Blood transfusion risk? God knew this long before man..

Originally posted by galveston75
And that's you opinion which there is over 7 billion of them on this planet. I don't worry about anyones opinion when it comes down to the Bible and God's commands. I only worry about his.

yes, that is why there should be laws in place to protect the innocent (your hypothetical or not children) from people who do not worry about anyone's opinion but what they think is god's will


i find no difference between a jw refusing to allow a doctor to do a life saving transfusion on his son or daughter and the psychopath who murders his family because a voice identifying itself as god commanded him to.

both should be imprisoned/hospitalized and the children taken away.

Originally posted by galveston75
And that's you opinion which there is over 7 billion of them on this planet. I don't worry about anyones opinion when it comes down to the Bible and God's commands. I only worry about his.

I think you are really worried about the Watchtower and your fellow JW's opinions. 😏

Originally posted by galveston75
Don't believe I ever said that either.

So you admit that doctors have limited time, yet insist they resort to more time consuming treatments instead of spending that time to help more people?

Originally posted by Vartiovuori
So you admit that doctors have limited time, yet insist they resort to more time consuming treatments instead of spending that time to help more people?

How do you know those alternative treatments take longer? Please expalin your knowledge on this subject....

-Removed-

I can't tell you how God views you and your wife's decisions on anything. That is between you two and God.

Originally posted by galveston75
I can't tell you how God views you and your wife's decisions on anything. That is between you two and God.

come now, don't be shy. please let us know how blood transfusion is a sin. how someone choosing to have blood transfusion and preserve the precious life that god gave us, which is his own command, is a sinner.


please let us know how the jws can suggest to a fellow man to die, rather than accept blood from a brother. how blood is precious, but the life of a human isn't. how blood is to be thrown away rather than given to another person as a gift. how people who donate blood are damned.

Originally posted by galveston75
I can't tell you how God views you and your wife's decisions on anything. That is between you two and God.

You say this, and yet it's interesting that you do NOT think you and your wife's decisions on things like this are just "between you two and God", indeed you choose to tell us how God views them.

Originally posted by FMF
You say this, and yet it's interesting that you do NOT think you and your wife's decisions on things like this are just "between you two and God", indeed you choose to tell us how God views them.

And that's a bad thing? Is learning about God not good?

Originally posted by Zahlanzi
come now, don't be shy. please let us know how blood transfusion is a sin. how someone choosing to have blood transfusion and preserve the precious life that god gave us, which is his own command, is a sinner.


please let us know how the jws can suggest to a fellow man to die, rather than accept blood from a brother. how blood is precious, but the ...[text shortened]... wn away rather than given to another person as a gift. how people who donate blood are damned.

You got the only answer you are going to get from me. If you want more, read your bible.

Originally posted by galveston75
How do you know those alternative treatments take longer? Please expalin your knowledge on this subject....

You yourself said "Thanks for your honest answers. Also if one were to look at those links and even other info on the actual need for a transfusion when that decision is made by a doctor, it is said that many times blood is the quick fix but actually not needed. It is more convienient to do that instead of the doctors taking their time and using the blood alternatives."

This clearly implies that they take longer, no?

Originally posted by galveston75
And that's a bad thing? Is learning about God not good?

Perhaps you did not understand what I said?

You: "I can't tell you how God views you and your wife's decisions on anything. That is between you two and God."

But you reckon you CAN tell us how God views YOUR decisions. It seems, in your case, that is NOT between you and God.

In one case [your own] you seek, effectively, to tell us God's views on you on this issue. In another case [divegeester's] you suddenly don't know what God's views are on this issue. One matter is between a person and God, but when that person is you, the matter is not between you and God, it is aired publicly and you seek to speak for God.

And, lo and behold, you inform us that God approves of you and your decision about blood. What is more, in your view, us listening to you, is us "learning about God". And yet, you "can't tell [divegeester] how God views [him]". Indeed, when you suggest you offer "learning about God" what you actually mean is that you offer 'learning about how you have declared that God endorses your views'.

Strikes me as a dodger & deflector's way of passing judgement - in a furtive, passive aggressive way.

-Removed-

It is not likely he will read it and learn the truth. It would be just as unusual as what happened to this man and his wife after all those years of taking orders from the watchtower.