09 Dec 17
Originally posted by @wolfgang59Nobody wants to be killed. Is it always wrong to kill?
Nobody wants to be raped.
Therefore it is wrong.
Pretty simple really - I don't need a book to tell me its wrong.
Do you?
09 Dec 17
Originally posted by @wolfgang59Would you therefore regard “do unto others as you would have them do unto you” as a moral absolute?
yes
Originally posted by @dj2beckerno
Would you therefore regard “do unto others as you would have them do unto you” as a moral absolute?
Originally posted by @dj2beckerPlease show that “Nobody wants to be killed” is true and its relevance to the claim that killing is always wrong.
Nobody wants to be killed. Is it always wrong to kill?
Originally posted by @wolfgang59No self defense exception?
yes
How about a right to die for terminally ill patients?
Originally posted by @bigdoggproblemMy short answers are aimed at dj2beckers intellect!
No self defense exception?
How about a right to die for terminally ill patients?
1. Self defence ... from a logical, moral perspective I feel it is still difficult to justify.
(Why should my life be worth more than my attackers?) but on practical grounds no, killing can be justified.
2. I would always support the right of everyone to euthanasia.
Originally posted by @wolfgang59I see you have no problem contradicting yourself at every turn. Superior intellect and all.
My short answers are aimed at dj2beckers intellect!
1. Self defence ... from a logical, moral perspective I feel it is still difficult to justify.
(Why should my life be worth more than my attackers?) but on practical grounds no, killing can be justified.
2. I would always support the right of everyone to euthanasia.
Originally posted by @wolfgang59It just seems like a trite 'yes', when there are obvious exceptions, gives your debate opponent ammo to use against you. (How hard is it to add "In general, yes", which allows for exceptions?)
My short answers are aimed at dj2beckers intellect!
1. Self defence ... from a logical, moral perspective I feel it is still difficult to justify.
(Why should my life be worth more than my attackers?) but on practical grounds no, killing can be justified.
2. I would always support the right of everyone to euthanasia.
As for self defense, a person who lives in peace with others has a strong claim of value of their own life versus a person who initiates aggression and force against others.
Originally posted by @dj2beckerI've met him a few times. Pretty sure he was mentally challenged.
... in reality Christianity is founded upon a relationship between the person and the Lord Jesus Christ...
Originally posted by @dj2beckerIf you want to interpret my shorthand answers as contradictions then go for it.
I see you have no problem contradicting yourself at every turn. Superior intellect and all.
Whatever makes you happy.
Originally posted by @bigdoggproblemHardish, but not very hard. Harder than "not hard at all".
(How hard is it to add "In general, yes", which allows for exceptions?)
Originally posted by @wolfgang59How? If defending yourself is corrupt, I guess helping you wife or kids or parents or neighbors or friends not get abused must be even worse.
...
1. Self defence ... from a logical, moral perspective I feel it is still difficult to justify. ...