Go back
Japan hangs 3 inmates

Japan hangs 3 inmates

Debates

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
21 Dec 21

@vivify said
The U.S. has laws against "cruel and unusual punishment" for a reason. That reason is the belief that despite the severity of a crime, the criminal is still a human being and should be treated as such.

Keeping someone in the dark, potentially for years, about when they're going to die, only to announce it the day of, naturally causes each day to be filled with anxiety an ...[text shortened]... their neck, this system seems pretty cruel for what's supposed to be a modern and advanced society.
I don't know. We're all in the state of not knowing when we're going to die. Which is worse, counting down 18 days or living each day with a hope for the next? I'm not completely sure one way or the other.

If done properly, hanging snaps the upper spinal cord upon the fall and death is virtually instantaneous. Aside from the optics, it seems like one of the most humane methods of execution, if properly executed (so to speak).

T

Joined
13 Mar 07
Moves
48752
Clock
21 Dec 21
1 edit

@vivify
I'm pretty shocked this happens in Japan. I thought they were more advanced and civilized than China.

These were the first executions in Japan in two years. Since the execution of the Aum Shinrikyo terrorists in the summer of 2018, a mere eight people have been put to death in Japan, all for multiple murder.

By contrast China executes thousands yearly, for a range of crimes.

These guys finding out they're going to be executed right before Christmas.

Japan is not a Christian country, so Christmas does not have any profound importance there.

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
21 Dec 21
1 edit

@teinosuke said
Japan is not a Christian country, so Christmas does not have any profound importance there.
They still celebrate Christmas, just like how we celebrate Halloween without any "profound importance" regarding dead saints.

I agree with you about China. It was unfair to compare them and Japan.

AverageJoe1
Catch the Train 47!

Lake Como

Joined
27 Jul 10
Moves
54580
Clock
21 Dec 21

@quackquack said
These individuals presumably committed brutal murders and did not give their victims prior notice that they were about do die in an inhumane manner. They also knew that in their society capital punishment is a possibility. I'm not sure why a countdown clock until their time of your death is more humane or a courtesy the inmate deserves.
I remember being taught in one particular class that the death penalty is not a deterrent to capital crimes, they don't give a crap. I guess that is true, though I did not believe it at the time. Two of our brothers were killed by another one in Chicago last night, and one was killed in a posh movie theater in Atlanta. Must've had a good reason, and prob was not worried about the electric chair.

q

Joined
05 Sep 08
Moves
66636
Clock
21 Dec 21

@vivify said
The U.S. has laws against "cruel and unusual punishment" for a reason. That reason is the belief that despite the severity of a crime, the criminal is still a human being and should be treated as such.

Keeping someone in the dark, potentially for years, about when they're going to die, only to announce it the day of, naturally causes each day to be filled with anxiety an ...[text shortened]... their neck, this system seems pretty cruel for what's supposed to be a modern and advanced society.
I literally think the last thing in the world you should worry about is being cruel to someone who was convicted of burning people alive. I find it bizarre that there are no calls to show sympathy to those who disagree us on abortion, gun control, or vaccine mandates but there are calls for the sympathy of these individuals.

AverageJoe1
Catch the Train 47!

Lake Como

Joined
27 Jul 10
Moves
54580
Clock
21 Dec 21

@quackquack said
I literally think the last thing in the world you should worry about is being cruel to someone who was convicted of burning people alive. I find it bizarre that there are no calls to show sympathy to those who disagree us on abortion, gun control, or vaccine mandates but there are calls for the sympathy of these individuals.
They can't answer logic. Don't look for much. At least they have mis-guided emotion to carry them through their not-arguments.

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26757
Clock
21 Dec 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm disappointed they didn't behead them with katanas.

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
21 Dec 21

@quackquack said
I literally think the last thing in the world you should worry about is being cruel to someone who was convicted of burning people alive. I find it bizarre that there are no calls to show sympathy to those who disagree us on abortion, gun control, or vaccine mandates but there are calls for the sympathy of these individuals.
Oh please. Are you on death row for your beliefs? Don't martyr yourself.

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26757
Clock
21 Dec 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
They still celebrate Christmas, just like how we celebrate Halloween without any "profound importance" regarding dead saints.

I agree with you about China. It was unfair to compare them and Japan.
They eat KFC for Christmas over there I'm told

q

Joined
05 Sep 08
Moves
66636
Clock
21 Dec 21

@vivify said
Oh please. Are you on death row for your beliefs? Don't martyr yourself.
1. These people are not on death row for their beliefs. They are being executed because they burned people to death. The fact that you are more upset by those who advocate ideas that are contrary to yours more than those who brutally murder is shocking.
2. I'm not sure why it matters but I am not an anti vaxer (I am fully vaccinated with boosters and have no problem with mandates), I support gun control and abortions rights. But, I certainly have more sympathy for those who disagree with me on issues such as these than for those who are convicted of brutal crimes.

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
21 Dec 21

@quackquack said
The fact that you are more upset by those who advocate ideas that are contrary to yours more than those who brutally murder is shocking.
Find one post. Just one post that I've made that even remotely supports your assertion.

jimm619

Joined
27 Sep 06
Moves
251103
Clock
21 Dec 21
3 edits

@averagejoe1 said
I assume you find capital punishment not acceptable. I don't fault you, not crazy about it myself, but what should we do with a person who gouges out the eyes of your 22 year old daughter, stabs her to death, and throws her in the city dump? Execute him like he did her?
Fact of the matter is; people
with money NEVER get
The Death Penalty....
''....Money can't buy you love but,
it can buy you a good defense attorney....''
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
https://www.fidh.org/en/issues/death-penalty/the-death-penalty-a-punishment-for-the-poor
https://okcadp.org/public-education/educational-resources/facts-about-the-death-penalty/
https://www.therichest.com/rich-list/10-innocent-people-who-were-sentenced-to-death/

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89778
Clock
21 Dec 21

@vivify said
https://www.al.com/news/2021/12/japan-hangs-3-inmates-in-first-executions-since-2019.html

Japan hanged three people, and it turns out their executions are all done in secret: prisoners are not informed of their fate until the morning they are hanged. Some death-row inmates are suing the Japanese government, saying that it causes serious mental stress and anxiety not knowin ...[text shortened]... m pretty shocked this happens in Japan. I thought they were more advanced and civilized than China.
Doesn’t surprise me at all.
A nation in which men spend money to buy used knickers and teenagers lock themselves in bedrooms for years, is the sort of nation which would spring death sentences on people like a game show.

However, I would presume a judge decides and that inmates have a chance to appeal.
Which makes the story slightly unbelievable…

jimm619

Joined
27 Sep 06
Moves
251103
Clock
21 Dec 21
1 edit

@dood111 said
I read somewhere that prisoners on death row are kept in isolation in a room with a bed and a chair. During the day they are not allowed to lay on the bed and have to sit in the chair all day in silence, waiting for the door to open and be led out and hanged. It can go on for years.
DOO, Do you ALWAYS LIE?
You did not, ''....read this somewhere
This is WRONG, UNTRUE,
a PREVARICATION..... 😠

jimm619

Joined
27 Sep 06
Moves
251103
Clock
21 Dec 21
1 edit

@averagejoe1 said
Not being picky, but your second paragraph does not jibe with the first, in that someone in your second paragraph, though convicted, may be innocent. Maybe his twin did it!!
Fact is, twins have identical DNA.
https://www.therichest.com/rich-list/10-innocent-people-who-were-sentenced-to-death/

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.