Go back
The Best Quarterback in the NFL

The Best Quarterback in the NFL

Sports

m

Joined
03 Aug 06
Moves
1116
Clock
02 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

according to most of the important stats peyton is the best QB out there brady has been clutch in the past but so has manning he just never won the big one.If i had to play the numbers I'd go with the numbers.i also believe that if you put manning on the patriots they would never lose

E

Joined
06 Jul 06
Moves
2926
Clock
02 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by maverick28
according to most of the important stats peyton is the best QB out there brady has been clutch in the past but so has manning he just never won the big one.If i had to play the numbers I'd go with the numbers.i also believe that if you put manning on the patriots they would never lose
at the beginning of the season i wouldve asked to have manning on the cowboys, now we dont need him.

NS
blunderer of pawns

Rhode (not an)Island

Joined
17 Apr 04
Moves
24785
Clock
03 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ramned
I never said Bulger threw more balls.
I was showing how few more he's thrown. not a big difference
"Nope. www.nfl.com/stats - you'll find just how many more balls Brady has thrown."

Those are your exact words; I didn't edit them. By the way, the argument about Holt being double-covered: He's still their leading receiver for the year, and was their leading receiver in 6 of their 11 games. The other times, it was either Bruce or one of your two running backs. You're supposed to be a fan of this team; are you even watching the games this year?

R
The Rams

Joined
04 Sep 06
Moves
13491
Clock
03 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Natural Science
"Nope. www.nfl.com/stats - you'll find just how many more balls Brady has thrown."

Those are your exact words; I didn't edit them. By the way, the argument about Holt being double-covered: He's still their leading receiver for the year, and was their leading receiver in 6 of their 11 games. The other times, it was either Bruce or one of your tw ...[text shortened]... cks. You're supposed to be a fan of this team; are you even watching the games this year?
😠
How dare you accuse me?? I have watched their games, and their replays, and, in alot of them, Holt is being double covered. Heh, it goes to show how good Torry is, catching, and how good Bulger is when he throws to him when he is db. covered.
😠

NS
blunderer of pawns

Rhode (not an)Island

Joined
17 Apr 04
Moves
24785
Clock
03 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ramned
😠
How dare you accuse me?? I have watched their games, and their replays, and, in alot of them, Holt is being double covered. Heh, it goes to show how good Torry is, catching, and how good Bulger is when he throws to him when he is db. covered.
😠
Oh dear, I triggered the mean smiley. 🙂

I brought Holt and Bruce into the conversation to contrast the receivers Bulger is throwing to, with the receivers Brady is throwing to. You're right, I could have also mentioned tight end Ben Watson. I also could have mentioned that 55-year old guy they've got running around on both offense and defense.

Anyway, point is, if you knew Holt was their leading receiver anyway, why bring up the fact that he's double-covered in the first place? A lot of teams' top receivers get double-covered.

R
The Rams

Joined
04 Sep 06
Moves
13491
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

21-0, Dolphins, over TOm BRady and the Patriots. I say, Tom Brady is not the best.

J

Joined
26 Jan 06
Moves
2645
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
at the beginning of the season i wouldve asked to have manning on the cowboys, now we dont need him.
Sure, that's why you got creamed by the Saints in Dallas! ROFLMAO

J

Joined
26 Jan 06
Moves
2645
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

You guys might call me crazy but I don't care, I don't neccessarily think Vince Young is the best right now! But the things he is doing for the Titans right now shows alot of promise for what the future has in store!

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
11 Dec 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

The last season someone besides Marc Bulger started at QB for the Rams, they went to the Super Bowl. And their defense wasn't much better than it is now. Also, Warner's numbers in that system were far better than Bulger's. Bulger is a middle of the pack QB.

P
Mystic Meg

tinyurl.com/3sbbwd4

Joined
27 Mar 03
Moves
17242
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ramned
21-0, Dolphins, over TOm BRady and the Patriots. I say, Tom Brady is not the best.
This is because one day can prove everything, right?

Pht.

P-

P
Banned from edits

Grammar dyslexic

Joined
20 May 05
Moves
11372
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Phlabibit
This is because one day can prove everything, right?

Pht.

P-
-1 points for him, I'm glad he was on my opponents roster this week 😛

My reasoning on why Brady is not great:

People say Marino can't be considered great because he didn't win the big one, thats crap.

So I say that winning the big one doesn't make you great

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
Clock
11 Dec 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PocketKings
So I say that winning the big one doesn't make you great
What about winning the big one three times and being the MVP twice?

EDIT - Or what about 10 straight postseason wins?

P
Banned from edits

Grammar dyslexic

Joined
20 May 05
Moves
11372
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darvlay
What about winning the big one three times and being the MVP twice?

EDIT - Or what about 10 straight postseason wins?
he had a great kicker? 😛 I don't like him anyway

J

Joined
26 Jan 06
Moves
2645
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PocketKings
he had a great kicker? 😛 I don't like him anyway
That is true, if you look at their superbowl victories, they were all decided by like a field goal!

R
The Rams

Joined
04 Sep 06
Moves
13491
Clock
11 Dec 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Phlabibit
This is because one day can prove everything, right?

Pht.

P-
no, this week, and the last. He through for less than 100 yards this week. Last week, he almost lost to the LIONS. If it weren't for Corey Dillon rushing for 3 TDS...2 weeks struggling straight. More to come.

LUCK WITH ST. LOUIS TONIGHT. BEAT CHICAGO!

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.