Originally posted by Shinidoki
the tablebases the website I have only allowed me to look at the position a pawn down, so, in awnser of your question, i've no idea.
but here's my logic;
1. If a pawn is lost (any white pawn) the game is drawn.
see: http://www.shredderchess.com/online-chess/online-databases/endgame-database.html
2. so for the win, white must hold both pawns ...[text shortened]... t black having a pawn, which restricts the kings movesment would be [b]EVEN MORE DRAWN?[/b]
I am with you in your reasoning, I will analise with him again tomorrow and post the result here, since i was unable to prove him the position was draw.