Go back
Was this a draw?

Was this a draw?

Only Chess

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
31 Jan 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Testrider
===================================
QUOTE:
---------
I know this is answering a different question that what was asked, but...

Black could have easily forced a draw on its last move. By playing Rf6
and forcing an exchange of rooks, it is very easy from there to attain
the draw (since the black king will be well positioned in front of the
advan ...[text shortened]... is a straight loss, after Rxf6 Kxf6 Kf4 black doesn't have opposition an white can get a queen.
Wrong. White cannot stay in front of the pawn with the opposition. Draw.

EDIT: OOPS! Thought it was White's move; it is a win with Black to move.

m

Joined
25 Sep 04
Moves
1779
Clock
31 Jan 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Just an observation.....Basic Chess Endings (also on old, out of print endgame book by Peter Griffiths), and probably other sources, as well as posts from several players here, point out this is an elementary draw. The fact that it's causing so much discussion leads me to believe some of us need to brush up on our endings!

t

Garner, NC

Joined
04 Nov 05
Moves
31225
Clock
31 Jan 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by no1marauder
Wrong. White cannot stay in front of the pawn with the opposition. Draw.

EDIT: OOPS! Thought it was White's move; it is a win with Black to move.
After further review I have to agree that Rf6 loses for black.

MS

Under Cover

Joined
25 Feb 04
Moves
28912
Clock
14 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by masscat
Help me out here. After 50.g7 Rg8 how should White play for the win?
After 50 g7 Rg8 white replies with 51 Kf2. Now he threatens to advance his King and win the black f-pawn. Blacks responses are limited to advancing the f-pawn, which loses it to gxf3 or moving the King which allows White's King to advance. Either way, White has 2 pawns to none, and in one instance they aren't doubled. Can black trade off the advanced g-pawn and Rooks, AND maintain the opposition to save the draw, I don't know. I never look that far ahead, which is probably why I lose. In any case, my point was that White would have better chances, not a guaranteed win, and I believe that I have explained it unless I missed something obvious, which is always possible with me.

MS

Under Cover

Joined
25 Feb 04
Moves
28912
Clock
14 Feb 06
3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

I just played this position out (after 50 g7) agains Fritz 8, allowing Fritz 2 minutes per move. Here is the way it finished:


50. g7 Rg8
51. Kf2 Ke5
52. Kf3 Kf5
53. Rxf4+ Ke5
54. Rg4 Kf5
55. g3 Ke5
56. Rg5+ Kd4
57. Kf4 Kd3
58. Kf5 Kf2
59. Kf6 Kf3
58. Kf7 resigns

*position after 51. Kf2

m

Joined
25 Sep 04
Moves
1779
Clock
14 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Kudos to BLReid

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.