Suicide on 9/11 - Damned?

Originally posted by no1marauder
I know all about logic; use some. Show why the premise that someone jumping from the 90th floor of a building knowing that they will die immediately above hitting the ground is committing suicide is "absurd and ridiculous". In order to do so, you will have to draw a valid distinction between the motive of these unfortunate people who were in such a po ...[text shortened]... ugh no fault of their own and choose to avoid suffering, both by immediately ending their lives.

marauder: "I know all about logic; ... "

ROTFLMSO 😀

Originally posted by no1marauder
Again, no logic. Do you even know what it is?

Who marauder, is on your fundamentalist side ?

Originally posted by ivanhoe
ROTFLMSO 😀

I know one person who won't be guessing what that stands for.

Goodnight.

Originally posted by ivanhoe
marauder: "I know all about logic; ... "

ROTFLMSO 😀

Grow up, jerkwad. You've stooped down to the level of your friend Darfius:

Those in the WTC did not want to die. It was foisted upon them by terrorists. I will repeat this until you concede or give up, like you do.

Are you simply going to repeat the same thing over and over again without ever logically justifying your absurd position?

Originally posted by no1marauder
I know all about logic; use some. Show why the premise that someone jumping from the 90th floor of a building knowing that they will die immediately above hitting the ground is committing suicide is "absurd and ridiculous". In order to do so, you will have to draw a valid distinction between the motive of these unfortunate people who were in such a po ...[text shortened]... ugh no fault of their own and choose to avoid suffering, both by immediately ending their lives.

Well since you know everything about logic you must be very capable to do this yourself.

Consider it homework ...... lol ..... 😛

Originally posted by ivanhoe
Who marauder, is on your fundamentalist side ?

I'm presenting a position; you're presenting childish insults. Grow up.

Originally posted by ivanhoe
Well since you know everything about logic you must be very capable to do this yourself.

Consider it homework ...... lol ..... 😛

I'll take that as you have no logical reason to differentiate the two cases. Maybe you should try actually coming up with some.

Originally posted by no1marauder
Show why that assumption is absurd.

The lady who jumped.
Were her intentions to kill herself or escape the heat?
If you would like to become a bookie then i would be so temped to put a lot of money on the later.You so stupid....i'm sure i would get good odds also.Yeah....i would put more money than that on where she now resides.🙂

Originally posted by no1marauder
Grow up, jerkwad. You've stooped down to the level of your friend Darfius:

Those in the WTC did not want to die. It was foisted upon them by terrorists. I will repeat this until you concede or give up, like you do.

Are you simply going to repeat the same thing over and over again without ever logically justifying your absurd position?

😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀


..... my absurd position ..... 😀 😀 😀

Who is supporting you in your reasonable and moderate view, marauder ? ..... The National Association Of People Who Like To Call Call Others Idiots, Jerkwads and Extremists" maybe ? ..... lol ............. 😀 😀 😀

Answer the question, you role-model of moderation ...... 😉

Originally posted by windmill
The lady who jumped.
Were her intentions to kill herself or escape the heat?
If you would like to become a bookie then i would be so temped to put a lot of money on the later.You so stupid....i'm sure i would get good odds also.Yeah....i would put more money than that on where she now resides.🙂

Her intention was to kill herself by jumping from the building rather than being burned alive. That is why she crossed herself; she knew she was going to die.

You're a teenager, aren't you? Your posts are very immature and lacking in logic. Ivanhoe's are too, but the words you use seem to indicate that you're an adolescent. Betcha I'm right about that.

Originally posted by no1marauder
I'm presenting a position; you're presenting childish insults. Grow up.

Are you hitting the bottle again, marauder ..... ?

Originally posted by ivanhoe
😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀


..... my absurd position ..... 😀 😀 😀

Who is supporting you in your reasonable and moderate view, marauder ? ..... The National Association Of People Who Like To Call Call Others Idiots, Jerkwads and Extremists" maybe ? ..... lol ............. 😀 😀 😀

Answer the question, you role-model of moderation ...... 😉

Very mature post.

As stated earlier, this is not a poll or a popularity contest. It is supposed to be a rational discussion. You refuse to take part in a rational discussion which would require logically defending your positions. Instead, you have dropped back into your inevitable rant and rave mode about other people. You need some serious help; maybe RB could light a candle for ya.

Originally posted by no1marauder
Very mature post.

As stated earlier, this is not a poll or a popularity contest. It is supposed to be a rational discussion. You refuse to take part in a rational discussion which would require logically defending your positions. Instead, you have dropped back into your inevitable rant and rave mode about other people. You need some serious help; maybe RB could light a candle for ya.

You really make me laugh, marauder .... you're so funny.

😀 😵 😀



EDIT: C'mon, who is with you on this ?

Originally posted by ivanhoe
Are you hitting the bottle again, marauder ..... ?

Could you at least try not to be an a**hole for a while? The thread is supposed to be a serious discussion on the issue of suicide not yet another thread for you to pursue your childish, personal vendettas. Get back on topic and answer the points I've raised.

Originally posted by no1marauder
Could you at least try not to be an a**hole for a while? The thread is supposed to be a serious discussion on the issue of suicide not yet another thread for you to pursue your childish, personal vendettas. Get back on topic and answer the points I've raised.

YES, SIR ! ....... 😀 😀 😀