04 Dec 07
Originally posted by pkpowersDark side of the moon is a great album. Yes.
Also I second "The darkside of the moon" as top album ever
But, it also has various weaknesses, obviously discluding it from a top album...
1. The lyrics are rubbish (I would have put this a little clearer, but censorship stops me from doing so, needless to say though it had to do with bodily excrement).
2. The sound is polished. What? Polished? Yes. So completely polished it shines like a crazy diamond, which, incidently wasn't even on that album...
3. "Animals", "Wish you were here" and "The wall" were better albums. Although I would even go as far to say that "Umaguma" better was...
Better tunes, less polishing, better solos and FAR better lyrics.
So, if any Pink Floyd album should be in ANY top then, it's not the commercial "Dark side of the moon".
In fact, I'd even go so far to ask: "Is there really a dark side of the bloody moon."
!
04 Dec 07
Originally posted by shavixmirAgreed. DSotM isn't my fav Floyd album either. I like Animals much better.
Dark side of the moon is a great album. Yes.
But, it also has various weaknesses, obviously discluding it from a top album...
1. The lyrics are rubbish (I would have put this a little clearer, but censorship stops me from doing so, needless to say though it had to do with bodily excrement).
2. The sound is polished. What? Polished? Yes. So complet ...[text shortened]... 'd even go so far to ask: "Is there really a dark side of the bloody moon."
!
You forgot Meddle (maybe you didn't forget).
04 Dec 07
Originally posted by rbmorrisI actually LOVE the A-side of Meddle (or the first half if you're into the whole CD malarky).
Agreed. DSotM isn't my fav Floyd album either. I like Animals much better.
You forgot Meddle (maybe you didn't forget).
The last song though... yeah... cool... but it drags on a bit...
04 Dec 07
1) A Quick One - The Who
2) Aftermath - The Rolling Stones
3) Revolver - The Beatles
4) Bayou Country - Creedence Clearwater Revival
5) Unhalfbricking - Fairport Convention
6) Deep Purple in Rock - Deep Purple
7) Hawkwind - Hawkwind
8) Strange Days - The Doors
9) After Bathing at Baxters - Jefferson Airplane
10) The Doughnut in Granny's Greenhouse - Bonzo Dog Doo Dah Band
05 Dec 07
Originally posted by shavixmirWell put.
Dark side of the moon is a great album. Yes.
But, it also has various weaknesses, obviously discluding it from a top album...
1. The lyrics are rubbish (I would have put this a little clearer, but censorship stops me from doing so, needless to say though it had to do with bodily excrement).
2. The sound is polished. What? Polished? Yes. So complet ...[text shortened]... 'd even go so far to ask: "Is there really a dark side of the bloody moon."
!
Favourite PF works:
1) A Saucerful of Secrets.
2) The Piper at the Gates of Dawn.
3) Pink Floyd: Live at Pompeii (not an album, I know)
05 Dec 07
Originally posted by PalynkaShav wouldn't know good music if it smacked him in the ear. Anyone that's into Bruce Springsteen, Abba and Boney M and has an opinion he wants heard on Pink Floyd should be made deaf by piercing his ear drums with a gramophone stylus.
Well put.
Favourite PF works:
1) A Saucerful of Secrets.
2) The Piper at the Gates of Dawn.
3) Pink Floyd: Live at Pompeii (not an album, I know)
05 Dec 07
1 edit
Originally posted by darvlayEchoes is brilliant. I hesitated to include Meddle there in third spot, but since the live version in Live at Pompeii is so good, I decided to put that one instead. Have you seen this video?
Meddle is my personal favourite PF album. Actually, it's the only PF album that I never tire of.
I don't like any PF from DSoTM (including) onwards .