Originally posted by stellspalfieA baby can not sin, so the baby can't be a sinner. A baby just does what babies do. So your belief is wrong.
[b]"What I believe is that if babies [b]die with cancer, then it is because they are sinners.[/b]
are you saying that not all babies are born with sin or that all babies are born with sin? if it is the latter and all babies are born with sin then why do some get cancer and some not?[/b]
A baby being born with cancer is no different from a baby born with spherocytosis. It is hereditary in both cases.
Natural history of hereditary spherocytosis during the first year of life
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10627440
Cancer is an aberration and part of the curse of the fall and the curse extends to the creation as well. Any human born is a son or daughter of Adam and hence have the sin nature or propensity to sin and will eventually sin. However I don't think God is punishing anyone even a child if they get cancer although He allows it to happen. This however is where I just trust God and His sovereignty as I believe God is good and just. However I can't answer for God in this area. He does promise that one day He will erase the curse and make all things new and this old order of things will be no more. No more death or evil or entropy
Manny
Fabian,
If cancer is evil when it is based on judgement, then is Life without parol evil for judging murder? Is jail time evil for judging theft? Is then man evil because of incarceration of criminals? Should we let murderers go free to continue murdering? If not, then why should we not be warned about God's ability to judge us for our sin?
Originally posted by KingOnPointYou start with a condition "If cancer is evil". Then the rest of you question make sense only if I agree with your condition. I don't.
Fabian,
If cancer is evil when it is based on judgement, then is Life without parol evil for judging murder? Is jail time evil for judging theft? Is then man evil because of incarceration of criminals? Should we let murderers go free to continue murdering? If not, then why should we not be warned about God's ability to judge us for our sin?
Cancer is mindless, it cannot punish anyone, it does not say that this person deserves to die.
But the creator of cancer if evil if it was created with the purpous to punish a sinner. And as everyone are sinners, then cancer can punish everyone. That's the reason that cancer exists. Says some cristians. I don't agree.
So forgive me not to answer the rest of your question because I cannot believe and worship an evil god. And only an evil god can create cancer. So you really have to ask someone else this question.
Originally posted by FabianFnasGod did not create cancer, numbnuts! Genesis chapter 1 tells us what God created and it was all good. Read it, numbnuts!
You start with a condition "If cancer is evil". Then the rest of you question make sense only if I agree with your condition. I don't.
Cancer is mindless, it cannot punish anyone, it does not say that this person deserves to die.
But the creator of cancer if evil if it was created with the purpous to punish a sinner. And as everyone are sinners, the ...[text shortened]... d. And only an evil god can create cancer. So you really have to ask someone else this question.
Originally posted by RJHindsDoes it say, dumbnut, everything that he didn't create, dumbnut? Don't you know your own dumbnut bible? Or didn't you find andy youtube about it, dumbnut?
God did not create cancer, numbnuts! Genesis chapter 1 tells us what God created and it was all good. Read it, numbnuts!
Originally posted by RJHindsDoes it really say that in the dumbnut bible, dumbnut? Read it again, dumbnut, and give the dumbnut ref again, dumbnut.
Yes, numbnuts. Everything that is not good, God did not create. So is cancer good or evil?
Or you can just grow up some.
Originally posted by RJHindsWhy don't we turn over a new leaf going into the high holy days, and cease with the disparaging name calling of one another. It benefits no one, and effects your witness. Just a thought.
Yes, numbnuts. Everything that is not good, God did not create. So is cancer good or evil?