Go back
JWs and blood transfusions

JWs and blood transfusions

Spirituality

menace71
Can't win a game of

38N Lat X 121W Lon

Joined
03 Apr 03
Moves
155417
Clock
28 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

I do think the dodging is silly ......Example -- Question: G-75 is the sky blue? Answer: G-75 how about them Yankees ? LOL or when presented with a question answering the question with a question which can be appropriate at times but not always ....He asked me a hypothetical question and I answered it of course I flipped back also to see how G-Man would answer it which is fair.....however normal conversation is hard when things are being dodged or other questions are being thrown out there and also the confusing of issues

Manny

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by menace71
One thing we agree on there R.C. .....sounds disgusting the blood foods 🙂


Manny
I seen them make the stuff, they pour blood into a big vat and then other stuff, its disgusting, but people like to eat it!

menace71
Can't win a game of

38N Lat X 121W Lon

Joined
03 Apr 03
Moves
155417
Clock
28 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I seen them make the stuff, they pour blood into a big vat and then other stuff, its disgusting, but people like to eat it!
Kinda like hotdogs .......which at least in the past was all of the left over scraps from other meats and foods ....and it contained things like insects ground up and who knows what else ......there is a big movement over here in the states for organic foods and higher quality meats and all......my big thing for the past 2 years is growing tomatoes and peppers and Zucchini and squash and various things like that .....nothing like a fresh tomato ..... Can you grow tomatoes in Scotland with any success ?

Manny

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
28 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by menace71
Kinda like hotdogs .......which at least in the past was all of the left over scraps from other meats and foods ....and it contained things like insects ground up and who knows what else ......there is a big movement over here in the states for organic foods and higher quality meats and all......my big thing for the past 2 years is growing tomatoes and pepp ...[text shortened]... nothing like a fresh tomato ..... Can you grow tomatoes in Scotland with any success ?

Manny
yes i grew them this year but you need a greenhouse and fortunately for me i have one, they were beautiful liitle cherry tomatoes. I also grew strawberries and raspberries 😀

divegeester

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120150
Clock
29 Sep 14
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I seen them make the stuff, they pour blood into a big vat and then other stuff, its disgusting, but people like to eat it!
How disgusting does it have to be before it's ok to let the child die?

64squaresofpain
The drunk knight

Stuck on g1

Joined
02 Sep 12
Moves
59488
Clock
29 Sep 14

Oh jeez, not this again.

Thread 159181

We've all been here before, giving the same arguments,
and not showing any sign of any real appreciation for the opposition,
but instead resort to mocking and probing one another's intelligence.

Do yourselves HUGE favours and end this foolishness already!

You're NEVER gonna make the million move milestone if you spend all your time and energy on here 😀

menace71
Can't win a game of

38N Lat X 121W Lon

Joined
03 Apr 03
Moves
155417
Clock
29 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've been trying to make the distinction between eating / drinking / whatever with blood and Transfusion as factually and scientifically they are not one and the same .....JWs seem to blur the two together but you know I acknowledge they have the right to believe what they will .....


Manny

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
29 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by menace71
I acknowledge they have the right to believe what they will .....
I agree. But if they seek to make a human sacrifice of their children to please their God figure, then I support the state stepping in.

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78874
Clock
29 Sep 14
1 edit

Originally posted by menace71
I've been trying to make the distinction between eating / drinking / whatever with blood and Transfusion as factually and scientifically they are not one and the same .....JWs seem to blur the two together but you know I acknowledge they have the right to believe what they will .....


Manny
But should it be blurred? Can you honestly say that there is really a differenace?
First point blank the blood is "entering your body" and if it has some dangerous diseases in it, could it not still infect you? Of course and probably would be more dangerous if it was directly put into you veins as stomach acids sometimes kills bacteria.
If you swallowed poison of some kind or injected it into you veins..same result, right? It's in you body and has the same affect.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
30 Sep 14

Originally posted by galveston75
But should it be blurred? Can you honestly say that there is really a differenace?
First point blank the blood is "entering your body" and if it has some dangerous diseases in it, could it not still infect you? Of course and probably would be more dangerous if it was directly put into you veins as stomach acids sometimes kills bacteria.
If you swallo ...[text shortened]... ind or injected it into you veins..same result, right? It's in you body and has the same affect.
A blood transfusion is not the same as "if you swallowed poison".

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78874
Clock
30 Sep 14

Originally posted by FMF
A blood transfusion is not the same as "if you swallowed poison".
Whatever. You obviously are ignoring just common sense examples and are here only to argue.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
30 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
Whatever. You obviously are ignoring just common sense examples and are here only to argue.
On the contrary. Your stance is not common sensical. Your "common sense" examples come across as you fumbling to defend a bizarre point of view. Just offer up the best bible verse you have - not one about animal blood or pagan rites - but one about life-saving blood transfusions.

RJHinds
The Near Genius

Fort Gordon

Joined
24 Jan 11
Moves
13644
Clock
30 Sep 14

Originally posted by galveston75
But should it be blurred? Can you honestly say that there is really a differenace?
First point blank the blood is "entering your body" and if it has some dangerous diseases in it, could it not still infect you? Of course and probably would be more dangerous if it was directly put into you veins as stomach acids sometimes kills bacteria.
If you swallo ...[text shortened]... ind or injected it into you veins..same result, right? It's in you body and has the same affect.
Blood is not given willy nilly. It is given only when it is believed necessary to save the life of someone who has lost too much blood and is in danger of death. Surely, blood should be checked to make sure it is the proper type and is free from disease. Otherwise, it could defeat the purpose of giving it.

menace71
Can't win a game of

38N Lat X 121W Lon

Joined
03 Apr 03
Moves
155417
Clock
30 Sep 14

Originally posted by galveston75
But should it be blurred? Can you honestly say that there is really a differenace?
First point blank the blood is "entering your body" and if it has some dangerous diseases in it, could it not still infect you? Of course and probably would be more dangerous if it was directly put into you veins as stomach acids sometimes kills bacteria.
If you swallo ...[text shortened]... ind or injected it into you veins..same result, right? It's in you body and has the same affect.
Think about it for a minute .....blood belongs where ? Easy answer in your veins ( we all agree there is a small risk in receiving blood ) However you can get a disease by ingesting bad food or breathing in air and your right you could get a disease by drinking infected blood so what ? Scientifically receiving blood into your veins is very different from eating or drinking blood. They are different things NOT the same!! If you were to eat or drink blood it would go through the digestive process and apparently humans are not very good and digesting blood ( Not like true carnivores Lions for example ) and too much iron can cause iron poisoning. I disagree with you on this .....you ingest food to be digested but that is not the same as receiving blood into your veins

Manny

menace71
Can't win a game of

38N Lat X 121W Lon

Joined
03 Apr 03
Moves
155417
Clock
30 Sep 14

Originally posted by RJHinds
Blood is not given willy nilly. It is given only when it is believed necessary to save the life of someone who has lost too much blood and is in danger of death. Surely, blood should be checked to make sure it is the proper type and is free from disease. Otherwise, it could defeat the purpose of giving it.
Agreed also .....Blood is not just handed out like candy ...haha man .....The blood has to matched properly and people receive it when their situation is dire.

Manny

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.