Go back
Limited Recs

Limited Recs

Site Ideas

d

Riding the Atom Bomb

Joined
14 May 05
Moves
4174
Clock
12 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

This doesnt really concern me because i cant give out any recommendations, but i heard others say they were being abused. Wouldnt recs mean something, be worth something, if they were limited?

(Not my idea, someone else's)

N
The eyes of truth

elsewhere

Joined
26 Apr 04
Moves
21784
Clock
12 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dale21
This doesnt really concern me because i cant give out any recommendations, but i heard others say they were being abused. Wouldnt recs mean something, be worth something, if they were limited?

(Not my idea, someone else's)
I fully support a limited amount of recs. They have become almost completely useless as of late. I myself have 190 someodd recs, and in my year here I've only written maybe one or two decent posts, so it's obvious they mean little.

CS

Joined
05 Dec 04
Moves
8732
Clock
12 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I support it too. It's very misused but a limit on the number of recs you can issue can be a step toward solving this problem.

Sicilian Sausage

In your face

Joined
21 Aug 04
Moves
55993
Clock
12 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dale21
This doesnt really concern me because i cant give out any recommendations, but i heard others say they were being abused. Wouldnt recs mean something, be worth something, if they were limited?

(Not my idea, someone else's)
This post got two recs. I like the irony. 😛

f
Quack Quack Quack !

Chesstralia

Joined
18 Aug 03
Moves
54533
Clock
12 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Chess Slayer
I support it too. It's very misused but a limit on the number of recs you can issue can be a step toward solving this problem.
i think the queestion is: what is the best way to limit them?

should it be impossible to make a rec for 1 hour after last making one?

should some people be able to make more recs than others?

but it is not a big problem : shavixmir has the heaps of recs ... and that is the way it should be ...

d

Riding the Atom Bomb

Joined
14 May 05
Moves
4174
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Ha Ha .The fact that people have rec'ed this thread suggests i may be right.

K
Strawman

Not Kansas

Joined
10 Jul 04
Moves
6405
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I'd be OK with the idea of limited recs.
Most posters would get the same proportion of recs they do now, so it wouldn't be a hardship to those that do enjoy getting recs.
Maybe it would stop useless recs, maybe not, but I think it's worth a try.
Some thought needs to be taken on how to implement this, i.e. so many recs given per week, an hour between giving recs or whatever.
I'm neutral on recs, on one hand it's rewarding to get them if I feel I've posted something good, on the other hand I'm puzzled at some recs I've received.

TP
Leak-Proof

under the sink

Joined
08 Aug 04
Moves
12493
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Here's a thought:

Is it possible for Recommended Posts to have a list at the bottom indicating who recommended the post?

murrow
penguinpuffin

finsbury

Joined
25 Aug 04
Moves
48501
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by The Plumber
Here's a thought:

Is it possible for Recommended Posts to have a list at the bottom indicating who recommended the post?

that's a great idea
stop people announcing it when they give a rec (soooo annoying)
it gets my rec

a

omnipresent

Joined
29 Oct 04
Moves
20009
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

yes, please limit them... How about a "rec bank"? As in I have 50 recs, so I can rec 50 people. For each time I rec someone, one rec gets deducted from my count, and each time someone recs me, one gets added. We could even have a "rec total" and rec "current" stat so you can see how many total recs someone got without deducting the ones he's given.
That way, people would only rec really good posts, since there's a limited number of recs available 😀

w
Jo

Moving on...

Joined
18 Nov 03
Moves
44943
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

i propose that recs are scrapped altogether.

r
Ginger Scum

Paranoia

Joined
23 Sep 03
Moves
15902
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by wucky3
i propose that recs are scrapped altogether.
why not just highlight the hot threads instead - i.e. those with most activity in terms of views / replies. That way we can all see where dapardies at...

T

Joined
10 Feb 03
Moves
12969
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by angie88
...For each time I rec someone, one rec gets deducted from my count, and each time someone recs me, one gets added...
Queue rec gangs aplenty: you rec me and I'll rec you.
Insestious recs were bad enough with padft, the wolf pack etc.
Let's not encourage that behaviour.

TP
Leak-Proof

under the sink

Joined
08 Aug 04
Moves
12493
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by angie88
yes, please limit them... How about a "rec bank"? As in I have 50 recs, so I can rec 50 people. For each time I rec someone, one rec gets deducted from my count, and each time someone recs me, one gets added. We could even have a "rec total" and rec "current" stat so you can see how many total recs someone got without deducting the ones he's given.
T ...[text shortened]... y, people would only rec really good posts, since there's a limited number of recs available 😀
Yesssss - we'll have a rectometer to keep track of it all, and call it the rec'tum for short....😀

d

Riding the Atom Bomb

Joined
14 May 05
Moves
4174
Clock
13 Jun 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

How about just 2 recs each day? is that too little?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.