Go back
Gary Barlow or Robbie?

Gary Barlow or Robbie?

General

Torunn

Gothenburg

Joined
11 Mar 16
Moves
28312
Clock
25 Nov 23

@fmf said
Are there other opinions about him?

Yes, a lot of people think he's not as good as Robbie Williams, empirically speaking.
What is there to say against him, empirically speaking?

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
25 Nov 23

@torunn said
What is there to say against him, empirically speaking?
Well, what I had in mind was money.

Torunn

Gothenburg

Joined
11 Mar 16
Moves
28312
Clock
25 Nov 23

@fmf said
Well, what I had in mind was money.
What about it?

Ghost of a Duke

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
29602
Clock
25 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@torunn said
What is there to say against him, empirically speaking?
Not a fan myself of either, but as a group they were better than Westlife. 🙂

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
25 Nov 23
1 edit

@torunn said
What about it?
It was just a quip, Torunn, alluding to the fact that Williams has probably made three times more money and sold maybe twice as many albums as Barlow since leaving Take That. These are guestimates.

Torunn

Gothenburg

Joined
11 Mar 16
Moves
28312
Clock
25 Nov 23

@fmf said
It was just a quip, Torunn, alluding to the fact that Williams has probably made three times more money and sold maybe twice as many albums as Barlow since leaving Take That. These are guestimates.
I don't know much about Robbie but Gary seems to be an artist who has matured a lot since he left Take That.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
25 Nov 23

@torunn said
I don't know much about Robbie but Gary seems to be an artist who has matured a lot since he left Take That.
My better half tells me Gary Barlow is much more cleancut than Robbie Williams.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
25 Nov 23

@Torunn
Cards on the table, I have never knowingly known that I knew I was listening to a song by either artist, although I accept that I have probaby heard their music without realizing it.

The same goes for Take That. Their lifespan as a band, I see, was 1990–1996 which more or less corresponds to my time on the edge of the rainforest listening to dangdut and keronchong or living in rural Japan listening to bands like Blur and Radiohead.

mchill
Cryptic

Behind the scenes

Joined
27 Jun 16
Moves
3283
Clock
25 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@divegeester said
Who’s the best?

The fight goes on 💪🏼
The artistic temperament produces some great music, but also some crazy behavior. These 2 seem like a milder version of The Who's Pete Townsend and Roger Daltrey, those guys had some smash mouth fights on more than one occasion.

divegeester
watching

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120628
Clock
25 Nov 23

@mchill said
The artistic temperament produces some great music, but also some crazy behavior. These 2 seem like a milder version of The Who's Pete Townsend and Roger Daltrey, those guys had some smash mouth fights on more than one occasion.
I got to see Daltry perform in one of those “picnic in the park” type of events about 15 years ago; it was an excellent gig.

I also got to see Townsend much more briefly when I was driving behind him in his big pale green Mercedes about 20 years ago. Less of an experience to be honest and hardly even worthy of note.

Torunn

Gothenburg

Joined
11 Mar 16
Moves
28312
Clock
25 Nov 23

@fmf said
@Torunn
Cards on the table, I have never knowingly known that I knew I was listening to a song by either artist, although I accept that I have probaby heard their music without realizing it.

The same goes for Take That. Their lifespan as a band, I see, was 1990–1996 which more or less corresponds to my time on the edge of the rainforest listening to dangdut and keronchong or living in rural Japan listening to bands like Blur and Radiohead.
Gary Barlow



Music for an old lady. ❤️

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
26 Nov 23

@divegeester said
I also got to see Townsend much more briefly when I was driving behind him in his big pale green Mercedes about 20 years ago. Less of an experience to be honest and hardly even worthy of note.
Eric Morecombe wiggled his spectacles at me from the backseat of his chauffeur-driven Rolls Royce as he waited at the traffic lights near my school. A pretty big deal for me. I was eight years old.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
26 Nov 23

If it had been Ernie Wise, it would have been less momentous for me.

divegeester
watching

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120628
Clock
361d

Nomination for best thread and best post of 2023.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.