Go back
Columbus Day

Columbus Day

General

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
670027
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Happy holiday to all who observe it.

Question: Is the landing of Christof Columbus in the west Indies a good reason for celebrating?

j

Dublin Ireland

Joined
31 Oct 12
Moves
14235
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ponderable
Happy holiday to all who observe it.

Question: Is the landing of Christof Columbus in the west Indies a good reason for celebrating?
What do you think?

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
670027
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

I think yes Columbus performed a great deed with the journey.

But he did bring the aboriginal Indians only bad things.

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ponderable
I think yes Columbus performed a great deed with the journey.

But he did bring the aboriginal Indians only bad things.
He did bring the original inhabitants bad things, but his discovery changed the world.

Does the good outweigh the bad?

Suzianne
Misfit Queen

Isle of Misfit Toys

Joined
08 Aug 03
Moves
37388
Clock
14 Oct 13
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ponderable
I think yes Columbus performed a great deed with the journey.

But he did bring the aboriginal Indians only bad things.
If it wasn't him, it would have been someone else.

By then, almost everyone was aware that the world was not flat.

Native Americans are still paying for it today, though. But, yes, the handwriting was on the wall for them by then.

Suzianne
Misfit Queen

Isle of Misfit Toys

Joined
08 Aug 03
Moves
37388
Clock
14 Oct 13
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HandyAndy
He did bring the original inhabitants bad things, but his discovery changed the world.

Does the good outweigh the bad?
What if aliens from outer space came down here, colonized and then arrived in such huge numbers that it almost made us extinct, even though several alien races enjoyed technological improvements and a much improved standard of living here.

Would you still be asking if the good outweighs the bad?

JS357

Joined
29 Dec 08
Moves
6788
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ponderable
Happy holiday to all who observe it.

Question: Is the landing of Christof Columbus in the west Indies a good reason for celebrating?
You might as well ask, "Is the way the world works a good thing?"

m
Ajarn

Wat?

Joined
16 Aug 05
Moves
76863
Clock
14 Oct 13
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Suzianne
If it wasn't him, it would have been someone else.

By then, almost everyone was aware that the world was not flat.

Native Americans are still paying for it today, though. But, yes, the handwriting was on the wall for them by then.
Wut? The world isn't flat?

-m.

Well fact me, I thought RJ was still on a cross in the 'olden days'. Where is he, when I need him now, to prove the world is flat?

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
14 Oct 13
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Suzianne
Would you still be asking if the good outweighs the bad?
The question is Socratic, not a value judgment.

I'm not taking sides.. just framing the issue for discussion.

m
Ajarn

Wat?

Joined
16 Aug 05
Moves
76863
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HandyAndy
The question is Socratic, not a value judgment.

I'm not taking sides.. just framing the issue for discussion.
Socratestical sidelining?

-m. 😉

ale1552

rural North Dakota

Joined
31 Oct 07
Moves
95775
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HandyAndy
The question is Socratic, not a value judgment.

I'm not taking sides.. just framing the issue for discussion.
Of course the Vikings were here first. But they were farther north and did not open the New World to trade or exploration.

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by mikelom
Socratestical sidelining?

-m. 😉
Something like that.

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ale1552
Of course the Vikings were here first. But they were farther north and did not open the New World to trade or exploration.
And didn't overpower the natives.

j

Dublin Ireland

Joined
31 Oct 12
Moves
14235
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ale1552
Of course the Vikings were here first. But they were farther north and did not open the New World to trade or exploration.
When the Vikings came to Ireland,
they settled and had a positive influence.

caissad4
Child of the Novelty

San Antonio, Texas

Joined
08 Mar 04
Moves
618778
Clock
14 Oct 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ponderable
Happy holiday to all who observe it.
Question: Is the landing of Christof Columbus in the west Indies a good reason for celebrating?
For the plunderers, yes.
For the plundered, no.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.