Go back
Forum moderation

Forum moderation

Site Ideas

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120597
Clock
21 Jan 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by yavash
i decided to take a look at clan forum - a posting / rant by a moderator was sexist in nature

i highlighted the fact it was sexist and (i presume it was a guy) he deleted my complaint!! he deleted it!!

oooo the power of the delete button
You must mean the bit where he referred to posters bitching on about trivialities as "little girls".

y
lovin the sea breeze

Up North!

Joined
21 Mar 07
Moves
99892
Clock
21 Jan 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
You must mean the bit where he referred to posters bitching on about trivialities as "little girls".
yes completely - not only was it sexist, it was size-ist and ageist - i am an older bigger girl AND i cry!!

also i know some big men that cry and talk trivial bitchy stuff too.

he just doesnt understand diversity! nevermind....

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120597
Clock
21 Jan 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by yavash
yes completely - not only was it sexist, it was size-ist and ageist - i am an older bigger girl AND i cry!!

also i know some big men that cry and talk trivial bitchy stuff too.

he just doesnt understand diversity! nevermind....
Don't you think picking that comment out of the contrast of all the stuff that flies back and forth in the Clans forum is a bit like picking straw out of cow poo and complaining that it's too dry? I.e. completely missing the point and the bigger picture.

Very Rusty
Treat Everyone Equal

Halifax, Nova Scotia

Joined
04 Oct 06
Moves
639949
Clock
22 Jan 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SwissGambit
Yeah, that's why it took you a month and a half to resurrect this thread. 🙄
Are you in need of eye glasses?

Look again and you'll find I did not resurrect this thread. 😛

y
lovin the sea breeze

Up North!

Joined
21 Mar 07
Moves
99892
Clock
22 Jan 13
1 edit

Originally posted by divegeester
Don't you think picking that comment out of the contrast of all the stuff that flies back and forth in the Clans forum is a bit like picking straw out of cow poo and complaining that it's too dry? I.e. completely missing the point and the bigger picture.
my point was about moderation and the moderators ability to encourage fair comments. If the moderator has no idea about diversity and equality and is in fact themselves saying statements that are sexist etc - how can they be expected to moderate appropriately and effectively?

people have been complaining about unfair and oppressive moderation. i am not 'blaming' the moderators as such, i think there should be a level of training and guidance and a transparent system.

i have had threads deleted for stating this, which indicates to me an air of defensiveness and inability to reflect on the part of the moderators. its a fair comment and not rude in any way

it may be a straw in poo to you but to me, this point just highlights the issue regarding inappropriate moderation.

cheers

Kewpie
Felis Australis

Australia

Joined
20 Jan 09
Moves
390174
Clock
23 Jan 13
1 edit

For heavens sake, this is a website for playing games on, and we're all anonymous. The volunteers are also anonymous, after all they're playing on the site too. Why the big lawsuit deal over what words are used in a moderator post? They have off days just like any other player on the site, their "moderator" posts just don't happen to have a handy alert button. Get over it!

y
lovin the sea breeze

Up North!

Joined
21 Mar 07
Moves
99892
Clock
23 Jan 13

Originally posted by Kewpie
For heavens sake, this is a website for playing games on, and we're all anonymous. The volunteers are also anonymous, after all they're playing on the site too. Why the big lawsuit deal over what words are used in a moderator post? They have off days just like any other player on the site, their "moderator" posts just don't happen to have a handy alert button. Get over it!
calm down... it's only a forum where people leave comments! get over it 🙂 x

Very Rusty
Treat Everyone Equal

Halifax, Nova Scotia

Joined
04 Oct 06
Moves
639949
Clock
23 Jan 13
3 edits

Originally posted by Kewpie
For heavens sake, this is a website for playing games on, and we're all anonymous. The volunteers are also anonymous, after all they're playing on the site too. Why the big lawsuit deal over what words are used in a moderator post? They have off days just like any other player on the site, their "moderator" posts just don't happen to have a handy alert button. Get over it!
I have to correct you here: 😛 😉 😉

We are not all anonymous...Do you forget Phlabby's BBQ'S that people from this site went to. They are all known to each other now. 😉

Also, there have been meets in the past that people have been to also.

Moderators should always be careful with their words, as they set the example for the rest. If their going to call names, it would be kind of hypocritical to remove posts with name calling wouldn't it?

Very Rusty
Treat Everyone Equal

Halifax, Nova Scotia

Joined
04 Oct 06
Moves
639949
Clock
23 Jan 13

Originally posted by yavash
calm down... it's only a forum where people leave comments! get over it 🙂 x
😀

I bet they hate it when you throw it back at them like that! 😉

patrickrutgers
Pale Yellow Star!

Minneapolis

Joined
29 Sep 08
Moves
38345
Clock
23 Jan 13
1 edit

Originally posted by Kewpie
For heavens sake, this is a website for playing games on, and we're all anonymous. The volunteers are also anonymous, after all they're playing on the site too. Why the big lawsuit deal over what words are used in a moderator post? They have off days just like any other player on the site, their "moderator" posts just don't happen to have a handy alert button. Get over it!
That one does have an alert button, and it's been used.

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
12 Nov 05
Moves
145614
Clock
30 Jan 13

Originally posted by Kewpie
For heavens sake, this is a website for playing games on, and we're all anonymous. The volunteers are also anonymous, after all they're playing on the site too. Why the big lawsuit deal over what words are used in a moderator post? They have off days just like any other player on the site, their "moderator" posts just don't happen to have a handy alert button. Get over it!
You can actually alert a moderator post 🙂 (as long as you are a subscriber)

Suzianne
Misfit Queen

Isle of Misfit Toys

Joined
08 Aug 03
Moves
37388
Clock
18 Mar 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by yavash
i have to say that i had a very bad experience from a moderator in the clan forum. he threatened to withdraw my membership. i was not being rude or oppressive in my comments in the forum and was only making a statement of what i believed to be true. when i sent him the RHP constitution regarding the right to speech and that i wasnt being rude, he stopped thre ...[text shortened]... apart especially when threatening my membership to RHP

i am glad others have picked up on it
There is a "RHP constitution regarding the right to speech"?

Where? I wouldn't mind taking a look at that...

d
His Mateship

Glowing in the dark

Joined
30 Apr 05
Moves
118683
Clock
18 Mar 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Very Rusty
I have to correct you here: 😛 😉 😉

We are not all anonymous...Do you forget Phlabby's BBQ'S that people from this site went to. They are all known to each other now. 😉

Also, there have been meets in the past that people have been to also.

Moderators should always be careful with their words, as they set the example for the rest. If thei ...[text shortened]... o call names, it would be kind of hypocritical to remove posts with name calling wouldn't it?
YES!

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.