Go back
Final Israeli Question

Final Israeli Question

Debates

MLK

Bournemouth UK

Joined
18 Jun 04
Moves
66392
Clock
23 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Being American I think if we just nuke both places this solves all the world arguements about this.

I know this is just a stupid comment, but until people (both sides) really want peace and sit down and talk about it nothing going to happen.

I never thought I would see in my life time; Nelson Mandela walk free or East and West Germany reunite. Even in Northen Ireland they are now talking and not bombing. Maybe not enough! But they are at least talking.

F

Unknown Territories

Joined
05 Dec 05
Moves
20408
Clock
23 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ICU2
I keep seeing posts about being pro and anti Israel. I find many things you say unaccurate but I'm too lazy to post on each thread.

So...tell me, what do you think Israel is doing wrong? (One at a time, One at a time).
They are both accused of being too lazy to listen to each others' point of view. Further, they claim those who are too lazy to inquire of others' pov's should be put to death.

Now... what was it you were asking?

huckleberryhound
Devout Agnostic.

DZ-015

Joined
12 Oct 05
Moves
42584
Clock
23 Nov 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ICU2
I keep seeing posts about being pro and anti Israel. I find many things you say unaccurate but I'm too lazy to post on each thread.

So...tell me, what do you think Israel is doing wrong? (One at a time, One at a time).
Might i suggest destabalising a pro-western Lebanese government would not've been one of your finest hours ?

o
Paralysed analyst

On a ship of fools

Joined
26 May 04
Moves
25780
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ICU2
True, but what is the solution? I mean, Israel and the Phalestines can't choose not to react to an attack.
Actually, they could choose. You just mean you don't think it's the right choice.

In my view, the main thing Israel is doing wrong is OVER-reacting. The idea of 'proportionate response' seems to have disappeared as politicians try to outdo each other with promises about what they're going to do to smash Hamas or Hezbollah or whoever.

The recent fighting in Lebanon was a good example. Israel could easily have mounted an operation to rescue the captured soldiers that involved tracking down where they were and mounting an assault on a particular building or 'compound'. They have the military expertise to do that. That scenario might have killed 20 or 50 Hezbollah members at most.

But instead, what we got was widespread destruction, many more deaths, and a MUCH larger slice of the Lebanese population that have a reason to detest Israel. It's not only disproportionate, it's completely counter-productive.

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by orfeo
Actually, they could choose. You just mean you don't think it's the right choice.

In my view, the main thing Israel is doing wrong is OVER-reacting. The idea of 'proportionate response' seems to have disappeared as politicians try to outdo each other with promises about what they're going to do to smash Hamas or Hezbollah or whoever.

The recent fightin ...[text shortened]... to detest Israel. It's not only disproportionate, it's completely counter-productive.
'Completely counter-productive' seems to me to sums up the Israeli strategy in a nutshell.

But there are 576 Israeli players on this website. Why can't we hear from them what they think they are doing wrong or doing right? Why don't they comment on their government's actions in public?

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

An article about a process to settle the historical facts on the Arab-Israeli conflict(s). Historians to the rescue!

http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/11/23/opinion/edryback.php?page=1

huckleberryhound
Devout Agnostic.

DZ-015

Joined
12 Oct 05
Moves
42584
Clock
24 Nov 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by spruce112358
'Completely counter-productive' seems to me to sums up the Israeli strategy in a nutshell.

But there are 576 Israeli players on this website. Why can't we hear from them what they think they are doing wrong or doing right? Why don't they comment on their government's actions in public?
I would suggest that the past trend of racist and anti-religious (notice i didn't say anti-semitic) tripe throwing that seemed to go on any time a question about the area came up, does not make for a welcoming enviroment for anyone, let alone an Israeli, to come on the forum and give their opinion now.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89791
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by huckleberryhound
I would suggest that the past trend of racist and anti-religious (notice i didn't say anti-semitic) tripe throwing that seemed to go on any time a question about the area came up, does not make for a welcoming enviroment for anyone, let alone an Israeli, to come on the forum and give their opinion now.
We don't want fascist Israeli opinion.
We've got enough right-wing dumb F'cks and capitalist whores clogging up the fora as it is.

What they all need is good bitch slapping.
They deserve nothing less than what they've been given and they deserve a lot more than what's been handed out!

F'ck 'em. And f'ck 'em rightiously!

ii

Joined
06 Jul 06
Moves
1163
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
We don't want fascist Israeli opinion.
We've got enough right-wing dumb F'cks and capitalist whores clogging up the fora as it is.

What they all need is good bitch slapping.
They deserve nothing less than what they've been given and they deserve a lot more than what's been handed out!

F'ck 'em. And f'ck 'em rightiously!
LMFAO

x
Incroyant

tinyurl.com/ksdwu

Joined
22 Sep 04
Moves
4728
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
We don't want fascist Israeli opinion.
We've got enough right-wing dumb F'cks and capitalist whores clogging up the fora as it is.

What they all need is good bitch slapping.
They deserve nothing less than what they've been given and they deserve a lot more than what's been handed out!

F'ck 'em. And f'ck 'em rightiously!
lol...what they've been given is a country.

huckleberryhound
Devout Agnostic.

DZ-015

Joined
12 Oct 05
Moves
42584
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by xs
lol...what they've been given is a country.
And they deserve nothing less 😵, that's what Shav said .

ii

Joined
06 Jul 06
Moves
1163
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Shav said nothing of the sort.......

Niether you or the poster before you read it properly

huckleberryhound
Devout Agnostic.

DZ-015

Joined
12 Oct 05
Moves
42584
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iraqi insurgent
Shav said nothing of the sort.......

Niether you or the poster before you read it properly
The Irony is not lost on me.

Amaurote
No Name Maddox

County Doledrum

Joined
04 Feb 05
Moves
16156
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've hated them all ever since Dana International.

o
Paralysed analyst

On a ship of fools

Joined
26 May 04
Moves
25780
Clock
24 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
We don't want fascist Israeli opinion.
We've got enough right-wing dumb F'cks and capitalist whores clogging up the fora as it is.

What they all need is good bitch slapping.
They deserve nothing less than what they've been given and they deserve a lot more than what's been handed out!

F'ck 'em. And f'ck 'em rightiously!
Okay, right there, you assumed (even for the sake of humour) that all the Israelis on this sight would be fascist, right-wing or whatever. It's quite clear that at least some Israelis AREN'T happy with their government's policies. Like any country, there will be a range of views.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.