Go back
This Debate Site

This Debate Site

Debates

AverageJoe1
Catch the Train 47!

Lake Como

Joined
27 Jul 10
Moves
54556
Clock
12 Oct 22

@mghrn55 said
A dozen libbies over a plethora of righties ??
Hilarious !!
Oh that's right. You think the conservative movement is expanding, not shrinking.
Ok. Carry on. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hey hey MG, there is a pretty simple issue on the table. Why cannot an unborn twin be a baby, as his twin brother is laid out on the table as a baby for a couple of hours?
A couple of zealots tried bringing the Bible on us, when the Bible is only a book of beliefs. I am asking a simple fact, which could not be decided on a foundation of belief.

m

Joined
07 Feb 09
Moves
151917
Clock
12 Oct 22

@averagejoe1 said
Hey hey MG, there is a pretty simple issue on the table. Why cannot an unborn twin be a baby, as his twin brother is laid out on the table as a baby for a couple of hours?
A couple of zealots tried bringing the Bible on us, when the Bible is only a book of beliefs. I am asking a simple fact, which could not be decided on a foundation of belief.
If one of those twins is born a few minutes before midnight and the other is born after midnight ???
They have different birthdays.

AverageJoe1
Catch the Train 47!

Lake Como

Joined
27 Jul 10
Moves
54556
Clock
12 Oct 22
1 edit

@mghrn55 said
If one of those twins is born a few minutes before midnight and the other is born after midnight ???
They have different birthdays.
Yes. But what about the basic question? Let's say we all live on an island and never heard of a calendar, or days or years. So, the day they are born is not relevant. It really is not germane to this issue.
You boys are really dancing. Just pitiful. So that is two down, you and the King Moses person.

Anyone else want to take a stab? No need to mention religion, the Bible, the Koran, the days of the week. Really.....what DAY it is should mean something to this issue? What DAY it is??
MG, MG.......

KingDavid403
King David

Planet Earth.

Joined
19 May 05
Moves
175601
Clock
13 Oct 22
7 edits

@averagejoe1 said
OK, King. This will prove it is a baby while in the womb.
Mother pregnant with twins.
Twin #1 born at 1PM. The blob that leaves the woman's body is a baby, referred to as such by the nurses and older brother on other side of the glass. Cool. Baby Bill.
Twin #2 is not born until 3PM.
If #1 is a baby, is not #2, inside the womb, a baby? Or, is there a ...[text shortened]... 1. Why would you not agree with that? We are trying to get to the bottom of what you are saying .
OK, King. This will prove it is a baby while in the womb.
No it does not prove anything.
Mother pregnant with twins.
How far along is the pregnancy? What type of twins? Fraternal Twins, Conjoined twins, or Identical Twins? Yes, that matters.
Twin #1 born at 1PM. The blob that leaves the woman's body is a baby,
I'm sorry, I don't know what a blob baby is. You'll have to explain that in more detail because I've never heard of that. I have heard many say, and I agree, that a pregnancy up until there is an embryo (around two months) is nothing but a blob of cells; which it is.
Twin #1 born at 1PM. The blob that leaves the woman's body is a baby, referred to as such by the nurses and older brother on other side of the glass. Cool. Baby Bill.
Did it start breathing and become alive when it was born? Or, was it a still-birth? If it started breathing and living after birth, then yes, it's a baby.
I think #2 is a baby if he has the same history as #1.
Well we don't know because it has not been born yet, right?
What type of twins? Fraternal Twins, Conjoined twins, or Identical Twins? Yes, that matters.

mike69

Joined
20 May 16
Moves
41711
Clock
13 Oct 22

@kingdavid403 said
OK, King. This will prove it is a baby while in the womb.
No it does not prove anything.
Mother pregnant with twins.
How far along is the pregnancy? What type of twins? Fraternal Twins, Conjoined twins, or Identical Twins? Yes, that matters.
Twin #1 born at 1PM. The blob that leaves the woman's body is a baby,
I'm sorry, I don't kn ...[text shortened]... ight?
What type of twins? Fraternal Twins, Conjoined twins, or Identical Twins? Yes, that matters.
Do you have children?

