Go back
Cat-skinning movie at Toronto festival

Cat-skinning movie at Toronto festival

General

S
Shut Gorohoviy!

Joined
19 May 03
Moves
14164
Clock
02 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Who cares about the movie?Go see it if you must.What would be intresting to know is how those kids have been dealt with!Surely they didn't get away with it,did they?

turtlex
Picard Is My Captain

United States

Joined
21 Feb 03
Moves
244486
Clock
02 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SirLoseALot
Who cares about the movie?Go see it if you must.What would be intresting to know is how those kids have been dealt with!Surely they didn't get away with it,did they?

Laughable, but the article says they got a "stern slap on the wrist", which is unbelievable.

r

Joined
08 Dec 03
Moves
3140
Clock
02 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

There is distinct difference between actors re-enacting an event and the actual depiction of cruelty. Did "Schindler's List" show actual footage of cruelty towards the prisoners?

-Ray.

turtlex
Picard Is My Captain

United States

Joined
21 Feb 03
Moves
244486
Clock
02 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rgoudie
There is distinct difference between actors re-enacting an event and the actual depiction of cruelty. Did "Schindler's List" show actual footage of cruelty towards the prisoners?

-Ray.

No, "Shindler's List" did not.

r

Joined
08 Dec 03
Moves
3140
Clock
02 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Here is an update. Apparently, the film does not show footage from the torture video.

http://www.cbc.ca/story/arts/national/2004/09/01/Arts/catkill040901.html

In light of this update, I request that this entire thread be deleted. My main issue was that the film depicted scenes from the video.

Thank you.

-Ray.

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
02 Sep 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Here is an update. Apparently, the film does not show footage from the torture video.
so basically you knew nothing about the movie and I knew nothing about the movie... seems we're both qualified to write a full length review for the Toronto Star. 😉

I don't think the thread should be deleted as it highlights the power of media (tabloid?) to incite hysteria and strong emotions among the masses through non-factual, non-researched editorial.

I guess Rondi Adamson should learn something from this as well...don't judge a book by the cover. Did she end up hating the movie, The Passion of the Christ, because she was expecting a porn flick?

D

pradtf

VeggieChess

Joined
03 Jun 02
Moves
7483
Clock
02 Sep 04
5 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by donallyne
I guess Rondi Adamson should learn something from this as well...don't judge a book by the cover.
i don't think it's as bad as that D.
adamson made her points quite well regarding the torture of the cat and people who made it an art form.

the move to boycott the movie was a good one. the flood of complaints was a good thing.
it may have forced that 2nd more explanatory article.
the organizers should perhaps have made things much clearer so that adamson didn't feel compelled to write the first article.

i agree with you in that media shouldn't be used to inspire hysterics, but when one is dealing with topics like these, it is up to the organizers to make things as clear as possible. otherwise, they can expect a justifiable torrent of protest.

what's in the book isn't going to prove to be that important, if people can't get passed the cover to begin with.

in friendship,
prad

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.