Go back
Tipping

Tipping

Debates

Mat Kelley

all at sea

Joined
21 Apr 03
Moves
67920
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I tip generously if the service and food is good - always cash never as an add on to a credit card.

However if service is bad I am quite prepared to leave nothing - I hate the fact that in the US I am expected to tip bad service - so I act the dumb English man and don't

Nemesio
Ursulakantor

Pittsburgh, PA

Joined
05 Mar 02
Moves
34824
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

To quote Vincent Antonelli a.k.a. Tod Wilkinson (Steve Martin) in My Blue Heaven:

"It's not tipping I believe in; it's over-tipping. That's my philosophy."

Nemesio

t
True X X Xian

The Lord's Army

Joined
18 Jul 04
Moves
8353
Clock
31 Aug 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I usually tip generously.

0% - if the service is offensively bad (Once a friend of mine and I were ignored for over an hour, even after we had approached our waiter three times! Actually, my friend still tipped him about 5%.)
10% - if the service bad.
15% - if the service is mediocre
20% - if service is good
25%+ - if I like you (for instance if you were to approach me)

Another tipping story. Back in my undergrad days, I spent a summer working as a waiter at Golden Corral (crappy buffet-style dining) for about a month. I can tell you who the worst tippers are.
Not the old people ("$Here's a couple of quarters deary. Go buy yourself something nice.)
Not foreigners (Most are pretty gracious actually.)

Answer is: Those damn big groups of fundie protestant xtians that come in on Sundays after church. Damn, they could put the food away! They were usually eeriely polite, like "Better show the boy Christ's love 'cause were gonna screw him in a bit." And when you got done, what was left on the table? A damn Chick track! I guess they thought the present discounted value of a mansion in heaven was worth about 10 bucks.

P
Mystic Meg

tinyurl.com/3sbbwd4

Joined
27 Mar 03
Moves
17242
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

My aunt to be works at a pub, 5 business men came in for dinner and drinks.

They spent about 2 hours, and had several drinks ordered. More than one person had to help serve the table.

They finally finished up, and the bill came to over $200. There on the table was a $5 tip.

So my aunt to be grabs the 5 bucks and runs out to the parking lot. They see her coming and roll the window down... perhaps thinking they forgot something?

She chucks the $5 into the window and says, ''You obviously need this more than I do if that was all you could afford to tip''.

They were stunned, embarrassed... and all reaching into their pockets to get more cash up. They ended up giving about $50 tip, and were full of sorrys and excuses saying they thought they left more.

P-

rwingett
Ming the Merciless

Royal Oak, MI

Joined
09 Sep 01
Moves
27626
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Phlabibit
My aunt to be works at a pub, 5 business men came in for dinner and drinks.

They spent about 2 hours, and had several drinks ordered. More than one person had to help serve the table.

They finally finished up, and the bill came to over $200. There on the table was a $5 tip.

So my aunt to be grabs the 5 bucks and runs out to the parking lot. The ...[text shortened]... ing about $50 tip, and were full of sorrys and excuses saying they thought they left more.

P-
This exactly underscores my point. A waitress shouldn't have depend upon the caprice of the customers for her living. They have a right to a standard, decent wage, the same as any other profession.

r

Over seas

Joined
20 Oct 01
Moves
14169
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rwingett
This exactly underscores my point. A waitress shouldn't have depend upon the caprice of the customers for her living. They have a right to a standard, decent wage, the same as any other profession.
I could argue this, because Not all but alot of people who depend on tips make pretty good money in a job that if a wage were offered, it would be pretty low I'm sure. And then you would have to pay taxes on it all, definetly.

There are places that I know waitresses are trying to get into because the tips are so good.

Mike

mwmiller
RHP Member No.16

Joined
25 Feb 01
Moves
104458
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Is the US the only country where tipping your barber is common?

I pay about an hour's wage for a 15 minute haircut. and add a tip. If the barber averages two customers per hour overall on a typical day, he is making twice as much as me. Why should I tip him? He ought to be tipping me....lol.

But then, if you don't leave a tip, your next haircut may be a little strange.😲

S

Joined
06 Aug 03
Moves
10020
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

If the service is good I tip, if not I don't. A tip is bonus not a right.

It gets me some very dirty looks, but people expecting a tip no matter what bug the hell out of me....

and yes i did bar/waiting work all through Uni... Tips were happily recieved but never expected by me....

c
Islamofascists Suck!

