebellions come to mind
Thanks. I figured it would be something like that. I am glad you mentioned it because people see this as a good opportunity and don't realize they are being set up and duped right now.
http://www.theforbiddenknowledge.com/quotes/index.htm

These quotes are an eye oppener too.

Once people start ratting on each other to the police state to save themselves or jockey for a position within it, we are in big trouble.

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
In other words, it would be a living hell.

I don't see how anyone would like to live in such place, its better to stay as we are now.
Who is suggesting the world government should be a dictatorship?

jb

Joined
29 Mar 09
Moves
816
Clock
19 Jul 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KazetNagorra
Who is suggesting the world government should be a dictatorship?
http://www.theforbiddenknowledge.com/quotes/index.htm

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.