Go back
How many non-chritian non-atheists are there on...

How many non-chritian non-atheists are there on...

Spirituality

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
Not "more" in the sense of "greater" or "more important". Every task, every responsibility, every job has a dignity of its own.
So the duties of Cardinal Law's houskeepers are just as important as the Pope's duties?

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
So the duties of Cardinal Law's houskeepers are just as important as the Pope's duties?
"Important" in what sense?

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
"Important" in what sense?
In the sense you had in mind when you said "more important."

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
19 Dec 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
In the sense you had in mind when you said "more important."
Then, yes.

EDIT: I used "greater"/"more important" in the sense of having greater intrinsic dignity.

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
Then, yes.
That's quite a claim. I doubt many Catholics would agree with you.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
That's quite a claim. I doubt many Catholics would agree with you.
The Pope would.

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
I used "greater"/"more important" in the sense of having greater intrinsic dignity.
No you didn't. Import has nothing to do with dignity. If that's what you meant, you would have said "having more dignity." You just made that up to patch up your position.

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
The Pope would.
Would the housekeepers?

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
No you didn't. Import has nothing to do with dignity. If that's what you meant, you would have said "having more dignity." You just made that up to patch up your position.
Yes I did - read the sentence following my first use of "more important".

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
Yes I did - read the sentence following my first use of "more important".
Why would you introduce the term "important" at all, if you were only discussing dignity?

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
Would the housekeepers?
If they've had philosophical or theological training, they would. Otherwise, they may or may not.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
19 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
Why would you introduce the term "important" at all, if you were only discussing dignity?
Because the idea of importance is related to the idea of dignity in common usage. And dignity is ultimately at the root of this discussion.

DoctorScribbles
BWA Soldier

Tha Brotha Hood

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
49088
Clock
19 Dec 05
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
And dignity is ultimately at the root of this discussion.
It sure is.

Cardinal Law, a man known to turn child molesters loose on various congregations, but a man nonetheless, is entitled to have women clean his toilet. Are those women entitled to have a man clean their toilets? I doubt it. How many women in the church are entitled to a car and driver? As you said, the sexes have different duties in the church. I suppose I'll have to take your word that those nuns on their knees, brush in hand, with the scent of urine wafting up through their holy nostrils, have just as much dignity as the Pope being cheered by huge crowds in Vatican Square and flossing around in the popemobile - and that if any don't, it's only because of their philosophical and theological shortcomings.

TM

Joined
17 Jun 05
Moves
9211
Clock
19 Dec 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I do not think you can keep denying the fact that the church is sexist. Its not like say the existance of god that really could go either way but we have diffrent veiws, it is rooted in fact that the church is sexist, i know you will keep trying to defend it but when it comes down to it im sure it is clear to most that the church is. I can understand you are defending it as it is a very important orgainisation in your eyes. But because it is so improtant does this mean it is without fault?

DC
Flamenco Sketches

Spain, in spirit

Joined
09 Sep 04
Moves
59422
Clock
20 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Bosse de Nage
I'm neither Christian nor atheist.
You just left 'em twisting in the wind about 5 pages back, didn'tcha?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.