13 Nov 06
Originally posted by mtthwIt was only 4 runs
Yep, the only umpire with the balls to do so after it was proved his action is legal. The only umpire to call a side for cheating without evidence. His problem is his ego - once he's made up his mind nothing else matters - evidence, the game of cricket, etc.
14 Nov 06
Originally posted by mtthwBut he does cheat. He chucks. They changed the rules twice for him.
It's not really, though, is it? For a start it's 4 runs and a further charge from the ICC, which would result in a suspension if upheld. But it's also a declaration that you're a cheat.
Ridiculous situation where the game of cricket is held hostage by a group of nations.
14 Nov 06
Originally posted by lordhighgusThere I was talking about the ball tampering.
But he does cheat. He chucks. They changed the rules twice for him.
Ridiculous situation where the game of cricket is held hostage by a group of nations.
But as for Murali - they changed the rules when it was proved that almost everybody chucked. He didn't chuck more than anybody else. It just looks stranger because of his unusual wrist.
This is one of those circumstances where I'll go with the biometric experts who have spent large amounts of time and effort investigating, rather than the random fan who watches it on telly.
14 Nov 06
Trescothick heading home:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/cricket/england/6146688.stm
They're never very clear on what the bloke is suffering from but maybe it's along the lines of manic depression? Anyhoo it paves the way for Ali Cook to show the Aussie's what he's capable of, and also the great fielder Collingwood, who is usually good for a few runs too.
14 Nov 06
Originally posted by ElleEffSeeeI think is good news for England.
Trescothick heading home:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/cricket/england/6146688.stm
They're never very clear on what the bloke is suffering from but maybe it's along the lines of manic depression? Anyhoo it paves the way for Ali Cook to show the Aussie's what he's capable of, and also the great fielder Collingwood, who is usually good for a few runs too.
I just wish they would play Reid instead of Jones as wickie. Even Matty Prior is better than Jones.
14 Nov 06
Originally posted by mtthwWell if he hadn't cheated he wouldn't have got caught 😛
It's not really, though, is it? For a start it's 4 runs and a further charge from the ICC, which would result in a suspension if upheld. But it's also a declaration that you're a cheat.
15 Nov 06
Originally posted by invigorateI agree. When you are on tour you need a settled batting line up and Trescothick was the fly in the ointment. Cook, Bell and Collingwood need to be able to just play cricket and not have to worry whether the axe is hanging over them.
I think is good news for England.
15 Nov 06
Originally posted by Ian68Someone called Joyce from Middlesex is being added to the squad.
I agree. When you are on tour you need a settled batting line up and Trescothick was the fly in the ointment. Cook, Bell and Collingwood need to be able to just play cricket and not have to worry whether the axe is hanging over them.
21 Nov 06
Originally posted by ElleEffSeeeI have it on good authority from someone inside sport that he is an alcoholic.
Trescothick heading home:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/cricket/england/6146688.stm
They're never very clear on what the bloke is suffering from but maybe it's along the lines of manic depression? Anyhoo it paves the way for Ali Cook to show the Aussie's what he's capable of, and also the great fielder Collingwood, who is usually good for a few runs too.
Clearly he got stressed because he couldn't get any good bitter down under!
21 Nov 06
Originally posted by howardgeeIts bad luck for the bloke and i hope he gets well soon.
I have it on good authority from someone inside sport that he is an alcoholic.
Clearly he got stressed because he couldn't get any good bitter down under!
Am really looking forward to some great games this Ashes. Bring it on!