Justify this..

Here is a link to a news story I read, that made me absolutly sick. I dare any of you "murder is wrong" people to read this article and give a justification of why we should allow this "man" to live.

http://www.krem.com/topstories/stories/krem2_010906_tugglesentenced.5f2c3b16.html

While writing your justification, I want you to think about the victim, Try to imagine her as your sister or daughter.

Originally posted by Canadaguy
Here is a link to a news story I read, that made me absolutly sick. I dare any of you "murder is wrong" people to read this article and give a justification of why we should allow this "man" to live.

http://www.krem.com/topstories/stories/krem2_010906_tugglesentenced.5f2c3b16.html

While writing your justification, I want you to think about the victim, Try to imagine her as your sister or daughter.

Originally posted by CliffLandin
I didn't read the story as I did not want to sign up for krem, but are you saying that you don't think murder is wrong?

Are you sure they've got the right guy?

Originally posted by shavixmir
Are you sure they've got the right guy?

Originally posted by Canadaguy
yup
he plead guilty
maybe this site would be better
http://www.amw.com/fugitives/brief.cfm?id=33503

yes
He raped his own daughter. I think she would know that. Did you actually read all the info?

I think he should run for president of the usa.

Originally posted by Canadaguy
yes
He raped his own daughter. I think she would know that. Did you actually read all the info?

Who wouldn't want to execute him. I'd do it in a heart beat.

I don't have an article saying what he was convicted of, but apparently he didn't kill anyone. You believe that the State should have the power to execute people who don't commit murder?

Originally posted by Canadaguy
Here is a link to a news story I read, that made me absolutly sick. I dare any of you "murder is wrong" people to read this article and give a justification of why we should allow this "man" to live.

http://www.krem.com/topstories/stories/krem2_010906_tugglesentenced.5f2c3b16.html

While writing your justification, I want you to think about the victim, Try to imagine her as your sister or daughter.

Tuggle was sentenced to two consecutive life terms for rape and kidnapping. http://msnbc.msn.com/id/10778216/

I think that's sufficient for a crime that, while sickening and violent, did not result in another person's death.

Originally posted by scottishinnz
Murder is wrong. So is what this man did. Will sentencing this guy to death make the daughter any less raped? Will it make her injuries go away? I think this guy deserves a good long time in a secure place with some real good psychiatric help because he obviously has problems. Do I think he should be killed? No. Do I think the death penalty is barbaric? Yes.