Go back
If the Sun's gravity...

If the Sun's gravity...

Posers and Puzzles

B

Joined
05 Oct 05
Moves
82
Clock
05 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Seems you all are stuck in the notion of forces.
If you instead look at the suns gravitation as an alteration of the space
around the sun, much like a stone would make a bump if placed on a stretched-out blanket, and the earth is a much smaller stone circling the bigger one, what would you then mean by "suddenly switch off" (the impact on the blanket caused by the mass of) the big stone? The question, even if hypothetically put, does not make sense.

B
Non-Subscriber

RHP IQ

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1345
Clock
05 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Birkmoor
Seems you all are stuck in the notion of forces.
If you instead look at the suns gravitation as an alteration of the space
around the sun, much like a stone would make a bump if placed on a stretched-out blanket, and the earth is a much smaller stone circling the bigger one, what would you then mean by "suddenly switch off" (the impact on the blanket ca ...[text shortened]... ed by the mass of) the big stone? The question, even if hypothetically put, does not make sense.
Another who doesn't read threads before replying?

P

Joined
17 Jan 05
Moves
3242
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

R

Coachella Valley,CA

Joined
20 Sep 05
Moves
469
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Bowmann
Don't you have any other hobbies?
Playing Chess!!!
how about a game Bowmann.

Actually I was hoping to be berated by you.
I like you!

R

Coachella Valley,CA

Joined
20 Sep 05
Moves
469
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Pullhard
I can't believe the bullshit that gets posted in these forums with such authoritative air. It took Bowmann to explain an elementary aspect of our universe. How embarrassing.
WARNING: Chronic debating can lead to blindness!

This should only be attempted by Master-Debaters.

P
Banned from edits

Grammar dyslexic

Joined
20 May 05
Moves
11372
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wildfire
If the Sun's gravity were suddenly "turned off," would the Earth be immediately affected? Or would it take eight minutes (the time it takes for the sun's light to reach Earth)?
does gravity affect light speed? i don't think it does

P
Banned from edits

Grammar dyslexic

Joined
20 May 05
Moves
11372
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PocketKings
does gravity affect light speed? i don't think it does
but i was never good at science anyway

P
Banned from edits

Grammar dyslexic

Joined
20 May 05
Moves
11372
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

testing

P
Banned from edits

Grammar dyslexic

Joined
20 May 05
Moves
11372
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

testing again

C

Earth Prime

Joined
16 Mar 05
Moves
35265
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PocketKings
does gravity affect light speed? i don't think it does
start a new thread. Name it "gravity and light" because it has been shown that gravity can pull light, but what strength is needed?

B
Non-Subscriber

RHP IQ

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1345
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Coconut
...gravity can pull light...
Wrong! There we go with the "force" idea again.

Light travels through space in straight lines and has no inertial mass to be 'pulled' by anything.

B
Non-Subscriber

RHP IQ

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1345
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Raw760
Playing Chess!!!
how about a game Bowmann.
Ask me in the appropriate forum.

o

Joined
06 Jun 05
Moves
502
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

My appologies if this has been covered erlyer, but im to lazy to read this entire thread.

Gravity acording to some theorys is a bending of space, this is why light (which has no mas) can be effected by a black hole, it goes in a straight line, its just that space is bent, there for there is no time needed for gravity to travel, its just "under" space.

Other theorys have the graviton (string theory for example) and this is far to bizare for me to comprihend, so that might take time to travle. I would loke to point out however that this is a pointles question as gravity cant be terned off, so by braking one rool of the univerce, all the others kinda fall to bits anyway!

o

Joined
06 Jun 05
Moves
502
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I would also like to appologise for beeing a little drunk and to lazy to use a spell check

and wilst im at it, i would like to appologise for gravity in the first place, i know its not my fawlt, but it is an all mighty pain at times (like when i fall of my bike!)

X
Cancerous Bus Crash

p^2.sin(phi)

Joined
06 Sep 04
Moves
25076
Clock
06 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by o0Ziggy0o
My appologies if this has been covered erlyer, but im to lazy to read this entire thread.

Gravity acording to some theorys is a bending of space, this is why light (which has no mas) can be effected by a black hole, it goes in a straight line, its just that space is bent, there for there is no time needed for gravity to travel, its just "under" space. ...[text shortened]... be terned off, so by braking one rool of the univerce, all the others kinda fall to bits anyway!
Argh. It's an epidemic.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.