26 Jan 09
Originally posted by ArrakThe acid test is not just whether they match Fritz, but whether they are finding the type of moves that human players typically would not see.
i know thats the thing though. after he blundered the piece he played pretty flawlessly. i matched the game up against a chess engine afterwords and ever since his blunder he seems to make the first move choosen by fritz?
ok maybe he didn't cheat but its just a bit fishy since he played such a poor opening and lost his bishop. i also thought he was playing above his 1600 rating compared to other 1600 ive played on here.
but maybe im wrong...
In that game, it is obvious to any moderately strong player what to do as Black: centralize the King, get the pawns rolling to try and make a passed pawn, etc. This is all really basic stuff.
26 Jan 09
Originally posted by Arrak"Most RHP members"? Not really.
why does it say arrakis got banned from the site. it seems like most rhp memebers like that guy. if he didn't cheat why did he get banned?
He was liked by a handful and tolerated by some. Most members loathed him for being a self-righteous, bigoted, fat, whining slob who had a self-importance complex.
27 Jan 09
Originally posted by SwissGambitAgree totally.
The acid test is not just whether they match Fritz, but whether they are finding the type of moves that human players typically would not see.
In that game, it is obvious to any moderately strong player what to do as Black: centralize the King, get the pawns rolling to try and make a passed pawn, etc. This is all really basic stuff.
Bet the Mods threw this one out after one look.
(and then had a whip round to buy black a better computer) 😉
Sorry Arrak but your bad play after you won the piece made
the other guys moves look good.
27 Jan 09
well this sucks... i guess after reading this post "Korch" kicked me out of his clan (chess warriors) because he thinks i cheat on playchess, it was a total misunderstanding.
if anyone wants me on their clan just email me. i like to move often so one day a move and either 0 or 3 day timebank is good for me.
28 Jan 09
Originally posted by GatecrasherIs this what you do personally or are you assisting an offender?
Chess sites that require you to download a client application in order for you to play can monitor the programs running in your tasklist. If you are running an engine while playing on their sites, you will most likely get banned for cheating or be labeled as a computer-assisted player. Since Chessbase is basically an engine interface, you run the risk of ...[text shortened]... ing banned/labeled just by looking up opening moves. It is much safer to use an online database.
28 Jan 09
I personally think people who use datebases, wether it be Openings,middlegames,end games... It's all a form of cheating, BUT not if you don't use it during a game. You won't get better at chess if you keep relying on the engine to tell you your moves. I use chessbase to analyze my games and study openings (away from the board...) and nothing else. So to put it short.
USE YOUR BRAIN.
30 Jan 09
Originally posted by Daniel KirkCorrespondence games take a long time. So, some of us always are in the middle of a game. Hence, books and DBs are allowed, because learning must still be allowed. This is a far cry from an engine which will generate a move for you in any type of position, without any need for you to personally understand what's going on.
I personally think people who use datebases, wether it be Openings,middlegames,end games... It's all a form of cheating, BUT not if you don't use it during a game. You won't get better at chess if you keep relying on the engine to tell you your moves. I use chessbase to analyze my games and study openings (away from the board...) and nothing else. So to put it short.
USE YOUR BRAIN.
Book knowledge, on the other hand, is useless unless the reader understands the thought behind the moves given. Using books DOES require using your brain.
- Joined
- 07 Jun 05
- Moves
- 5301
02 Feb 09
2 edits
Originally posted by Daniel KirkSee the ToS at the foot of the page. Rule 3 (b).
I personally think people who use datebases, wether it be Openings,middlegames,end games... It's all a form of cheating.
[snip]
While a game is in progress you may not refer to chess engines, chess computers or be assisted by a third party. Endgame tablebases may not be consulted during play but you may reference books, databases consisting of previously played games between human players, and other pre-existing research materials.
So opening databases are clearly permitted, as are all kinds of reference books. But do not analyse a game in progress with an engine.
Arrak:
The question you asked in Thread 106311 got met with ridicule because it is hard work to detect an engine. There are endless threads expressing opinion about how it might be done, but it is difficult to be sure. The thing to do if you suspect a cheat is to (on http://www.redhotpawn.com/fairplay/createticket.php) highlight it to your friendly mod.
None of us is keen to spend months playing an engine - please don't bother.
edit: trying to fix the URL - just noticed that they do not work on public forums.
- Joined
- 20 Jan 07
- Moves
- 24894
02 Feb 09
Originally posted by ivan2908well......
opening books are not allowed on playchess but they are allowed here. (Totally different types of chess - correspodence / real time have totally different rules.)
As far as I know engines are not allowed on RHP neither on playchess.
04 Feb 09
Originally posted by ArrakFirst of all, good thing you're not doing it anymore. The fact that you're asking tells me that you really mean it.
ive been caught cheating before on playchess and havent done it since... but id like to improve my opening play. would i get caught for this or not? id like to use cheesbase 9 opening database... would playchess.com catch me for cheating?
As far as opening goes; I do not think there is a problem checking out the openings; heck! there's a whole bunch of stuff you can find regarding openings, they sometimes even go around the 25th or something move...my advice to you is find an opening that you find yourself comfortable with and try to understand the idea behind it; you can use chessbase to find games that were played on that particular opening and go from there; the rest you'll get it with practice (sorry, that's how it goes)
good luck
🙂