Muslim Murdered by Hindus for Allegedly Eating Beef in India

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I provided evidence which is damn more than you have. Look I am interested in evidence, if you ever manage to produce any let me know, ill be happy to consider it and go away happy that I have learned something.

You need evidence of violence and abuse in marriages in India and its prevalence? Surely you are kidding, robbie?

Originally posted by FMF
But why do you need evidence of the high rate of domestic violence in India? Haven't you already conceded that it is high?

I do not need evidence of domestic violence in India. I have not called for evidence of domestic violence in India. What I have actually called for is evidence that its a significant contributing factor in India's low divorce rate.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
What I have actually called for is evidence that its a significant contributing factor in India's low divorce rate.

But I have not claimed anything of the sort. Why do you require evidence from me of something I have not claimed?

Originally posted by FMF
But I have not claimed anything of the sort. Why do you require evidence from me of something I have not claimed?

you do not believe there is any correlation between domestic violence and low divorce rates in India? then your previous statement citing domestic violence and low divorce makes NO SENSE. Perhaps you can explain why you cited it?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
you do not believe there is any correlation between domestic violence and low divorce rates in India?

I have said exactly nothing about the divorce rate being low because of the prevalence of violence. You are attempting to attribute it to me. You are pretending that it is my point. But it is not. I quite simply did not say it. You have absolutely no reason to keep harping on about it as if I did.

Originally posted by FMF
I have said exactly nothing about the divorce rate being low because of the prevalence of violence. You are attempting to attribute it to me. You are pretending that it is my point. But it is not. I quite simply did not say it. You have absolutely no reason to keep harping on about it as if I did.

Then what is your point?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
then your previous statement citing domestic violence and low divorce makes NO SENSE.

What I have said does make sense. Pretending that I said something different and then saying THAT doesn't mistake is just you clowning. Talk about this issue seriously, come on, robbie.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Then what is your point?

As I wrote before, I am saying that low divorce rates ~ this statistical fact that you lionize ~ disguise the horror of marriage in India, except that they don't disguise it - because the phenomenon is well known - it is just ideologues like you who seek to disguise or distract from the horror: why else would you praise these low divorce rates? Why else would you praise 'Indian marriage' as an examplar?

Originally posted by FMF
What I have said does make sense. Pretending that I said something different and then saying THAT doesn't mistake is just you clowning. Talk about this issue seriously, come on, robbie.

It makes no sense unless you are attempting to draw some kind of significance between low divorce rates and domestic violence.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
It makes no sense unless you are attempting to draw some kind of significance between low divorce rates and domestic violence.

You are attempting to claim that I said something I didn't. I am talking about domestic violence. And I am talking about the divorce rate. Please address what I am saying.

Originally posted by FMF
As I write before, I am saying that low divorce rates ~ this statistical fact that you lionize ~ disguise the horror of marriage in India, except that they don't disguise it - because the phenomenon is well known - it is just ideologues like you who seek to disguise or distract from the horror: why else would you praise these low divorce rates? Why else would you praise 'Indian marriage' as an examplar?

Low divorce rates disguise the horror of marriage in India? I have provided reasons why i think that the divorce rate is low, you may make reference to those, none of which seek to disguise anything.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Low divorce rates disguise the horror of marriage in India?

Yes. Absolutely. Surely you agree?

Originally posted by FMF
You are attempting to claim that I said something I didn't. I am talking about domestic violence. And I am talking about the divorce rate. Please address what I am saying.

On the contrary you seem to think that low divorce is because of the prevalence of violence. That is the impression that you are giving.

Originally posted by FMF
Yes. Absolutely. Surely you agree?

No i have already cited the reasons why I think divorce is low in India, these are religious, moral and cultural reasons.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
On the contrary you seem to think that low divorce is because of the prevalence of violence. That is the impression that you are giving.

Then go back and read again. Pretending-to-miss-the-point is one of your least funny routines, robbie.