10 Jan 08
If you're reading this, you may already be aware that you don't have to submit a move when you resign. But it seems like a lot of people don't know this. They want to resign so they make some pointless move at the same time, maybe because you have to press the 'Submit move' button so it seems logical that you would have to make a move.
My suggestion is simply to put a note about this somewhere so that more people are aware of it. For example, in the confirmation popup that says "Resigning will award the game to your opponent", etc. just add a note that says "You can resign without making a move on the board."
10 Jan 08
2 edits
Originally posted by incandenzaI'm not sure, but I believe that if you move while resigning the move is NOT recorded.
If you're reading this, you may already be aware that you don't have to submit a move when you resign. But it seems like a lot of people don't know this. They want to resign so they make some pointless move at the same time, maybe because you have to press the 'Submit move' button so it seems logical that you would have to make a move.
My suggestion t", etc. just add a note that says "You can resign without making a move on the board."
I don't have a game to test this with... But I always make a very stupid/funny move while resigning and it isn't recorded if I remember right.
P-
The move is not recorded, as in this instance I moved Rxg6 before resigning.
Game 3417730
10 Jan 08
Originally posted by incandenzaIt never occurred to me to make a move when resigning, but it doesn't make any difference whether you make a move or not, so I don't really see the problem. What I think would be more useful is a note somewhere that you can resign a game even when it's not your move, which is another thing many people don't seem to know.
If you're reading this, you may already be aware that you don't have to submit a move when you resign. But it seems like a lot of people don't know this. They want to resign so they make some pointless move at the same time, maybe because you have to press the 'Submit move' button so it seems logical that you would have to make a move.
My suggestion ...[text shortened]... t", etc. just add a note that says "You can resign without making a move on the board."
10 Jan 08
Originally posted by PhlabibitHmm, that's strange. Seems to contradict my experience, where at least half the time I see a silly move come across at the same time as the resignation.
I'm not sure, but I believe that if you move while resigning the move is NOT recorded.
10 Jan 08
Originally posted by NordlysWell, it just looks strange in the final game notation that the opponent resigned when it wasn't their move. Also, I would kind of like the record to only include "real" moves. e.g., if you blundered and then figured it out and resigned because of it, that's one thing, but if you're just submitting a dumb move because maybe you think it's mandatory, then I'd rather leave that out of the notation.
It never occurred to me to make a move when resigning, but it doesn't make any difference whether you make a move or not, so I don't really see the problem. What I think would be more useful is a note somewhere that you can resign a game even when it's not your move, which is another thing many people don't seem to know.
10 Jan 08
Originally posted by incandenzaI agree that's stupid. I wasn't aware this was happening (and apparently it isn't always happening).
Well, it just looks strange in the final game notation that the opponent resigned when it wasn't their move. Also, I would kind of like the record to only include "real" moves. e.g., if you blundered and then figured it out and resigned because of it, that's one thing, but if you're just submitting a dumb move because maybe you think it's mandatory, then I'd rather leave that out of the notation.
11 Jan 08
Originally posted by incandenzaPlease give a link to some games where the person who resigned made the last move. I clicked around finding about 6 games and all of them ended with the winner's move.
Hmm, that's strange. Seems to contradict my experience, where at least half the time I see a silly move come across at the same time as the resignation.
P-
11 Jan 08
Originally posted by PhlabibitHere are the three most recent I have seen:
Please give a link to some games where the person who resigned made the last move. I clicked around finding about 6 games and all of them ended with the winner's move.
P-
Game 3988121
Game 3988122
Game 4312765
On these, the 'Last move' time on the summary page is the exact same time as the time of the last move in the game log, which makes me think the move was submitted along with the resignation.
With a normal resignation, the 'Last move' time in the summary is different than the time of the last move in the game log (since it's the time the resignation, by itself, was made).
11 Jan 08
Originally posted by incandenzaComing to think of it, could it be that those are cases where your opponent made a stupid move, then realised it and resigned before you got a chance to move?
Hmm, that's strange. Seems to contradict my experience, where at least half the time I see a silly move come across at the same time as the resignation.
11 Jan 08
1 edit
Originally posted by NordlysI suppose it's technically possible, but the timestamp on the resignation (which is the 'Last move' time on the summary page) is the same as the time of the last move, which means they would have had to do that within the same minute, which doesn't seem likely.
Coming to think of it, could it be that those are cases where your opponent made a stupid move, then realised it and resigned before you got a chance to move?
EDIT: In fact, look at the whole history of the player 'jarno1974'. It looks like he always makes a move when he resigns. This is the kind of player the message I suggested would be aimed at, just in case they don't know they don't have to do that.
11 Jan 08
Originally posted by incandenzaIt could also be that if you resign before your opponent moves, the "last move" time shown is still the time of the last move.
I suppose it's technically possible, but the timestamp on the resignation (which is the 'Last move' time on the summary page) is the same as the time of the last move, which means they would have had to do that within the same minute, which doesn't seem likely.
I should try to lose some games soon, so that I can experiment a bit...
11 Jan 08
Originally posted by NordlysActually I know that is not the case, because I do have one game where I resigned in the way you say--thought I made a blunder and decided to resign without waiting for the opponent to move. The timestamps are in fact different.
It could also be that if you resign before your opponent moves, the "last move" time shown is still the time of the last move.