Tolkien fans

jarryd

Thief Baggins!

General

10 Jan 05

Mangy Mooose

a.k.a. Polar

LasVegas via Alaska

Joined: 24 Oct 04
Moves: 7303

20 Jan 05

Originally posted by Varg
Who would you envisage playing Goldberry then?
And I won't accept ridiculously bad casting, such as Liv Tyler as Arwen.

Here 3 possibles

Diane Kruger
Radha Mitchell
Mischa Barton

Starrman

Joined: 19 Nov 03
Moves: 31382

20 Jan 05

It's got to be someone who treads the line between motherly and desireable, but my brain is too sleepy to think of anyone suitable atm.

Mangy Mooose

a.k.a. Polar

LasVegas via Alaska

Joined: 24 Oct 04
Moves: 7303

20 Jan 05

Originally posted by Starrman
It's got to be someone who treads the line between motherly and desireable, but my brain is too sleepy to think of anyone suitable atm.

Kate Hudson

XanthosNZ

Cancerous Bus Crash

p^2.sin(phi)

Joined: 06 Sep 04
Moves: 25076

20 Jan 05

Originally posted by elvendreamgirl
Even with the obvious flaw of not including Bombadil, don't you agree that jackson did the best job of the three books that could possibly be done?

Good book != Good film

Personally I loved both the book and the film. The film is different yes and there are some things I would have loved to see in it that weren't. But I can't see anyone doing a better job on the translation.
For the people who just wanted the book filmed page by page, imagine a 1 hour Council of Elrond scene. It wouldn't have worked.

Varg

Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined: 20 Jan 03
Moves: 14580

20 Jan 05

1 edit

Originally posted by Starrman
It's got to be someone who treads the line between motherly and desireable, but my brain is too sleepy to think of anyone suitable atm.

Kate Winslet? Not sure she'd be right as she is too down to earth and human, but she is motherly and desirable.

Mangy Mooose

a.k.a. Polar

LasVegas via Alaska

Joined: 24 Oct 04
Moves: 7303

20 Jan 05

Originally posted by Varg
Kate Winslet? Not sure she'd be right as she is too down to earth and human, but she is motherly and desirable.

Kate Winslet I can see that ... did you know she has very large feet and wears size 11 shoes 😲

of the 2 Kates I still like Hudson