07 Nov 05
1 edit
I was surprised recently when I heard that certain clergymen attempted to become unionized to protect themselves from abuse from parishioners and ensure more equitable wages. The Protestant and United churches have stated that they are not opposed to this move by their clergymen.
What do you guys/broads think of this? Should these clergymen be looking to unions for help in their professions or should they just be looking to God exclusively? They are, after all, doing "His" work. Will the will of the union always be the same as the will of God? Will picketing clergymen stop their congregation from attending scab church on Sundays?
http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2004/11/05/clergy_unionization041105.html
07 Nov 05
Originally posted by darvlayThis is a very complicated issue where there are many factors to consider. Indeed there are many poor pastors that have little or nothing to retire on. They have lived their lives trying to live in integrity with the Gospel and their faith, and many have been taken advantage of by ruthless congregations that when they say something they disagree with send them packing.
I was surprised recently when I heard that certain clergymen attempted to become unionized to protect themselves from abuse from parishioners and ensure more equitable wages. The Protestant and United churches have stated that they are not opposed to this move by their clergymen.
What do you guys/broads think of this? Should these clergymen be looking t ...[text shortened]... on Sundays?
http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2004/11/05/clergy_unionization041105.html
One of the problems that I see is that there are too many ministers. There is not the demand for the numbers they are turning out of divinity schools and seminaries, so I'm not suprised that there is a move to unionize. Where I live many of the ministers have absolutely no educational training. Their churches do not cooperate with other churches unless there is a wet/dry vote on alcohol sales. These tend to be fundamentalist churches with no church structure. Somebody can show up on their doorstep and say "God wants me to preach here" and they will be happy to accomodate them.
If I can tie this in with unions in general, I think unions come about when workers feel discounted, under-appreciated or taken advantage of. When live in a tme when ministers are seen as laughable. It seems that the most laughable ones who create embarrassment for ministers with integrity are ones who get the most attention. My favorite description of these people comes from Will Campbell (see Ivory Tower thread) who describes them as "electronic soul molesters."
07 Nov 05
Originally posted by darvlayI think it's up to the clergymen themselves. If unionising will help improve their lot and that of their brothers, then, sure. I'm not sure how they'll exercise collective bargaining, though. I am not in favour of picketing the faithful of their own congregation.
I was surprised recently when I heard that certain clergymen attempted to become unionized to protect themselves from abuse from parishioners and ensure more equitable wages. The Protestant and United churches have stated that they are not opposed to this move by their clergymen.
What do you guys/broads think of this? Should these clergymen be looking t ...[text shortened]... on Sundays?
http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2004/11/05/clergy_unionization041105.html
If I were a cleric, I'd leave it to God.
07 Nov 05
Originally posted by darvlayIs their right to be on strike a sin? What would happen to the flock?
I was surprised recently when I heard that certain clergymen attempted to become unionized to protect themselves from abuse from parishioners and ensure more equitable wages. The Protestant and United churches have stated that they are not opposed to this move by their clergymen.
What do you guys/broads think of this? Should these clergymen be looking t ...[text shortened]... on Sundays?
http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2004/11/05/clergy_unionization041105.html
07 Nov 05
If the congregations of churches and self-appointed People of God do not take care of their own appointed leaders and teachers (the pastors and Priests), then those teachers must rely on the unionisation of the clergy to secure their well-being.
Where does God and His will fit into the above statement?
07 Nov 05
Originally posted by darvlayGod is the one in charge of guiding the blind that guide the blind. God help them...
If the congregations of churches and self-appointed People of God do not take care of their own appointed leaders and teachers (the pastors and Priests), then those teachers must rely on the unionisation of the clergy to secure their well-being.
Where does God and His will fit into the above statement?
07 Nov 05
1 edit
Originally posted by PalynkaIt makes you wonder if these Clergymen sought answers from God in this matter.
God is the one in charge of guiding the blind that guide the blind. God help them...
Management siding with labour? God works in mysterious ways, indeed.
07 Nov 05
Originally posted by darvlayI'm sorry - is that a response to my post?
If the congregations of churches and self-appointed People of God do not take care of their own appointed leaders and teachers (the pastors and Priests), then those teachers must rely on the unionisation of the clergy to secure their well-being.
Where does God and His will fit into the above statement?