Go back
Quick novice question

Quick novice question

Only Chess

l

Milton Keynes, UK

Joined
28 Jul 04
Moves
81593
Clock
22 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sjeg
The Queen even I can do. I'd be happy to try with two Bishops. One Knight and one Bishop sounds a nightmare.

But mate with one rook is possible, but tricky?

EDIT: Basically, the one Rook ++ is the most difficult? When I learnt from a tiny paper-back book and a plastic chess set, I read that a valuation of the pieces can be set very basically at:

1 poin ...[text shortened]... B;
5 for R;
10 for Q.

So by that, rook is the most bloody difficult. Is that about right?
Here is a recent game where I mated with a rook. It isn't hard once you know how to do it.

Game 1817989

EDIT: Found a better example which shows how to push the king to the edge of the board.

Game 1594528

T

Joined
20 Dec 05
Moves
12772
Clock
22 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Varenka,

You are, of course, correct. I was assuming best defence.

T
Full speed locomotiv

On tracks.

Joined
03 Oct 04
Moves
12831
Clock
22 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sjeg
The Queen even I can do. I'd be happy to try with two Bishops. One Knight and one Bishop sounds a nightmare.

But mate with one rook is possible, but tricky?

EDIT: Basically, the one Rook ++ is the most difficult? When I learnt from a tiny paper-back book and a plastic chess set, I read that a valuation of the pieces can be set very basically at:

1 poin ...[text shortened]... B;
5 for R;
10 for Q.

So by that, rook is the most bloody difficult. Is that about right?
Nine for a queen, nine.

m
Y.N.W.A

Athens

Joined
05 Dec 05
Moves
24586
Clock
22 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sjeg
What's the minimum you can ++ with on a board with only another king against you?

e.g. your King plus one Rook, versus another King- is it possible to mate, or only draw?
I knew you could do it, but i made a bit of a mess of it. It was the first time i've ever been in that situation so i've learn from my error.

Game 1681285

T

Somewhere out there!

Joined
09 Nov 04
Moves
2700
Clock
22 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by millerman
I knew you could do it, but i made a bit of a mess of it. It was the first time i've ever been in that situation so i've learn from my error.

Game 1681285
you did not really bad, but on move 78 you simply missed mate by Ra7, it won't get more easy then that XD

m
Y.N.W.A

Athens

Joined
05 Dec 05
Moves
24586
Clock
22 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Testrider
you did not really bad, but on move 78 you simply missed mate by Ra7, it won't get more easy then that XD
Thanks Testrider, i had to look again to see where i missed it. It's so obvious now in hindsight, thanks for pointing it out to me.

s

Et in Arcadia ego...

Joined
02 Feb 05
Moves
1666
Clock
23 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lausey
Here is a recent game where I mated with a rook. It isn't hard once you know how to do it.

Game 1817989

EDIT: Found a better example which shows how to push the king to the edge of the board.

Game 1594528
Woo hoo- I see the technique you were all trying to explain to me now. Thanks to all of you. It's pretty simple. I don't know why, but when first puzzled, I thought of pinning using the rook beside the king, but no mate there.

Then a lightbuld- trap the king in the corner. That was when i thought I had got it. Then i read your posts, mystified- but that second game lausey posted shows the technique clearly. Thanks again.

sjeg

d

Joined
12 Jun 05
Moves
14671
Clock
23 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sjeg
Woo hoo- I see the technique you were all trying to explain to me now. Thanks to all of you. It's pretty simple. I don't know why, but when first puzzled, I thought of pinning using the rook beside the king, but no mate there.

Then a lightbuld- trap the king in the corner. That was when i thought I had got it. Then i read your posts, mystified- but that second game lausey posted shows the technique clearly. Thanks again.

sjeg
Indeed. That second example is worth 1,000 words.

Particularly if those words are mine.

E3

Joined
29 Jun 05
Moves
6907
Clock
23 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sjeg
What's the minimum you can ++ with on a board with only another king against you?

e.g. your King plus one Rook, versus another King- is it possible to mate, or only draw?
In fact, to show how strong the Rook actually is, with K & R v K it is possible to force mate on any particular edge square that is desig-nated. Not of any practical use in play, but is an amusing and not very difficult puzzle.

y

Mumbai, India

Joined
12 Oct 05
Moves
5445
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

K
Mel Kirwan

Hauxton

Joined
20 Nov 05
Moves
17764
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

K
Mel Kirwan

Hauxton

Joined
20 Nov 05
Moves
17764
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sorry. Meant to say black to mate in three moves

K
Mel Kirwan

Hauxton

Joined
20 Nov 05
Moves
17764
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sorry. Meant to say black to mate in three moves

K
Mel Kirwan

Hauxton

Joined
20 Nov 05
Moves
17764
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm not very good at this I'm afraid.

I think K + 2N v K is a draw. If the defending side has a pawn it can be won but not in 50 moves. I think FIDE changed the law in that position so you have to mate in 100 moves instead. Then again I could have dreamt all that.

Sorry again.

E3

Joined
29 Jun 05
Moves
6907
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Kirwan
I'm not very good at this I'm afraid.

I think K + 2N v K is a draw. If the defending side has a pawn it can be won but not in 50 moves. I think FIDE changed the law in that position so you have to mate in 100 moves instead. Then again I could have dreamt all that.

Sorry again.
Yes,K+2n cannot force mate, although if the weaker side makes a mistake mate is possible. Some K+2n v K+P can be won

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.