Macon, Georgia, CSA

Joined
17 Feb 02
Moves
32132
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mat Kelley
I tip generously if the service and food is good - always cash never as an add on to a credit card.

However if service is bad I am quite prepared to leave nothing - I hate the fact that in the US I am expected to tip bad service - so I act the dumb English man and don't
I don't expect you tip for bad service in the US, and whoever does is full of crap....😲

bbarr
Chief Justice

Center of Contention

Joined
14 Jun 02
Moves
17381
Clock
31 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I don't tip for poor service under normal circumstances, even though I've waited tables and tended bar. If, however, the place is really busy and the wait staff are too overworked to provide good service, then I'll still tip, as understaffing isn't the fault of the waitstaff. I tip even when the food is bad, because the wait staff has no control over food quality. In general, I assume I'm going to tip at least 20%, and then adjust according to the quality of service.

c
Islamofascists Suck!

Macon, Georgia, CSA

Joined
17 Feb 02
Moves
32132
Clock
01 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by bbarr
I don't tip for poor service under normal circumstances, even though I've waited tables and tended bar. If, however, the place is really busy and the wait staff are too overworked to provide good service, then I'll still tip, as understaffing isn't the fault of the waitstaff. I tip even when the food is bad, because the wait staff has no control over foo ...[text shortened]... I assume I'm going to tip at least 20%, and then adjust according to the quality of service.
That about reflects my tipping protocol...good advise..

o
Paralysed analyst

On a ship of fools

Joined
26 May 04
Moves
25780
Clock
01 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Australians are beginning to tip in restaurants, but I suspect our heart really isn't in it and it started because we have become aware that it's done in USA. Mostly it's more a case of leaving (some of) your change on the table as you leave. Or in a group setting, everyone puts in slightly extra rather than working out the bill to the exact cent, and if the leftover seems about right it'll be left as a tip.

However if I or my friends get particularly good service we will consciously include a tip. No idea whether it gets pooled or not.

We have laws about minimum wages here, and a strong union tradition. The wages that waiters and some other jobs get in America would cause an uproar because they're so low.

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
01 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

A few years ago, I'd never heard of tipping in the UK (OK, I don't go to London much where I suspect it's more common).
Now, it's starting to creep in.

But what's with the tipping for beers in bars in the US and Canada?
I'm in there trying to get drunk and having to remain compus mentis enough to think about providing a reasonable tip. It just puts a downer on the whole experience for me when you have to pay $5 for a beer, and then $1 tip or something. Every beer!
A friend of mine didn't have enough money so he only gave about 25c tip and the waiter came back and told hime it wasn't enough, open handed!
Another waiter gave me some crap story about how they need at least 50c tip because they have to rent the glasses, or something.

Acolyte
Now With Added BA

Loughborough

Joined
04 Jul 02
Moves
3790
Clock
01 Sep 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Varg
A friend of mine didn't have enough money so he only gave about 25c tip and the waiter came back and told hime it wasn't enough, open handed!
I think this is where tipping goes bad. If customers are forced to tip, then effectively it's just another surcharge, and it would be much more honest for the bar to increase its prices.

Tipping in bars is strange. Do Americans tip at McDonald's, or at the supermarket? Tending a bar isn't the same as waiting on a table. I worry that if the tipping culture spreads too far, people will start paying tips for business deals (as is traditional elsewhere in the world), and then you're heading into the shady world of corruption.

I had a somewhat different experience in a German pub. When people returned empty glasses/bottles to the bar to be reused, they were given a few pfennigs 'Pfand' (lit. 'pledge' in the sense of deposit).

turtlex
Picard Is My Captain

United States

Joined
21 Feb 03
Moves
244486
Clock
01 Sep 04
4 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sorry if this stirs the pot even more but ... my sister-in-law used to be a waitress and I use her as a guide as to what is fair.

To be clear - I'm with those who say that minimum wage should be applied across the table. That should be a waiters/ress minimum. Ideally - Tips should be in addition to a fair minimum wage.

Well, she (my sis-in-law) says this -
1) you tip based on service. it is NOT the servicepersons fault if the food is not good (unless they took down or ordered you the wrong thing).

2) if you've a problem with the food - say something and let the serviceperson try to fix it. thats part of their job.

3) you tip on the food/drink total - not the total after taxes are added.

4) if it's a buffet - then one dollar per person is sufficient for a tip as you were not served food, just (usually in the US) given beverages.

Its that last part about the buffet stuff that I don't always agree with, but that's her rule. (for instance, I think its not always enough)

Personally, I generally tip about 20%.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.