General
24 Feb 08
Originally posted by AThousandYoungThere's no sentence outside the quotation marks, so the full stop after the quotation marks doesn't make sense. It's different if you have a quote "within a sentence".
OK. I don't know if Shav was actually quoting something.
"That doesn't make any sense.".
No, that kinda looks funny.
No matter how you do it it looks wrong to me. Oh well.
Originally posted by NordlysMy intuition tells me that periods should be a clean end to a sentence, that's all. That's why this issue feels so awkward to me.
There's no sentence outside the quotation marks, so the full stop after the quotation marks doesn't make sense. It's different if you have a quote "within a sentence".
However I believe I am capable of writing in a technically correct way. I just find this part of that technical correctness awkward.
Originally posted by AThousandYoungNo it doesn't.
Exactly. I cannot stand that. The period is supposed to end the sentence, but then there's that little dangly endquote invading the space of the next sentence.
"This is what is meant". That just feels better. It makes sense. It's more aesthetically pleasing.
Why on earth would the full stop be outside the quote???
Originally posted by AThousandYoungIt's only a full stop when it ends a sentence.
Why is it called a "full stop" if the sentence doesn't stop fully but continues on after the "full stop"?
When you're quoting something, then what you're quoting gets the full stop, unless it's part of a larger sentence...
Originally posted by shavixmirWhat if the quote IS part of a larger sentence?
It's only a full stop when it ends a sentence.
When you're quoting something, then what you're quoting gets the full stop, unless it's part of a larger sentence...
For example, you wrote "It's only a full stop when it ends a sentence." How come the sentence doesn't end at the period? There's a natural dividor in the period, but to the right of that natural dividor (is it -er or -or?) there's a symbol that applies to the sentence to the left of the period. 😠