02 Jan 10
The post that was quoted here has been removedYou can parrot the party line all you want, but people who are concerned about cheating on this site have been exposing cheats in the forums since before you were even a member. And if they hadn't been, we wouldn't even have had a Game Mod system.
If Russ and Chris NOW don't want to listen to the concerns of the non-cheating community, that's up to them. I'm hardly the only one dissatisfied with the "Fair Play Ticket" system and many suggestions for detecting and punishing cheats have been made in the Forums, but lately they have all been ignored as far as anyone can tell.
02 Jan 10
The post that was quoted here has been removedIf Russ and Chris don't want non-subscribers posting, then they should make that rule. Your personal attacks are tiresome.
Naming names in the forums in the past has led to quite a few bannings. You'd know this if you had ever took any interest in the debates regarding cheat detection and punishment.
- Joined
- 12 Nov 05
- Moves
- 145614
02 Jan 10
My concern is what if a player is named and they are actually not a cheater? What then? This can open a huge can of worms, all it takes is for one person to walk on and say ".......... uses an engine"
As for suggestions for improving detection can someone link to a thread please (i cant see any from recently maybe i'm looking in the wrong place)
02 Jan 10
Originally posted by Silverstrikermost of the better players can smell engine moves miles away anyway, and usually a quick look at a suspects game(s) will quickly tell whether there are any grounds for the suspicion. the cheaters are mostly known already.
My concern is what if a player is named and they are actually not a cheater? What then? This can open a huge can of worms, all it takes is for one person to walk on and say ".......... uses an engine"
As for suggestions for improving detection can someone link to a thread please (i cant see any from recently maybe i'm looking in the wrong place)
and a certain amount of accusations are to be expected anyway for every high rated player, it comes with the territory when the game is played over internet and you can't actually see the other guy. when it's baseless, it's all pretty easy to just shrug off.
I'm sure all higher rated players would swap the 'policy of silence' with getting rid of the blatant offenders in a heartbeat.
02 Jan 10
Originally posted by wormwoodWhen the Game Mod system was in effect, when we knew who the Game Mods were and could contact them and we had the list of banned players and could see that cheaters were being regularly banned, there was a lot less public accusation and/or insinuation. There were still too many cheats , but at least there was an observable reality that something was being done.
most of the better players can smell engine moves miles away anyway, and usually a quick look at a suspects game(s) will quickly tell whether there are any grounds for the suspicion. the cheaters are mostly known already.
and a certain amount of accusations are to be expected anyway for every high rated player, it comes with the territory when the game i ...[text shortened]... uld swap the 'policy of silence' with getting rid of the blatant offenders in a heartbeat.
With the secret system now in place, what players see is that some very obvious cheaters are rapidly rising up the player tables. Of course that is going to lead to dissatisfaction with the "system" (such as it is).