Go back
Clan Elo Rating Suggestion

Clan Elo Rating Suggestion

Site Ideas

roma45
st johnstone

Joined
14 Nov 09
Moves
427957
Clock
27 Mar 17

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Perhaps the alternative of having to deal with dim, vulgar, unreasoning airheads like you is not as appealing as one would think. 😵
I don't cheat
I don't lie
Thank God I am not like you

JG

Joined
21 Jan 11
Moves
72604
Clock
28 Mar 17
Vote Up
Vote Down

You can modify the ELO-Ranking. For every inactive day you loose ELO-Points. also you can make other ruloes for loosing points.

padger

Here

Joined
31 May 06
Moves
416756
Clock
28 Mar 17

It doesn't matter how much you dress ELO up it will not work for a group
It was designed for individuals nothing else

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by padger
It doesn't matter how much you dress ELO up it will not work for a group
It was designed for individuals nothing else
Epic fail. It can and it will.

roma45
st johnstone

Joined
14 Nov 09
Moves
427957
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Epic fail. It can and it will.
It won't stop you colluding
All it will do is put the final nail in the clan coffin
That's what you really want

roma45
st johnstone

Joined
14 Nov 09
Moves
427957
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by Johannes Goethe
You can modify the ELO-Ranking. For every inactive day you loose ELO-Points. also you can make other ruloes for loosing points.
It will not stop robbie continuing to use collusion

padger

Here

Joined
31 May 06
Moves
416756
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Epic fail. It can and it will.
It can't and it won't

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Mar 17
3 edits

Originally posted by roma45
It won't stop you colluding
All it will do is put the final nail in the clan coffin
That's what you really want
Russ already explained to you why there will be no intensives. You were too dim to grasp it and you are still too dim to grasp it. Furthermore neither you nor anyone else has managed to produce a single game where the outcome was decided beforehand, no not a single one and yet you keep on harping on about your imaginary rules and imaginary punishments for your imaginary rules. Get a grip you ultra spangle, ELO is happening and it will make for a much more level playing field, you simply cannot handle the fact that your heroes the saggy baggsters will have no more challenges to dump at the end of the year and no more games to throw when the challenge is already won.

We still need to stop the likes of Maghoober55 using tournaments to lower his rating though. Its amazing how fortuitous the dips in his rating are. Along comes a 2100 rated player to beat him up just when he needs it and down comes his rating.

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Mar 17
1 edit

Originally posted by padger
It can't and it won't
Yes and you are a world war one flying ace the flew with the Red Barron. 🙄

roma45
st johnstone

Joined
14 Nov 09
Moves
427957
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Russ already explained to you why there will be no intensives. You were too dim to grasp it and you are still too dim to grasp it. Furthermore neither you nor anyone else has managed to produce a single game where the outcome was decided beforehand, no not a single one and yet you keep on harping on about your imaginary rules and imaginary punishme ...[text shortened]... Along comes a 2100 rated player to beat him up just when he needs it and down comes his rating.
No one on here has shown how the Elo system will stop collusion
Russ saying it would be much use is not stopping it you can easily manipulate the new system because you are a cheat
Points must be removed suspensions must be handed out

Have a look at relegation boy mctayto if you want to see a sandbagger
You are dimmer than the light your wife uses to look at you

roma45
st johnstone

Joined
14 Nov 09
Moves
427957
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Yes and you are a world war one flying ace the flew with the Red Barron. 🙄
You are a cheat and an idiot a lying fake

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Mar 17
3 edits

Here is a challenge chosen at random. Metallica vs Tolkien Clan Clan challenge 287174

Here is the position as it stands,

Metallica won 4 games Tolkien clan won 3
Metallica get 8 Gross Points and Tolkien clan get 0
Difference is 8 Net Points for Metallica and -8 for Tolkien

I think we can agree that this does not accurately reflect the play. Tolkien only lost the challenge by a single game and yet they get zero points. Metallica the much stronger clan get all the points. Under the ELO system we get the following

Clan Rating after challenge
1419 (Metallica) 1179 (Tolkien)
Previous rating
1418 (Metallica) 1180 (Tolkien)
Difference
1 (Metallica) -1 (Tolkien)

This is what we would expect when a much stronger clan beats up on a clan that was much weaker.

Now I cite this for all those people that have FAILED to understand why collusion would no longer be viable because instead of getting all the points as it stands at present the stronger clan only gets a measly point. The difference between the Easy Riders and say a clan like Anti-Metallica is even greater than the difference between a clan like Metallica and the Tolkien clan and the incentives for beating up on such a clan are nil. I hope that those who have stated that the ELO system does not prevent collusion will be able to grasp this and refrain from making ill informed assertions about a system they have not taken the time to understand. It may not stop collusion but it most certainly stops any rewards for doing so.

The new ELO system is brilliant because it will force clan leaders to make much fairer challenges and to play clans that are as strong as they are instead of beating up on weaker rated clans all the time.

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Mar 17
1 edit

Originally posted by roma45
You are a cheat and an idiot a lying fake
Please try to refrain from projecting your ignorance, you are too dim and too lazy to understand the system. All we get is the same lame drivel, you are a cheat and a liar and the system will not stop collusion. My goodness you are a not just a donkey, you are a repetitive, dull, dimwitted, boorish churlish ill mannered donkey.

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Mar 17
1 edit

Originally posted by roma45
No one on here has shown how the Elo system will stop collusion
Russ saying it would be much use is not stopping it you can easily manipulate the new system because you are a cheat
Points must be removed suspensions must be handed out

Have a look at relegation boy mctayto if you want to see a sandbagger
You are dimmer than the light your wife uses to look at you
Please shut up and read the above post, how many times does it need to be explained to you? Your silly punitive suggestions are nothing more than a reflection of your inability to grasp the system.

roma45
st johnstone

Joined
14 Nov 09
Moves
427957
Clock
28 Mar 17

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Please shut up and read the above post, how many times does it need to be explained to you? Your silly punitive suggestions are nothing more than a reflection of your inability to grasp the system.
Perhaps I might understand better if you showed challenges between easy riders and the three columns clans that's breaking bad arrow and anti Metallica

No amnesty
No forgiveness
No mercy

Just roll back and suspensions

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.