Go back
Lying to the public should be a criminal offense

Lying to the public should be a criminal offense

Debates

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
03 May 19
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@philokalia said
Here's the thing...

There are lies, and then there are ... things that people call lies which are not blatantly lies.

Here's a classic lie:

Lie: "Boss, I'm sick. I can't come to work today."
Reality: I've called in sick on a Friday to go to the beach for all of Friday & Saturday.

Here's another one:

Lie: I never kissed her.
[b]Rea ...[text shortened]... laim its misleading, like I suspect would be the end result of this for a lot of people... Then, no.
Don't play word games. Lies are deliberate acts to deceive. Barr *deliberately* mislead the public and lied to Congress. And he didn't lie about "kissing" or any of your nonsense; he lied about an investigation about collusion with a foreign government to undermine the election and obstruction of justice.

The OP:

"should lying to the public be a criminal offense if done by government officials regarding government matters?"

Philokalia

S. Korea

Joined
03 Jun 17
Moves
41191
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

If I interpret something so it is in my favor, am I lying? Of course not. It might feel like someone is "lying" when they are interpreting everything to benefit them, and they may be making bad arguments, and they may be "misleading" (one of the most subjective words in existence), but can you say they are lying?

There is no way to reliably employ a word like "misleading" without using bias, and so it is useless then claim "misleading" people is lying and expect that this can be used in a legal context without creating a spiderweb of problems.

I understand there is such a concept as lying by omission.

Is this an instance where he has told a lie by omission?

Just lay it out there for me.

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
03 May 19

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@philokalia said
If I interpret something so it is in my favor, am I lying? Of course not. It might feel like someone is "lying" when they are interpreting everything to benefit them, and they may be making bad arguments, and they may be "misleading" (one of the most subjective words in existence), but can you say they are lying?

There is no way to reliably employ a word like "misleadin ...[text shortened]... on.[/i]

Is this an instance where he has told a lie by omission?

Just lay it out there for me.
"Lies are deliberate acts to deceive."----Vivify

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
03 May 19
3 edits

The post that was quoted here has been removed
You phrased your hypothetical in a way that practically answers it's example question. Any public speaker with even a modicum of common sense can answer such questions in a much more general way. "We don't answer intelligence questions" or some some other generic responses are perfectly reasonable.

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
Clock
03 May 19
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
"Lies are deliberate acts to deceive."----Vivify
You mean like when Obama said if you like your present healthcare you can keep it.

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
03 May 19
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@eladar said
You mean like when Obama said if you like your present healthcare you can keep it.
Yes.
See that? That's called having the balls to be honest, something sackless Republicans lack.

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify
So you believe Obama should be in jail.

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@eladar said
@vivify
So you believe Obama should be in jail.
If you lie knowing it's a criminal offense to do so, yes. Trump's AG lied under oath, a criminal offense.

Government officials lying to the public should be one as well.

w

Joined
02 Jan 06
Moves
12857
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
With Barr now being caught in two separate lies (his misleading summary on the Mueller report and lying to Congress under oath about not knowing Mueller's complaint about Barr's summary), and a report showing that Trump lied over ten thousand times in office, should lying to the public be a criminal offense if done by government officials regarding government matters?

I do ...[text shortened]... isn't already a crime. Congress should introduce legislation making blatant lies a criminal offense.
I love it!

So the next politician that lies goes to jail.

LMAO!

w

Joined
02 Jan 06
Moves
12857
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@eladar said
@vivify
So you believe Obama should be in jail.
Like Hillary, Obama never lied.

You must be listening to that Fox news again.

Gursh durn it!

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

Mott The Hoople

Joined
05 Nov 06
Moves
147482
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
"Lies are deliberate acts to deceive."----Vivify
you keep saying Barr lied...can you state the lie(s)?

Mott The Hoople

Joined
05 Nov 06
Moves
147482
Clock
03 May 19
Vote Up
Vote Down

@whodey said
Like Hillary, Obama never lied.

You must be listening to that Fox news again.

Gursh durn it!
why would people not listen to the #1 news source in the entire country?

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
03 May 19

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.