24 Nov 08
1 edit
Originally posted by RagnorakWhat's the best (let's rephrase "most acclaimed" ) football school there?
No doubt. It's very hard (impossible) to criticise Wenger for the football that he tries to get his team to play.
Ferguson approaches games in the same way, and tries to build teams full of attackers. Recently, he has tried to make his team tougher to break down as well. In his European naivety, in thinking that his team could beat any other team in t Giggs, Brown, Rossi, Campbell, Da Silvas, Evans, etc) Wenger doesn't have that luxury.
D
Is there something like that, i.e. ManU football school for kids, Arsenal football school, etc.?
- Joined
- 10 Jan 08
- Moves
- 19047
24 Nov 08
Originally posted by Seitseevery clubs has their own youth program. man utd and west ham seem to be the most famous for producing young players.
What's the best (let's rephrase "most acclaimed" ) football school there?
Is there something like that, i.e. ManU football school for kids, Arsenal football school, etc.?
24 Nov 08
3 edits
Originally posted by SeitseIs Arsenal really that good? For example, here's a recent list for young players Porto who passed by Porto recently (last 4 years):
What's the best (let's rephrase "most acclaimed" ) football school there?
Is there something like that, i.e. ManU football school for kids, Arsenal football school, etc.?
Deco, Bosingwa, Carvalho, Quaresma, Anderson, Lucho Gonzalez, Maniche, Diego, Luis Fabiano, Helton, etc...
Try making an Arsenal list and see who you come up with.
Edit - And I agree with Rags here, Ferguson's list is also more impressive than Wenger's IMO.
24 Nov 08
Originally posted by SeitseCome on, don't give up like that. 🙂
Well, when faced with facts, there's not a lot to do, is it?
I guess that the fact that I like Wenger is based purely on my feelings.
Wenger is a great coach, definitely one of the best around, and I would love to have him coaching Porto. Just that many of his kids weren't all that good. Maybe he made them play well. He was on fire for a few seasons when he nabbed some amazing players (Vieira, Overmars, Petit, Henry, Bergkamp and maybe more I'm missing), but I'm just a bit more skeptical of his last seasons. He still does great things with what he has, though.
24 Nov 08
2 edits
Originally posted by PalynkaGood point.
Is Arsenal really that good?
Try making an Arsenal list and see who you come up with.
Off the top of my head, all I could think of was Jermaine Pennant and David Bentley.
A quick search reveals that the following Arsenal youths are playing the premiership...
1. Steve Sidwell - Villa
2. Jeremie Aliadiare - Middlesborough
3. Matthew Upson - West Ham United
4. Hoyte - Boro
5. Jermaine Pennant - Liverpool
6. Moritz Voltz - Fulham
7. Ashley Cole - Chelsea
8. Bentley - Blackburn
9. Larsson - Birmingham
10. Stokes - Sunderland
For United youth players, off the top of my head...
1. Beckham (AC Milan, and ex Real Madrid)
2. Butt (Newcastle)
3. Rossi (Villareal and Italy)
4. Jonathan Greening (WBA)
5. Phil Neville (Everton)
6. Bardsley (Sunderland)
7. Richardson (Sunderland)
8. Healy (Sunderland & record breaker with NI)
9. Pique (Barcelona)
10. Frazier Campbell (Spurs)
11. Danny Simpson (Blackburn)
12. Danny Pugh (Stoke)
13. Shawcross (Stoke)
14. Nevland (Fulham)
15. Higginbottom (Stoke)
D
24 Nov 08
Originally posted by RagnorakI think you should extend both those lists to players who really developed with those coaches, not just pure home-grown talent. Wenger would probably do a bit better in that case.
Good point.
Off the top of my head, all I could think of was Jermaine Pennant and David Bentley.
A quick search reveals that the following Arsenal youths are playing the premiership...
1. Steve Sidwell - Villa
2. Jeremie Aliadiare - Middlesborough
3. [b]Matthew Upson - West Ham United
4. Hoyte - Boro
5. Jermaine Pennant - Liv ...[text shortened]... . Danny Pugh (Stoke)
13. Shawcross (Stoke)
14. Nevland (Fulham)
15. Higginbottom (Stoke)
D[/b]
24 Nov 08
Originally posted by PalynkaI thought I had (Voltz, Pique and Rossi), but tbh, it's a difficult list to compile.
I think you should extend both those lists to players who really developed with those coaches, not just pure home-grown talent. Wenger would probably do a bit better in that case.
Why? Who are you thinking of?
D
24 Nov 08
Originally posted by PalynkaI excluded players who still played for their respective club, and I didn't include Viera because I felt he was too old when he signed for Arsenal. Having said that, 20 is borderline (I thought he was 24 when he signed)
I'm not sure actually. I would include Vieira and Fabregas, though.
D
24 Nov 08
Originally posted by RagnorakBENTLEY PLAYS FOR SPURS not Blackburn
Good point.
Off the top of my head, all I could think of was Jermaine Pennant and David Bentley.
A quick search reveals that the following Arsenal youths are playing the premiership...
1. Steve Sidwell - Villa
2. Jeremie Aliadiare - Middlesborough
3. [b]Matthew Upson - West Ham United
4. Hoyte - Boro
5. Jermaine Pennant - Liv ...[text shortened]... ] - Chelsea
8. Bentley - Blackburn
9. Larsson - Birmingham
10. Stokes - Sunderland