KingDavid403
King David

Planet Earth.

Joined
19 May 05
Moves
175601
Clock
13 Oct 22
1 edit

@mike69 said
Do you have children?
Yep, four adult daughters and 12 grand children. You?

mike69

Joined
20 May 16
Moves
41711
Clock
13 Oct 22

@kingdavid403 said
Yep, four daughters and 12 grand children. You?
Five boys and one daughter with my youngest son passing shortly after birth. I find your words hard to believe if true seeing your children grow within and out of the womb and still hold these beliefs literally until they come out.

mike69

Joined
20 May 16
Moves
41711
Clock
13 Oct 22

All grown.

KingDavid403
King David

Planet Earth.

Joined
19 May 05
Moves
175601
Clock
13 Oct 22

@mike69 said
Five boys and one daughter with my youngest son passing shortly after birth. I find your words hard to believe if true seeing your children grow within and out of the womb and still hold these beliefs literally until they come out.
I find your words hard to believe if true seeing your children grow within and out of the womb and still hold these beliefs literally until they come out.
It's called reality.
Sorry to hear about your son passing.

KingDavid403
King David

Planet Earth.

Joined
19 May 05
Moves
175601
Clock
13 Oct 22
2 edits

@mike69 said
Five boys and one daughter with my youngest son passing shortly after birth. I find your words hard to believe if true seeing your children grow within and out of the womb and still hold these beliefs literally until they come out.
I find your words hard to believe
I think you may be reading into what I have written by things other pro-choice people have stated over time. I personally find the abortion laws in Russia the best (I hate to say); "abortion is legal in Russia up to three months of a pregnancy; or for medical conditions after that.
However, it is none of my business what a woman chooses; and, I think they should always have their rights to choose. Especially with such a delicate PERSONAL matter. 🙂

mike69

Joined
20 May 16
Moves
41711
Clock
13 Oct 22

@kingdavid403 said
I find your words hard to believe if true seeing your children grow within and out of the womb and still hold these beliefs literally until they come out.
It's called reality.
Sorry to hear about your son passing.
It’s your reality, I see very little logic in your words.

KingDavid403
King David

Planet Earth.

Joined
19 May 05
Moves
175601
Clock
13 Oct 22
1 edit

@mike69 said
It’s your reality, I see very little logic in your words.
Ditto. If you ever get pregnant (God forbid), don't have an abortion. That's your CHOICE. 🙂

mike69

Joined
20 May 16
Moves
41711
Clock
13 Oct 22

@kingdavid403 said
Ditto. If you ever get pregnant (God forbid), don't have an abortion. That's your CHOICE. 🙂
So your reality is termination up until birth. Would you think this woman would be in her right mind, regardless of legal or not?

KingDavid403
King David

Planet Earth.

Joined
19 May 05
Moves
175601
Clock
13 Oct 22
1 edit

@mike69 said
So your reality is termination up until birth. Would you think this woman would be in her right mind, regardless of legal or not?
So your reality is termination up until birth.
For medical reasons, yes.
Would you think this woman would be in her right mind, regardless of legal or not?
The reality is: no women or woman is doing that. If you can point to one instance of this happening please share. Until then, this is a fallacy. And, it is illegal in the USA in all states.

mike69

Joined
20 May 16
Moves
41711
Clock
13 Oct 22

@kingdavid403 said
So your reality is termination up until birth.
For medical reasons, yes.
Would you think this woman would be in her right mind, regardless of legal or not?
The reality is: no women or woman is doing that. If you can point to one instance of this happening please share. Until then, this is a fallacy.
7 months then, did I miss understand it being a delicate PERSONAL matter up to the mother.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.