Go back
Anyone better at math than me....

Anyone better at math than me....

Posers and Puzzles

M
Quis custodiet

ipsos custodes?

Joined
16 Feb 03
Moves
13400
Clock
24 Feb 08
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Whats the square root of -i ??

G

Joined
13 Dec 06
Moves
792
Clock
24 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

-sqrt(2)/2+sqrt(2)i/2
and
sqrt(2)/2-sqrt(2)i/2
I think.

M
Quis custodiet

ipsos custodes?

Joined
16 Feb 03
Moves
13400
Clock
24 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by GregM
-sqrt(2)/2+sqrt(2)i/2
and
sqrt(2)/2-sqrt(2)i/2
I think.
Don't suppose you want to show me how to get that?

A

Joined
02 Mar 06
Moves
17881
Clock
24 Feb 08
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mexico
Don't suppose you want to show me how to get that?
we seek a complex number a+bi, whose square: (a^2 - b^2) + (2ab)i = -i

so we seek a simultaneous solution to

(1) a^2 - b^2 = 0 and

(2) 2ab = -1.

clearly by equation (1), a=b will give us one solution. then by (2), a=b= [sqrt(2)/2]*i, and our complex number a+bi = [sqrt(2)/2]i - [sqrt(2)/2]i^2 or finally:
a+bi = [sqrt(2)/2]i - sqrt(2)/2

the other solution is given by a=-b. so then a = [sqrt(2)/2] and b = -[sqrt(2)/2].
so a + bi = [sqrt(2)/2] - [sqrt(2)/2]i.

M
Quis custodiet

ipsos custodes?

Joined
16 Feb 03
Moves
13400
Clock
24 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Thank you....

A

Joined
02 Mar 06
Moves
17881
Clock
24 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

you're welcome 🙂 it's easier than it looks with all the sqrt(---) notation. i wish equation editor worked outside of microsoft word haha

m

Joined
07 Sep 05
Moves
35068
Clock
24 Feb 08
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Another way is to use the identity:

r(cos x + i sin x) = e^(ix)

So -i = e^(-i PI/2)

=> sqrt(i) = +/- e^(-i PI/4)
= +/- [cos PI/4 - i sin PI/4]
= +/- [sqrt(2)/2 - i sqrt(2)/2

G

Joined
13 Dec 06
Moves
792
Clock
25 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mexico
Don't suppose you want to show me how to get that?
-i = e^(3pi/2 * i)
sqrt(-i) = (-i)^(1/2) = (e^(3pi/2 * i)) ^ (1/2) = e^(3pi/2 * i * 1/2) = e^(3pi/4 * i)

r*e^(theta * i) = r*(cos(theta) + i*sin(theta)), so that
e^(3pi/4 * i) = cos(3pi/4) + i*sin(3pi/4) = -sqrt(2)/2 + sqrt(2)i/2

But all numbers have two square roots (and, in general, n nth roots). The second square root is always the negative of the first, because if x = sqrt(y) then (-x)^2 = (-1 * x)^2 = (-1)^2 * (x)^2 = 1*x^2 = y, so that -x is another square root of y. So the other root is

-1*(-sqrt(2)/2 + sqrt(2)i/2) = sqrt(2)/2 - sqrt(2)i/2.

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26753
Clock
29 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mexico
Whats the square root of -i ??
(-i)^(1/2)
(-1)^(1/2)*i^(1/2)
i*-i = 1

P
Bananarama

False berry

Joined
14 Feb 04
Moves
28719
Clock
29 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Further to what GregM showed, use can use de Moivre's theorem to find the nth root of a complex number. Given a complex number c = a + bi = r*cis(x), where cis(x) = sin(x) + i*cos(x), the roots are:

c^(1/n) = r^(1/n) * (sin((x+2k*pi)/n) + i*cos((x+2k*pi)/n)) for k = 0,1,...(n-1)

p
Iron Pillar

Backside of desert

Joined
09 Nov 06
Moves
14828
Clock
29 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

simplest way:

transform < a , b > = a + bi

to < r , y > where r = radius and y = angle from positive real numbers.

then < r , y > ^n = < r^n , y*n >

to get all roots of a number

< r , y > ^(1/n) = < r^(1/n) , [y/n + (2k pi /n)] > k= (1, 2, ... , n)

P
Bananarama

False berry

Joined
14 Feb 04
Moves
28719
Clock
29 Feb 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

The cool thing about the roots of an imaginary number is that when you plot them on the imaginary plane, they form a regular n-gon. If you can find one of the roots by inspection, this makes finding the other roots a snap.

For example, one of the cube roots of 1 is 1. To find the others, just rotate the vector (1,0) on the imaginary plane 120 degrees (360/3) until you're back where you started. The other two roots are then (-SQRT(2), SQRT(2)) and (-SQRT(2), -SQRT(2)).

A

Joined
02 Mar 06
Moves
17881
Clock
01 Mar 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

this material is too complex for me.

and i've always loved that fact about the n-th roots of a number forming a regular n-gon. it's unreal.

F

Joined
28 Jan 08
Moves
339
Clock
01 Mar 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mexico
Whats the square root of -i ??
Do negative numbers have square roots? I don't think so, but my maths teacher says they do in a complicated way...

s

Joined
28 Aug 07
Moves
3178
Clock
01 Mar 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mexico
Whats the square root of -i ??
You can check quaternions math. It's cool.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.