Go back
union or league, or even football?!?

union or league, or even football?!?

General

willatkins
Frustrated...

Pittsburgh, PA, USA

Joined
22 Jul 02
Moves
63635
Clock
08 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by genius
which is the best: rugby league, rugby union (yay!) or american football? i'd say union. why? well, bacause it's much more flowing and nicer to watch/play. with league and football, the game is stopped every few seconds/minutes-but not with union! i can't really talk about football-but with league it's just some big blokes runnging at other big blokes wit ...[text shortened]... ere are more breakaways/kicks (there's less risk in kicking with union)...so-which is better?!?
What is the difference between league and union?

If you are looking for smashmouth, bone crunching action, rugby is where it is at. But, American football, by spreading the players apart, allows for more skill and individualism. But, that is my opinion.

g
Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined
12 Mar 02
Moves
15128
Clock
08 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

scotland are playing the US at union soon, so you might get too se that on your TV. as for the differences between league and union, league only has 13 players, and when your tackled you must roll the ball between your feet. with union, there are 15 players, and when your tackled 8 of them start shoving and pushing and basically fighting over the ball above you...πŸ˜›

Acolyte
Now With Added BA

Loughborough

Joined
04 Jul 02
Moves
3790
Clock
08 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

If the following are true, could someone explain to me why:

1. In American football each side needs about three whole teams, depending on which side has the ball and if it's a special play or not;

2. An American football game takes about 3 hours for an hour's play?

r
CHAOS GHOST!!!

Elsewhere

Joined
29 Nov 02
Moves
17317
Clock
08 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acolyte
If the following are true, could someone explain to me why:

1. In American football each side needs about three whole teams, depending on which side has the ball and if it's a special play or not;

2. An American football game takes about 3 hours for an hour's play?
1. Ever been in an American corporate office? The petty specialization helps weekend warriors identify with the game they watch while huddled over their chips (crisps to you) and beer.

2. It's actually a relativistic effect. Time dilates around massive bodies, and two teams of 20-stone barbarians easily fit the bill. They only experience 1 hour πŸ˜›.

C
Not Aleister

Control room

Joined
17 Apr 02
Moves
91813
Clock
09 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by genius
props (2/3rds of the front row) are usually fat slobs who are just there for the weight-or at least in scotland west division B they are...πŸ˜›
Must be only like that in Scotland... If you saw Richard Bands hit a gap and score a beauty in the Tri Nations, or Matt Dunning (sic?) from NSW almost run away from the opponent flankers in the Super 12, you'll change your mind.

BTW, I like league because it's a bit quicker (but if you like running rugga, watch 7's) but Union just has that little something extra, because there is more structure and tactics involved...

g
Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined
12 Mar 02
Moves
15128
Clock
10 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Crowley
Must be only like that in Scotland... If you saw Richard Bands hit a gap and score a beauty in the Tri Nations, or Matt Dunning (sic?) from NSW almost run away from the opponent flankers in the Super 12, you'll change your mind.

BTW, I like league because it's a bit quicker (but if you like running rugga, watch 7's) but Union just has that little something extra, because there is more structure and tactics involved...
it is usually with club rugby, i think. but with professional? well...:p but yeah-7's is much better than union. although it's torture to play 😞

CP

Asheville, N.C. USA

Joined
03 Sep 03
Moves
28378
Clock
10 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Dr. Brain
Welcome coach.Hope you are going to have a blast.I am a union man.League seems boring to me.(Awaiting a fierce attack from Dylan)Grid Iron is Greek to me.I have no clue as to what happens there.I have heard that union will never take off in the US as the game is too short and does not allow for enough ad breaks.Pity really.

As far as Australian Rules go ...[text shortened]... s and why does the guy behind the posts use his hands to indicate the size of his... erm anyway.
Thanks! πŸ™‚

Mat Kelley

all at sea

Joined
21 Apr 03
Moves
67920
Clock
11 Sep 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

I thinkthe game which is better is often going to be the one that one understands best. Explaing the intricies of what goes on in the front row (union as league scrumes are pointless) or indeed at the bottom of a ruck. Being one of the fat boys I find hard fought forward contests as good to watch as the free flrowing stuff. Anyway Union is best league can be exciting if decent teams are playing and Gridiron a bit girlie - by the was the heavy blokes running 40yds in sub 5 sec have to take oxygen afterwards don't theyπŸ˜€

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.