Go back
Forum Mod Idea

Forum Mod Idea

General

S
Love gave me wings

Turfed Out

Joined
23 Jun 04
Moves
12608
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
Absolutely not!

What a heavy handed approach towards all non-subscribers, just because of one person.

Such draconian measures only serve to whip people up into frenzies. Like anti-terrorist laws, like wars on third world countries, etc. etc.

Tomorrow the mods will clean it up and it will be like a fart in the wind. Just ignore him.
If you think it is draconian to legislate against terrorism you are a fool. The world will never be ideal, stop dreaming start living
πŸ™‚

S
Love gave me wings

Turfed Out

Joined
23 Jun 04
Moves
12608
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by trawets113
I feel this is a very harsh approach as most non subscribers do not spam. Also i feel u r neglecting to take in to account tht some people may struggle to afford the fee. For example im a university student, and have limited funds as it is. But i enjoy playing chess. Once i leave uni i will definately subscribe when i have a job and am able to afford the subscription. But i still feel we have a right to our say.
I am glad that you enjoy chess, but why is it harsh, to make a non subscriber wait for a short while before they can see their posts in the forum? Surely my idea would, in the long run, make the forums better for genuine guests such as yourself

S
Love gave me wings

Turfed Out

Joined
23 Jun 04
Moves
12608
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ravello
My solution is always the same: DON'T ALLOW NON-SUBSCRIBERS TO POST IN FORUMS!

A subscriber fears the temporarly forum-ban or the subscription/account deletion;non subscribers simply don't care.
I agree with you as it happens, but was offering a compromise.

It is a shame the damage to the forums by troublemakers is at the bottom of Russ and Chris's priority list. Probably because non subscribers can be seen as a potential market, where as, WE have already parted with our money so our wishes are not important
πŸ™‚

N
The eyes of truth

elsewhere

Joined
26 Apr 04
Moves
21784
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SirUlrich
I agree with you as it happens, but was offering a compromise.

It is a shame the damage to the forums by troublemakers is at the bottom of Russ and Chris's priority list. Probably because non subscribers can be seen as a potential market, where as, WE have already parted with our money so our wishes are not important
πŸ™‚
This argument wold seem more feasible if it were a lifetime fee as it used to be. But since every year we become another subscription, and having a track record of paying the site previous subscriptions, I'd say we were slightly more inportant then a potential subscription.

I'm against the idea of banning non subscribers from the forums. Maybe a trial period where they could inly post after a couple moves were made in a game. Also I see no reason why they should'nt be able to post in the help or meet opponents threads. On that note I see no reason why a nonsubscriber would need to post in the clan forum, as they really have'nt much they could add to that conversation.

Nyxie

v

Newcastle upon tyne

Joined
06 Dec 04
Moves
1126
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Hey, I cant subscribe cause I am only 13 and my mam would not let me! 😠 so leave me alone. yes alot of non-subscribe post rubbish, but some of don't why say all of us when it is only a few! 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠

TSP
HIT THE LIGHTS

Joined
15 Nov 03
Moves
57135
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

g
Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined
12 Mar 02
Moves
15128
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by T1000
If memory servces, back in the dim and distant days, at one point on the old boards I seem to recall all posts made by people who hadn't made many posts had to be approved by a moderator before they displayed. Not saying it was a good way or anything - just raising it as a bit of nostalgia 😲
yup-that was the old way, and it got rather confusing if your post didn't appear immediatly...IMO, the current way is better as one night of madness every night in a while is better than consant boredom...

a

omnipresent

Joined
29 Oct 04
Moves
20009
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SirUlrich
Seeing the General Forum again filled with foul mouthed rubbish from a non subscriber, why not change the forum mods' guidelines.

All posts by subscribers to be treated exactly as they are now:
eg. . only looked at by mods after alerts are raised.

All posts by non-subscribers to be looked at by mods BEFORE they appear in the forums. This gives tho ...[text shortened]... heard, albeit on a slightly delayed basis.

If this needs more mods I for one will volunteer.
If I may make a slightly altered suggestion:
Why not do what you suggested, but only for non-subscribers below a certain number of recs? If someone gathers 10 recs, chances are high that he is not one of those rubbish posters. That way, it could be considered a trial period for non-subscribers.

lol I'm also there if more mods are needed...

Angie πŸ˜€

D

Toronto

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1617
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

how about a person can not post again untill after 1 minute. than it will be make the spammers tired to wait so long just to spam another thread, getting rid of all those pages of spam.

Ravello
The RudeΒ©

who knows?

Joined
30 Dec 03
Moves
176648
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SirUlrich
I agree with you as it happens, but was offering a compromise.

It is a shame the damage to the forums by troublemakers is at the bottom of Russ and Chris's priority list. Probably because non subscribers can be seen as a potential market, where as, WE have already parted with our money so our wishes are not important
πŸ™‚
I don't agree on this : admins have taken care in may ways about troublemaker and we can't hassle 'em at every guy who posts rubbish in forums.
It was created Robomod,more mods were recruited,the cheat police has been created,the over 13 age limit has been introduced: all we can say but not that Russ doesn't care about trouble makers.

On the issue of non-subs I have my opinion but Russ already made it clear in the past:non subscribers posting in forums are a good marketing for the site and Russ is first of all a business man,so don't expect him to take in consideration a vote about non-subs posting in forums.

tmetzler

Joined
03 Sep 03
Moves
87628
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DavidLynx
how about a person can not post again untill after 1 minute. than it will be make the spammers tired to wait so long just to spam another thread, getting rid of all those pages of spam.
I find it interesting that it was only a FEW MINUTES after YOU asked if somebody could be kicked off for spamming; that the spammer last night started up. Don't you find that interesting?

Note: when I mentioned this "coincidence" to the spammer. They said that they know you/play with you on IC. Sounds like the old brother/dad excuses used by certain now-banned players of the site.

I hate to accuse falsely, but I think that it is a pretty amazing coincidence...

--tmetzler

D

Toronto

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1617
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

πŸ˜› sorry, i had nothing to do with it...

a

omnipresent

Joined
29 Oct 04
Moves
20009
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DavidLynx
how about a person can not post again untill after 1 minute. than it will be make the spammers tired to wait so long just to spam another thread, getting rid of all those pages of spam.
considering the rubbish you wrote in other threads, you are not exactly improving the situation for non-subscribers.
How about a button under non-subscribers posts "shut this user up". It should either be that when you click it, that user can't post again for an hour, or when 10 people click the button that person get's a forum ban for 2 weeks... or forever... I don't care

Angie

g
Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined
12 Mar 02
Moves
15128
Clock
20 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

is it just me, or did he not come up with a good idea though? say, one post every 5 minutes or something?

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
20 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by genius
is it just me, or did he not come up with a good idea though? say, one post every 5 minutes or something?
just u.

D

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.