We don't know what is going on now, or what happened, or what happens next. Therefore we need gods.
But we have studied existence and history and science, and the need for gods is fading. Gods are nowhere to be found. No talking snakes or parting seas are happening anymore. No virgin births or real miracles anywhere except in the mythic past.
The mythic past is just from our memories when we were ignorant but were showing signs of brilliance. To shine brighter, we should realize that childhood fantasies are useful until we are ready to leave them behind.
We have so many things to figure out right here in the real world. Unless your gods are natural, they are not showing up to help us. We are happy to use belief in gods to kill and war and hate, That seems to take little effort. Peace and love are harder, but we are forcing the old ways to conform.
Haters need the old testament. Good but old people need the new testament. Young people need something else.
20 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathistYour 'given' is false, therefore the rest of your argument goes nowhere.
We don't know what is going on now, or what happened, or what happens next. Therefore we need gods.
But we have studied existence and history and science, and the need for gods is fading. Gods are nowhere to be found. No talking snakes or parting seas are happening anymore. No virgin births or real miracles anywhere except in the mythic past.
The myt ...[text shortened]... the old testament. Good but old people need the new testament. Young people need something else.
20 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathistTrue religion is about love and life, the hate and death around us shows us how much it is needed.
We don't know what is going on now, or what happened, or what happens next. Therefore we need gods.
But we have studied existence and history and science, and the need for gods is fading. Gods are nowhere to be found. No talking snakes or parting seas are happening anymore. No virgin births or real miracles anywhere except in the mythic past.
The myt ...[text shortened]... the old testament. Good but old people need the new testament. Young people need something else.
- Joined
- 29 Dec 08
- Moves
- 6788
20 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathist"Unless your gods are natural, they are not showing up to help us"
We don't know what is going on now, or what happened, or what happens next. Therefore we need gods.
But we have studied existence and history and science, and the need for gods is fading. Gods are nowhere to be found. No talking snakes or parting seas are happening anymore. No virgin births or real miracles anywhere except in the mythic past.
The myt ...[text shortened]... the old testament. Good but old people need the new testament. Young people need something else.
I think the early Christian scholars recognized this in John 1:14: "And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us..."
There has to be a meeting place in the natural world where the natural and supernatural interact. Originally it was Eden, but that was lost. The scholars recognized this problem and fixed it in the scriptures - under divine guidance, or so they believed.
There are other points were the supernatural enters the realm of its creation, according to some, they occur in the rituals of sacraments, others involve mushrooms and such.
Plus you are right; we need the eggs.
[/bloviating]
20 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathistWhen you say "we" you mean other people wag more intelligent than you.
We don't know what is going on now, or what happened, or what happens next. Therefore we need gods.
But we have studied existence and history and science, and the need for gods is fading. Gods are nowhere to be found. No talking snakes or parting seas are happening anymore. No virgin births or real miracles anywhere except in the mythic past.
The myt ...[text shortened]... the old testament. Good but old people need the new testament. Young people need something else.
Originally posted by apathist"Young people need something else."
We don't know what is going on now, or what happened, or what happens next. Therefore we need gods.
But we have studied existence and history and science, and the need for gods is fading. Gods are nowhere to be found. No talking snakes or parting seas are happening anymore. No virgin births or real miracles anywhere except in the mythic past.
The myt ...[text shortened]... the old testament. Good but old people need the new testament. Young people need something else.
Ya, they need the same thing as everyone else. Less religion and a relationship with Jesus Christ.
Originally posted by josephwSpirituality is what may help, and it isn't limited to your religion. I think your religion impedes spirituality, since it condemns all non-christians. Your group is special, right?
"Young people need something else."
Ya, they need the same thing as everyone else. Less religion and a relationship with Jesus Christ.
Originally posted by EladarNot a new realization, it is just that my skepticism has less and less to hold on to. There is something hateful and wrong about the abrahamic religions. I believe we should stop pretending otherwise.
Is this a recent realization for you? I figured that this has been one of your beliefs from the very start.
21 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathistI don't do religion. Get that through your thick skull.
Spirituality is what may help, and it isn't limited to your religion. I think your religion impedes spirituality, since it condemns all non-christians. Your group is special, right?
Jesus is special, and no one else. He lives.
True Christianity isn't about condemning. It's about the truth.
Originally posted by josephwWhat exactly is a relationship with Jesus Christ? Because nowhere does Jesus say any such thing about having a relationship with him, and neither does the Apostles.
[b]"Young people need something else."
Ya, they need the same thing as everyone else. Less religion and a relationship with Jesus Christ.[/b]
I notice you say / support several doctrines which are not in the Bible eg
- Jesus was born without sin.
- When good people die they go to heaven.
- That the wicked are tormented in hell forever.
.. just to name a few
So if you want a Bible reader [as opposed to a church goer] to understand what a relationship with Jesus Christ is maybe you can explain it.
Oh ... by the way your father-in-law was trying to speak to you in another thread. Makes me wonder if he is your family and he cannot speak to you privately and needs to resort to talking to you on a public forum then I would guess you guys have serious communication issues. I suggest you have some more respect for the man 🙂
21 Apr 17
Originally posted by josephwI already nailed that. Your Jesus is nowhere in reality. Everyone not in your group is doomed to Hell, right?
I don't do religion. Get that through your thick skull.
Jesus is special, and no one else. He lives.
True Christianity isn't about condemning. It's about the truth.
21 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathistYou know the drill. Jesus is the way, the truth and the life. Without Jesus there is no life.
I already nailed that. Your Jesus is nowhere in reality. Everyone not in your group is doomed to Hell, right?
Jesus is alive and you have no evidence to the contrary. Eternal life is being offered to you, but you'd rather live in the dark not knowing where you're going after you die.
Quit lying to yourself. You have no assurance of anything except you know you're going to die. Go ahead and believe there's nothing after death even though you know you don't know for sure what's next.
21 Apr 17
Originally posted by apathistNo, there is nothing that condemns us other than our own sins. When we hate another,
Spirituality is what may help, and it isn't limited to your religion. I think your religion impedes spirituality, since it condemns all non-christians. Your group is special, right?
when we speak bad about another, when we do not keep our words, when we treat others
badly, when we condemn others for things we do, and things like that, that will condemn us.
The thing about Christianity is that God reached down to mankind to help, He either did
that or we would all be condemn with no hope. Jesus came to save sinners, not some
special group of people better than others. So when you think about Christians, do not
think we are better than anyone else we are not. The one thing that sets us apart is not
something we can take credit for, it is Jesus Christ who died for us so we could be
forgiven than rose from the dead so we could live with God forever.
If you got other ways to God, other spiritual paths, unless God accepts them they are only
as good as their sources. With Christianity, God is the source.