Go back
Chess players are smart, right?

Chess players are smart, right?

Debates

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
Clock
23 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by no1marauder
I spend my days making a couple hundred bucks an hour when I actually work and since I'm ain't greedy or pretentious this allows me plenty of time to play online chess. I guess I'll just have to learn to live with the pity of "normal" people.
Aw c'mon marauder, I'm just bustin' yer balls. No need to boost up your self-confidence on my account.

D

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
1983
Clock
23 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darvlay
From the thread "who america will attack next"

Originally posted by Dodger11
[b]Anyone we want, Tuco. Hahahahahahahaahaha...and there's nothing you fuktarded little third world turd guzzlers can do about it, hahahahahahaha America Roo00OOOOLZ, get used to it, stupid.


perhaps ivangrice has been right all along?[/b]
hahahahha mi-tee funny !!! I can't believe you'd look that up or be aware of it. I roo00OOOOOL!

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darvlay
From the thread "who america will attack next"

Originally posted by Dodger11
[b]Anyone we want, Tuco. Hahahahahahahaahaha...and there's nothing you fuktarded little third world turd guzzlers can do about it, hahahahahahaha America Roo00OOOOLZ, get used to it, stupid.


perhaps ivangrice has been right all along?[/b]
As Dodger11 is not a chess player (0 moves) or intelligent in any way, shape or form but a mere internet troll or second account, this discussion does not apply to him/her/it.

K

Bannedtown, TX

Joined
11 Nov 04
Moves
77
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Decanter
So... is it time to set aside this particular misconception? Are good chess players REALLY smarter than the average person... or are good players JUST good chess players?[/b]
Chess players as a group are smarter than the population as a whole.
Bridge players as a group are smarter than chess players as a group.

c
Islamofascists Suck!

Macon, Georgia, CSA

Joined
17 Feb 02
Moves
32132
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darvlay
From the thread "who america will attack next"

Originally posted by Dodger11
[b]Anyone we want, Tuco. Hahahahahahahaahaha...and there's nothing you fuktarded little third world turd guzzlers can do about it, hahahahahahaha America Roo00OOOOLZ, get used to it, stupid.


perhaps ivangrice has been right all along?[/b]
pretty good, there, d 😲 😵 😉

S
BentnevolentDictater

x10,y45,z-88,t3.1415

Joined
26 Jan 03
Moves
1644
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Relativity. Are chess players as smart as ... "What?"

I'm about half as smart as Einstein. He played chess only as a last resort. If there was not a violin to play or a person to meet.

I have often wondered about "IQ". I came to the conclusion a few years back that "smartness" is probably an "accumulation of natural and learned talent that add up to an ability to test new ideas in several ways."

Language + Math + Spatial Awareness + Time Cognative Awareness + Body Control + Short Term Memory + Factual Integration + Mid Term Memory + Long Term Memory + Short/Mid/Long Term Thought and Memory Retrieval + Associative Awareness + Ability To Discard + Attentive Devotion Quotient + Relational Accumulative Ability

Don't worry if you can't find this on the net anywhere. These are just my categories that I have invented to describe parts of "intelligence".

I think that Chess players probably are "deformed" in some ways. They have an amazing ability in the "Spacial Relations" and "Memory Retrieval" areas but are alarmingly lacking in the "Factual Integration" and "Ability To Discard" areas.

Maybe. And this is the key. I don't have the intellectual capital to make any of these ideas anything more than "interesting" or "silly".

Alas.

g

Joined
29 Jul 01
Moves
8818
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Both Fischer and Kramnik have been asked what skills are needed to play chess well. A person's I.Q. was not a part of their answer. I do not remember thier answer, but a good memory (Doh) and problem solving skills were in both of thier answer.

D

Joined
18 Sep 03
Moves
17220
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by gambit3
Both Fischer and Kramnik have been asked what skills are needed to play chess well. A person's I.Q. was not a part of their answer. I do not remember thier answer, but a good memory (Doh) and problem solving skills were in both of thier answer.
I think there's no question that playing chess requires deductive reasoning capacity and some degree of creative thought, but I've actually encountered people (especially on RHP) who react negatively to anyone who questions the opinion of a high ranking player.

The insinuation (and some people have said it outright) is that higher ranking players are smarter than we are and we should just accept what they say. I've also noticed a number of players who are painfully detailed in describing their level of education, which seems a little odd given that no one talks at length about their personal lives or their careers... why SPECIFICALLY their education? Is it to imply that they're good chess players, or that they believe themselves to be AS SMART as a good chess player?

I'm not trying to question anyone's intelligence. I just think that there's an interesting group dynamic at play, which seems to be based largely upon the perception that the higher the rank, the smarter the player. I've seen several trends among the members here, but that certainly isn't one of them.

D

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
1983
Clock
24 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Dodger11
There is a loose correlation between chess ability and IQ, but it's not absolute. A lot of very intelligent people are mediocre chess players,no matter how hard they study, and some dull-normal types can be quite good at chess with a small amount of effort. Among the top-notch players however, there is no doubt that it takes a superior intellect. (excluding idiot-savants, and I don't know of any in the chess world, has anyone here heard of one?)
Let's try this again....there are idiot-savants that can multiply 10 digit numers in their their head, or tell you what day january 10, 1742 fell on in an instant. Has there ever been a chess idiot savant? I'm just curious, because I've never heard of one.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.