What would you give up?

Originally posted by stellspalfie
not accurate? whats not accurate? you are presuming a lot. i never said she was disciplined in any j.w. official sense. i am aware my use of the phrase 'kicked-out' could be taken wrong.

your claims that nobody is ever treated rudely or unkind on any level show how deluded you are when it comes to your church. there is unkindness in all walks of lif ...[text shortened]... ted are higher than an elder getting members to knock on specific doors to increase the flock.

taken wrong, its a piece of nonsense that you made up as you have the majority of your text, look at this latest, tell the forum how often you have attended a meeting of Jehovahs witnesses so that you have knowledge of whether or not you are treated rudely, that is correct, you have no experience.

Furthermore, the person that you mention was not an elder in fact he was never in a position of responsibility , but you don't know that because you have not taken the time to ascertain the details, look stellspalfie, i tell you this for your own good, unless you do, you will be roasty toasty every single time, because insinuations, half baked assertions, inaccuracy of any kind will be pounced upon and shredded!

she was ostracised for what ? arguing with elders decisions? what decisions and try to be precise this time.

Originally posted by stellspalfie
and do you know what went on at my mothers friends hall. or are you just saying what should happen and then guessing thats what did happen and anything else must be a lie?? looks like you are speculating with out knowing the facts. so before you start bitching about other people having the complete picture you may do well to heed your own advice.

your mothers friends hall? I don't mean to be rude but you sound like a first class
sweetie wife gossiping away! pssst 😛

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
your mothers friends hall? I don't mean to be rude but you sound like a first class
sweetie wife gossiping away! pssst

whats a sweetie wife?

why do you feel its gossip?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
your mothers friends hall? I don't mean to be rude but you sound like a first class
sweetie wife gossiping away! pssst 😛

so are you still saying its impossible for these things to happen in jw church?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
taken wrong, its a piece of nonsense that you made up as you have the majority of your text, look at this latest, tell the forum how often you have attended a meeting of Jehovahs witnesses so that you have knowledge of whether or not you are treated rudely, that is correct, you have no experience.

Furthermore, the person that you mention was not ...[text shortened]... ised for what ? arguing with elders decisions? what decisions and try to be precise this time.

Furthermore, the person that you mention was not an elder in fact he was never in a position of responsibility

Does a 'ministerial servant' not have a position of responsibility?

Originally posted by Proper Knob
[b]Furthermore, the person that you mention was not an elder in fact he was never in a position of responsibility

Does a 'ministerial servant' not have a position of responsibility?[/b]

no he makes no decisions, he shows people to their seats, works the sound system, hands out slips of paper.

Originally posted by stellspalfie
whats a sweetie wife?

why do you feel its gossip?

a sweetie wife, lol, you dont know?

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_does_sweetie_wife_mean

Originally posted by stellspalfie
so are you still saying its impossible for these things to happen in jw church?

what things, you have provided no details?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
no he makes no decisions, he shows people to their seats, works the sound system, hands out slips of paper.

It isn't a matter of whether 'he makes decisions', it's a matter of whether he was in a position of responsibility. Does a 'ministerial servant' have responsibilities within the congregation?

Originally posted by Proper Knob
It isn't a matter of whether 'he makes decisions', it's a matter of whether he was in a position of responsibility. Does a 'ministerial servant' have responsibilities within the congregation?

lol, if you think showing people to their seats is a position of responsibility, yes. and yes it does matter, for he is not qualified to have any influence within the congregation.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
what things, you have provided no details?

what things? you were happy to say it wouldnt happen earlier. now you need details.....after i pointed out you didnt have the details.

so to clarify your position now is - you couldnt comment on the truthfulness of my story as you are unaware of the facts.

my what a very sensible mature approach robbie.

Originally posted by stellspalfie
what things? you were happy to say it wouldnt happen earlier. now you need details.....after i pointed out you didnt have the details.

so to clarify your position now is - you couldnt comment on the truthfulness of my story as you are unaware of the facts.

my what a very sensible mature approach robbie.

i have only been a witness for eighteen years and you how many? just sayin

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
i have only been a witness for eighteen years and you how many? just sayin

I have been a Witness for 50 years and have never once seen it happen or heard of it happen.

Originally posted by galveston75
I have been a Witness for 50 years and have never once seen it happen or heard of it happen.

heard what happen? what do you think happened?

how many times have you seen children molested in your 50years?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
i have only been a witness for eighteen years and you how many? just sayin

what? im not sure what you are saying now. are you and galv doing the j.w equivalent of measuring your penis's? he's got 50 to your 18, i guess that makes him the erm...big j.w. around here.