Go back
2012 RHP Prose Competition - VOTING THREAD

2012 RHP Prose Competition - VOTING THREAD

General

Great Big Stees

Joined
14 Mar 04
Moves
186301
Clock
16 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

This will take some time to read all the entries. I tried and by the time I got through the first 3 my computer screen went black. 😳

Kewpie
Felis Australis

Australia

Joined
20 Jan 09
Moves
390166
Clock
17 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

1st: #4 Kilcan
2nd: #7 The Tailor's Daughter
3rd: #1 Tick

Honourable mentions to the rest, didn't know we had so much creative talent at RHP! 🙂

C
Cowboy From Hell

American West

Joined
19 Apr 10
Moves
55013
Clock
17 Jul 12
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

#1. Entry 2
Beautiful

#2. Entry 6
Moving

#3. Entry 3
off beat

All entries were worth while reading IMO

l

Joined
10 May 07
Moves
10128
Clock
17 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

No 1: - 4 Kilcan

No 2: - 2 Hints of spring in the air

No 3: - 9 A winter's run

l

Joined
10 May 07
Moves
10128
Clock
17 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

I forgot to say they were all very good.

Great Big Stees

Joined
14 Mar 04
Moves
186301
Clock
17 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

1st- #9: A Winter's Run
2nd- #3: Hotel Anywhere
3rd- #4: Kilcan

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
18 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

Here are my top three:

First: #1 -- Tick

Second: #6 -- The Crawling Spring of Times

Third: #7 -- The Tailor's Daughter

And there really wasn't a whole lot to separate the remaining nine entries from the three I chose. Kudos to all of you.

b

Joined
18 Apr 06
Moves
2443
Clock
18 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

very hard to narrow it down to three but well done on organising this - if i get time i will make an entry for 2013

1st - A night on the rocks. Dramatic and i was hooked throughout

2nd - Tick - kept me engaged throughout

3rd - The Crossroads demon. Love supernatural stories 😀

I enjoyed the seasons stories too 🙂

orangutan
ook

hirsute rooster

Joined
13 Apr 05
Moves
20607
Clock
19 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

1st : Tick
2nd : Kilcan
3rd : A Winter's run

Good work all.

k
Flexible

The wrong side of 60

Joined
22 Dec 11
Moves
37304
Clock
19 Jul 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

1st Kilcan (made me wanna be a 'sell-sword'😉

2nd Tick (nice blend of bitter n sweet)

3rd Hints of spring in the air (ornate and accurate)

Looking forward to next year already.

Grampy Bobby
Boston Lad

USA

Joined
14 Jul 07
Moves
43012
Clock
22 Jul 12

Originally posted by Silverstriker

Hi readers

First of all thank you to all this years entrants, this thread will show the amount of talent we have this year 🙂

Please take a look through the entries and i would like everyone to pick their favourite three. If you wrote an entry you can't vote for your own entry. Please post your votes in this thread and the deadline for votes ...[text shortened]... u need to keep anonymous (i.e. dont say which entry is yours)

Happy reading

Silverstriker
Just one man's opinion, but I considered four things: 1) Is it inspired? 2) Does it reflect the artistic integrity of holding itself together? 3) Is it entertaining? 4) Is it respectful of the English Language. No particular weighting, only a sense that I've just experienced something unforgettable and would like to read more by (or have a few cold ones with) its author:

#12 (Whether a real or imagined place, I too would like to return to play at Margate).

#7 (Story within a story of love and loss... my how the ache and ark of it resonated).

#10 (No plot, nameless characters but such a vivid snapshot of a memorable day.)


Thanks to those who encouraged me to participate and to you, Striker, for an enjoyable, well managed competition.

gb

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
12 Nov 05
Moves
145614
Clock
22 Jul 12

1 week left to vote

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
23 Jul 12

Put a little culture in your life.

Read the entries.

Pick a winner.

Pick a second and third.

Give yourself a pat on the back.

Live long and prosper.

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
12 Nov 05
Moves
145614
Clock
23 Jul 12

why someone has been thumbing down some of the entries i don't know why

PATHETIC

still lots of time to vote 🙂

m
Ajarn

Wat?

Joined
16 Aug 05
Moves
76863
Clock
23 Jul 12

Originally posted by Silverstriker
why someone has been thumbing down some of the entries i don't know why

PATHETIC

still lots of time to vote 🙂
I'm sure the Mods could find out who has been thumbing down, and up, the odd entries. It would be courageous, and courteous also, for them to identify and make known this grumpy, cursed idiot.

Any comments from any Mods available about this?

Let the cruel participater be known amongst us, the Judas? What say ye 'Mods'?

-m.

It's an annual event..... why let a 'one' spoil it for many. We'd like to know who the idiot was. If you want to know the idiot - thumbs up this post!...if you don't, down it with a thumb.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.