10 best players

chesstora

Only Chess

26 Jul 10 19:37

Small Animal

Joined: 11 Jan 09
Moves: 67686

27 Jul 10 04:14

I just find it hard to believe Fischer, and I mean in his prime, is not top 1 or 2 on anyone's list.

gorookyourself

Joined: 20 Jul 10
Moves: 1072

27 Jul 10 04:23

3 edits

Originally posted by dirtysniper
I just find it hard to believe Fischer, and I mean in his prime, is not top 1 or 2 on anyone's list.

I never thought Spassky was that good. (Compared to the Chess Gods)
I mean come on? How many of us have ever said Spassky was on the "top ten" list?

I have never even met anyone who said Spassky was there favorite chess master.
Also Fischer ran away when he heard Karpov was slaying the Lions and Dragons and eating there hearts.

Fischer played great chess, BUT SO DID MANY.

gorookyourself

Joined: 20 Jul 10
Moves: 1072

27 Jul 10 04:25

I notice a lot of North Americans say Fischer was the greatest...Biased?
As soon as the U.S.A produces the next world champ you won't hear the Fischer name anymore.

Diophantus

Up a

gumtree

Joined: 13 Jan 10
Moves: 5151

27 Jul 10 06:25

Originally posted by greenpawn34
"Yakov Estrin (you missed him) is another CC world champion and
another who was likely better than Berliner. "

Have you read [b]64 Great Chess Games by Harding. My mate Yakov does not
come out of that too well. Bit of controversy about his world title.
(see game Estrin v Morgado)

Hardin and others voted Estrin v Berliner 1965 as the greates ...[text shortened]... the 1400 database. 😉

Best chess player ever. Kasparov/Fischer cannot split them.[/b]

That is why Estrin is on my list. He makes you think. I always got the impression some of his dodgy lines were deliberate. He knew the opposition was likely to read his stuff so he put in little traps to catch the unwary. Can't do that today of course, the engines would spot them a mile off.

wolfgang59

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined: 09 Jun 07
Moves: 48794

27 Jul 10 06:48

1 edit

Originally posted by chesstora
At several points in his life; Bobby Fischer was asked who are the best 10 chess players. I now pose that question to members of RHP. If I may opine first; my list isn't in any type of order just 10 players who I think are great.

Karpov
Kasparov
Fischer
Petrosian
Korchnoi
Tal
Kramnik
Aronian
Anand
Carlson

You may now opine my dear chess friends.

1. Kasparov
2. Karpov
3. Reti
4. Botvinnik
5. Capablanca
6. Lasker
7. Korchnoi
8. Spassky
9. Smyslov
10. Petrosian
😀

http://jaced.com/2005/06/10/all-time-chess-rankings/

toeternitoe

Joined: 28 Mar 10
Moves: 3807

27 Jul 10 09:10

Originally posted by greenpawn34
What Estrin book are you waiting on?

The world champions teach chess

But I'm not waiting on it,it's waiting on me.
It sits there on the shelf ,yelling and whining "why are you readig that garbage?Read me instead!READ ME!"

All day long!But after a while you don't hear it no more.

Guess have to come up with a list too.Impossible task but here goes:

-all world champions up to Kasparov and including the unofficials
then add
-Tarrasch
-Rubinstein
-Pillsbury
-Keres
-Najdorf
-Réti
-Nezhmetdinov
-Korchnoi
-Junge

the list would differ from day to day

toet.

Willzzz

Joined: 19 Apr 10
Moves: 1968

27 Jul 10 10:00

In alphabetical order:

Alekhine
Botvinnik
Capablanca
Fine
Fischer
Karpov
Kasparov
Kramnik
Smyslov
Tal

nimzo5

Ronin

Hereford Boathouse

Joined: 08 Oct 09
Moves: 29575

27 Jul 10 11:27

Originally posted by wormwood
karpov's technique was second to none, the only reason why kasparov had the slightest edge was his more dynamic (more modern) style. both were a head above all the rest, and the only player to even touch their level will be carlsen (in a couple of years from now).

is smyslov the most underrated great ever? only one mention that I can see.

I agree about Karpov's technique. but if you are talking about match play, Kramnik in 2000 was the highest level of play we have seen.

Carlsen is destroying the field in tournaments, but we will have to see how he stands up in match play vs either Anand or Kramnik.

chesstora

Joined: 31 May 10
Moves: 1772

27 Jul 10 17:18

When it comes to being under rated it has to be Petrosian. As great as he was he never got the credit that he was due. That is why he is in my top 10.

Talisman

Joined: 20 Jan 07
Moves: 24970

27 Jul 10 19:25

How can you start the list by having Karpov above Kasparov. He lost in 5 world Championship battles to kasparov. The rest of the list can be dicsarded on this basis!!

chesstora

Joined: 31 May 10
Moves: 1772

27 Jul 10 19:42

You don't have to put the players in order from 1 - 10; just who do you think are the best 10 players. The order of the players isn't important; it is your opinion that is important.

Maxacre42

Joined: 16 Oct 09
Moves: 2448

27 Jul 10 20:01

1 edit

Originally posted by wormwood
karpov's technique was second to none, the only reason why kasparov had the slightest edge was his more dynamic (more modern) style. both were a head above all the rest, and the only player to even touch their level will be carlsen (in a couple of years from now).

is smyslov the most underrated great ever? only one mention that I can see.

Smyslov is absolutely amazing. I can't describe it. He was just extreme in every aspect of the game. His over-perfectionism, laser-like preciseness and dazzling combos will always be remembered. Plus he proved his longevity like almost no other, he was what, like 2500 in his 80s! You're damn right he's underrated. There will always be a place for him in my top 10!

Paul Leggett

Chess Librarian

The Stacks

Joined: 21 Aug 09
Moves: 115073

27 Jul 10 23:02

Originally posted by wormwood
karpov's technique was second to none, the only reason why kasparov had the slightest edge was his more dynamic (more modern) style. both were a head above all the rest, and the only player to even touch their level will be carlsen (in a couple of years from now).

is smyslov the most underrated great ever? only one mention that I can see.

From my mind to your keyboard!

Paul

toeternitoe

Joined: 28 Mar 10
Moves: 3807

27 Jul 10 23:16

Yes,for some strange reason Smyslov is always overlooked.Although he made it 4 times into this thread.Quite good actually.

If you combine his 3 match scores for the crown versus botvinnik,Smyslov wins by 18 to 17.

Never met him but felt sad the day I heard he passed away.A fan with the skills should write a fitting eulogy.

toet.

chesstora

Joined: 31 May 10
Moves: 1772

28 Jul 10 00:49

I'll have to agree with the post about Smyslov (R.I.P oh great one). He proved himself by how long he continued to play (and win games!). But my questions goes to the post about Spassky. If he wasn't "that good of a player"; how could he claw his way to the top? He faced off with some of the all time greats.