Go back
yet another scandal.

yet another scandal.

General

n

Who could tell?

Joined
05 Feb 03
Moves
826
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

NHS organ harvesting scandal has moved to new depths, with the discovery of thousands of stolen brains.

while i understand the problem with stealing the brains from dead people, i was wondering, whats wrong with harvesting organs from dead people for research/transplantation?

U

Steelers Country

Joined
12 Apr 02
Moves
32833
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nktwild
....whats wrong with harvesting organs from dead people for research/transplantation?
Nothing is wrong with it, its not like the dead people need it anymore,
what I cant see is why some people dont whant to give there organs away when they die (if posible)

kirksey957
Outkast

With White Women

Joined
31 Jul 01
Moves
91452
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

OK< i understand kidneys, hearts, livers, but why would you steal a brain? Kirk

n

Who could tell?

Joined
05 Feb 03
Moves
826
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

its normaly the family members who put up the protests, if the patient has a (UK) doner card(sp?) then the organs belong to the NHS after death, if no doner card is present then the docs have to ask the family members for the internals. the image of butchery fills their minds they panic and get all protective over a decomposing corpse.

i would like to see organ harvesting compulsery after death, they could do a lot of good.

n

Who could tell?

Joined
05 Feb 03
Moves
826
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kirksey957
OK< i understand kidneys, hearts, livers, but why would you steal a brain? Kirk
research into the brain.

kirksey957
Outkast

With White Women

Joined
31 Jul 01
Moves
91452
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nktwild
its normaly the family members who put up the protests, if the patient has a (UK) doner card(sp?) then the organs belong to the NHS after death, if no doner card is present then the docs have to ask the family members for the internals. the image of butchery fills their minds they panic and get all protective over a decomposing corpse.

i would like to see organ harvesting compulsery after death, they could do a lot of good.
I would like to see cremation being compulsory after death and the cremains used to fill potholes. That could do a lot of good. $924 poorer to pothole damage😠 Kirk

U

Steelers Country

Joined
12 Apr 02
Moves
32833
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

I agree with organ harvesting being compulsery, but not cremation.
and if your going to do the pot-hole thing why not use the bones?😉
the ashs wouldnt be enouf to fill a pot-hole even though its the whole body it loses mass when its burned. (I could tell the pothole thing was a joke)

kirksey957
Outkast

With White Women

Joined
31 Jul 01
Moves
91452
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Trust me, when I got the bill for damages from the pothole, I wasn't laughing. I think cremains would fill more evenly than just the bones. Kirk

L

Joined
08 Mar 03
Moves
13753
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kirksey957
OK< i understand kidneys, hearts, livers, but why would you steal a brain? Kirk
Because alot of people have been infected with CJD, and the goverment staticians need a reasonable sample to determine just how much damage was done by mad cow...

Acolyte
Now With Added BA

Loughborough

Joined
04 Jul 02
Moves
3790
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nktwild
its normaly the family members who put up the protests, if the patient has a (UK) doner card(sp?) then the organs belong to the NHS after death, if no doner card is present then the docs have to ask the family members for the internals. the image of butchery fills their minds they panic and get all protective over a decomposing corpse.

i would like to see organ harvesting compulsery after death, they could do a lot of good.
Don't make it compulsory; some people have religious objections. Make it so that you have to fill in a form to opt out, and you'll see donor rates go through the roof. Many people aren't donors only because they haven't bothered to say they are. Similarly, many non-Christians will get a Christian funeral if they haven't specified otherwise, because that's the 'default' option.

N

Joined
10 Apr 03
Moves
181
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

i would prefer to give my organs up for use when i die, i can understand why people would not like to and religion does come into it, so you cannot make it compulsary.

i myself do not beleive in religion, i find it hard to beleive that there is anything after life.


what do others think.

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acolyte
Don't make it compulsory; some people have religious objections. Make it so that you have to fill in a form to opt out, and you'll see donor rates go through the roof. Many people aren't donors only because they haven't bothered to say they are. Similarly, many non-Christians will get a Christian funeral if they haven't specified otherwise, because that's the 'default' option.
That's why most muslims won't get a decent tissue match when they need an organ transplant (of course, that's assuming they are not 'caucasian' muslims) - because not enough of them donate.

s
Member of Gonzo Clan

Innsbruck, Austria

Joined
11 Dec 01
Moves
37411
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

In Austria you have a opt out option ... If you have religious or other reasons do not give your organs after death, you have to hand in a form and your organs won't be removed ...

I won't hand in my form - because I believe when I am dead my body shall help other people who may need it (although I believe my lungs won't be used again)

S
BentnevolentDictater

x10,y45,z-88,t3.1415

Joined
26 Jan 03
Moves
1644
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kirksey957
OK< i understand kidneys, hearts, livers, but why would you steal a brain? Kirk
Theroy Number one...

It was a dark and stormy night! Suddenly Igor tripped into the back side of Young Dr. Frankenstein! &quot;Sorry&quot; he uttered as the good doctor moans in pain beside the open grave. Mary Shelly turns in the dark and says &quot;Igor! If you don't start watching where you step, i'll leave you here to rot! This is my plot, after all!&quot; &lt;nice pun there&gt;


😞😵

Theory number two...

They sell them to schools for the thousands of students who are required to do the Anatomy and Physiolology(sp?) thing to become nurses and doctors.

ChessNut
Lightly Salted...

Joined
18 Jul 01
Moves
36979
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Theory # 3: Anyone seen the movie Hannibal? 😉

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.