Go back
Can color be proven?

Can color be proven?

Science

Cheesemaster
😏

Joined
22 Sep 20
Moves
2987
Clock
15 Nov 20

@humy said
Yes, but the essence of the philosophical OP problem of this thread isn't a problem of what physically defines color but rather, and even if and when there are no differences between how our physical eyes respond to color, how do we know we all share the same private color sensory sensation in our minds when we physically see the same physical color of, say, color green. How, fo ...[text shortened]... ical green is more like your color sensory sensation of, say, blue rather than green, or vice versa?
This.

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
09 Sep 18
Moves
20590
Clock
16 Nov 20
Vote Up
Vote Down

@sonhouse said
@badradger
It also turns out color blind folks have a compensation:
They see many shades of gray and have been used by military to identify enemy blinds and such that normal folks would not be able to discern.
They really do see 50 shades of gray.
when we had a black and white tv back in the 60s my son swore he could tell the colour of clothing by its shade of grey.

Cheesemaster
😏

Joined
22 Sep 20
Moves
2987
Clock
17 Nov 20

@badradger said
when we had a black and white tv back in the 60s my son swore he could tell the colour of clothing by its shade of grey.
I believe it 🤔

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669999
Clock
17 Nov 20
Vote Up
Vote Down

@cheesemaster said
I believe it 🤔
you can also have quite an interesting Theory if you read Goethes take on this.

Starting Point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_Colours

Cheesemaster
😏

Joined
22 Sep 20
Moves
2987
Clock
17 Nov 20
Vote Up
Vote Down

I see people have been arguing about color for hundreds of years 🤔
Interesting article. Too smart for me to understand all of it though.

lemon lime
itiswhatitis

oLd ScHoOl

Joined
31 May 13
Moves
5577
Clock
18 Nov 20
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@badradger said
when we had a black and white tv back in the 60s my son swore he could tell the colour of clothing by its shade of grey.
Grey levels are one of the factors used in the colorization of black and white films. It's a complicated process, and still requires human input to guess (if it's not known) what color an object is or might be. And sometimes you can catch mistakes if you happen to know what color something is supposed to be.

I once saw a colorized version of an old Superman episode where a little guy was supposed to be a Martian with green hair. But his hair was red. Whoever did the colorization of that film either didn't know the story line, or something went wrong in the colorization process and no one bothered to fix it, probably due to budgetary constraints. Either way it was very entertaining to hear the actors talking about the little Martian's "green" hair.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.