KASPAROV OR FISCHER, WHO WOULD WIN??

secretweapon

General

14 Nov 03

secretweapon

Joined: 05 Nov 03
Moves: 117

14 Nov 03

Just a survey. Who do you think would win if they were to play each other in their prime.

Phlabibit

Mystic Meg

tinyurl.com/3sbbwd4

Joined: 27 Mar 03
Moves: 17242

14 Nov 03

Originally posted by secretweapon
Just a survey. Who do you think would win if they were to play each other in their prime.

During one of the X3D matches they were saying Kasparov is probably the best ever... having gone GM at about 22, and holding the World Champ title for a full decade.

What was Fischer rated at his prime?

As a note, I don't like BF.... so that's my vote for Kasparov.

P

eddie anders

Santa.

The Mall.

Joined: 11 Jul 02
Moves: 66753

14 Nov 03

Originally posted by Phlabibit
During one of the X3D matches they were saying Kasparov is probably the best ever... having gone GM at about 22, and holding the World Champ title for a full decade.

What was Fischer rated at his prime?

As a note, I don't like BF.... so that's my vote for Kasparov.

P

Kasparov no problem end of thread thanks.😉

ivanhoe

Felicific Forest

Joined: 15 Dec 02
Moves: 50145

15 Nov 03

Well, we will never know .... what we dó know is that they are both giants in chess, they both influenced the way the game is played ...

royalchicken

CHAOS GHOST!!!

Elsewhere

Joined: 29 Nov 02
Moves: 17317

15 Nov 03

Nowhere was it specified that they are playing chess.

bbarr

Chief Justice

Center of Contention

Joined: 14 Jun 02
Moves: 17381

15 Nov 03

Originally posted by royalchicken
Nowhere was it specified that they are playing chess.

Kasparov vs. Fischer in the FIDE Tetherball Championships.

genius

Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined: 12 Mar 02
Moves: 15128

15 Nov 03

Originally posted by Phlabibit
During one of the X3D matches they were saying Kasparov is probably the best ever... having gone GM at about 22, and holding the World Champ title for a full decade.

What was Fischer rated at his prime?

As a note, I don't like BF.... so that's my vote for Kasparov.

P

kasparov has got the highest ever rating, beating fischers old record. however, over the years, ratings have been slowly increasing-this isn't such a good measure...

fischer went GM at 16-6 years younger than kasparov, and only lost the WC title through default to karpov.

also-is kasparov the greatest chess player just now? didn't judit polgar beat him last year when he played the berlin defence against her or something? in, like, amsterdam or somewhere...and didn't he lose the world title but is still the highest rated player or smething?

pkingjacques

Joined: 11 Apr 03
Moves: 3795

15 Nov 03

fisher would win because i think he's got more love for the game.

bluebabygirl

Joined: 14 Jun 03
Moves: 265

17 Nov 03

Fischer is the greater player of the two. In his prime he would have easily beat Karpov in his prime ,so Yes he would have beaten Kaspy too. He is absolutely the greatest chessplayer ever!! -BBG

E C Perreault

Joined: 11 Nov 03
Moves: 363

17 Nov 03

I believe in equal 21 game matches:

If they played in 1972 (1972 chess knowledge), then Fischer would win 11 1/2 to 09 1/2, and would exclaim that he didn't play his hardest in the beginning when he dropped the third game with the White Pieces!!!

If they played in 1985 (1985 chess knowledge, both having used modern computer databases for much more information and available games for study), then Fischer would win 12 1/2 to 8 1/2, claiming 3 of the games were played before and would quote games exactly; move by move, complete with the written analysis and his additions he analyzed during those games. Kasparov would become a citizen of France!

🙄

E C Perreault