Go back
The Juice: Did He Do It?

The Juice: Did He Do It?

Debates

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
246d

@averagejoe1 said
Yes. Who else would have done it?
I wonder how often the police try to 'gild the lily' by planting evidence to make someone they *know* is guilty look guiltier. The case in Wisconsin against Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey that was documented in "Making a Murderer" certainly raised that allegation.

Still, it's still hard to understand how 'the police framed him!' could be accepted as a reason to acquit without any evidence of that.

Almost like claiming, oh I don't know... like claiming 'the election was rigged!'

Without. Any. Evidence

Cliff Mashburn

Joined
09 Jan 22
Moves
1139
Clock
246d
2 edits

@suzianne said
Psychologically speaking, I believe that he was completely capable of the crime. He had the means, motive and opportunity. He probably did it, but a conviction requires evidence, and the prosecution failed on this step.
You obviously didn't follow the trial at all. The evidence was overwhelming.
He even admitted doing it in jail when talking to Rosie Greer but it was inadmissible since Greer was acting as a pastor and it was privileged information..

Fartacus

Joined
09 Sep 10
Moves
2501
Clock
246d

Like I said. People didn't want to admit he did it.

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
246d

@cliff-mashburn said
You obviously didn't follow the trial at all. The evidence was overwhelming.
He even admitted doing it in jail when talking to Rosie Greer but it was inadmissible since Greer was acting as a pastor and it was privileged information..
Maybe Rosey will tell us before he goes...

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
246d
Vote Up
Vote Down

'Local control' - highly touted by the right as a cure for almost everything - can become a nightmare...

The APM podcast "In the Dark" investigates the case of Curtis Flowers: "...a black man from Winona, Mississippi, who was tried six times for the same crime. Flowers spent more than 20 years fighting for his life while a white prosecutor spent that same time trying just as hard to execute him."

Flowers was released in 2019 after over 20 years on death row in Parchman prison.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
246d
1 edit

@cliff-mashburn said
You obviously didn't follow the trial at all. The evidence was overwhelming.
He even admitted doing it in jail when talking to Rosie Greer but it was inadmissible since Greer was acting as a pastor and it was privileged information..
The evidence was overwhelming even without Greer. They found his blood and her blood in the car and her blood on his gloves. All of this was confirmed with DNA identification. His bloody Bruno Magli shoeprints were found at the scene.

Of course he did it.

The defense argument was hardly even that he didn't do it. It was to tell the mostly black jury that the LAPD are a bunch of racist hooligans.

"Who is going to police the police? You can, with this verdict." - Johnny Cochran, during closing arguments.

And that's exactly what they did. They let OJ get away with murder to send a message to the LAPD.

Even the argument that this jury nullification was justified is a better argument than that he was innocent. There's zero chance he was innocent.

Fartacus

Joined
09 Sep 10
Moves
2501
Clock
246d

And that is why juries can't be trusted.

Cliff Mashburn

Joined
09 Jan 22
Moves
1139
Clock
246d

@fartacus said
And that is why juries can't be trusted.
Several jurors later said that they thought he did it, but fell back on "reasonable doubt" to let him off. I believe they were fearful of reprisals by OJ fans or blacks in general if they found him guilty...and rightfully so.

Cliff Mashburn

Joined
09 Jan 22
Moves
1139
Clock
246d

I remember the day of the verdict, spontaneous demonstrations erupted all over the country by blacks, delirious with joy. They drove around with their lights on and honking and waving at each other.
Soooo glad that OJ slaughtered two white people and got away with it.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
246d

@cliff-mashburn said
I remember the day of the verdict, spontaneous demonstrations erupted all over the country by blacks, delirious with joy. They drove around with their lights on and honking and waving at each other.
Soooo glad that OJ slaughtered two white people and got away with it.
I think it was more like a black guy finally beat the system that they felt was rigged against them and LAPD racists like Mark Fuhrman were finally exposed and punished.

But all that has nothing do with the OJ's guilt, which was clear and obvious to anyone with half a brain.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
246d

@cliff-mashburn said
Several jurors later said that they thought he did it, but fell back on "reasonable doubt" to let him off. I believe they were fearful of reprisals by OJ fans or blacks in general if they found him guilty...and rightfully so.
They're lying. They let him off to punish the LAPD. The judge and the prosecution let the trial devolve into a circus and a trial of the LAPD rather than of OJ Simpson. As Robert Shapiro later said, they played the race card from the bottom of the deck. And it was an Ace.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
245d

@fartacus said
And that is why juries can't be trusted.
Lol. You use an extremely unusual Hollywood celebrity trial to make blanket statements on the utility of peer evaluation of criminal evidence?

Juries are excellent overall. Way better than alternatives.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
245d

@sh76 said
The evidence was overwhelming even without Greer. They found his blood and her blood in the car and her blood on his gloves. All of this was confirmed with DNA identification. His bloody Bruno Magli shoeprints were found at the scene.

Of course he did it.

The defense argument was hardly even that he didn't do it. It was to tell the mostly black jury that the LAPD are a b ...[text shortened]... n was justified is a better argument than that he was innocent. There's zero chance he was innocent.
It's the same principle as any other criminal, white collar especially, walking free on a technicality.

Suzianne
Misfit Queen

Isle of Misfit Toys

Joined
08 Aug 03
Moves
37388
Clock
245d

Yes, white people are SOOOOOOOOOO persecuted.


🙄

Fartacus

Joined
09 Sep 10
Moves
2501
Clock
245d

@wildgrass said
It's the same principle as any other criminal, white collar especially, walking free on a technicality.
This idiot is comparing white collar crime to double homicide ⬆️ 🤣

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.