New idea for this forum

Originally posted by @padger
Take the football league
It is made up of matches ( challenges )
Goals ( games )
The current system is trying to make the best clan the one that scores the most goals
It should be the one that wins the most matches
There is not a league in the world that uses our system
Why ?
Because it doesn't make sense

Not a true analogy Padge.
Each pairing in a challenge is a "match."
The winning clan is the one that wins the most "matches"
How the points are allocated is a different issue.
Goals(games)?
So each "game" is 1-0 or 0-0
That's not how the football league(or any other league) works

Originally posted by @venda
Not a true analogy Padge.
Each pairing in a challenge is a "match."
The winning clan is the one that wins the most "matches"
How the points are allocated is a different issue.
Goals(games)?
So each "game" is 1-0 or 0-0
That's not how the football league(or any other league) works

You are twisting the facts
Each pairing = a goal either for or against

Originally posted by @padger
Take the football league
It is made up of matches ( challenges )
Goals ( games )
The current system is trying to make the best clan the one that scores the most goals
It should be the one that wins the most matches
There is not a league in the world that uses our system
Why ?
Because it doesn't make sense

Perhaps we should just agree that you are never going to be satisfied and move on?

Originally posted by @padger
You are twisting the facts
Each pairing = a goal either for or against

The current set up is accepted by the majority.
Once site dealt with the cheats, the remaining minor issues melted away.

Let's leave it be.

Originally posted by @mghrn55
The current set up is accepted by the majority.
Once site dealt with the cheats, the remaining minor issues melted away.

Let's leave it be.

No
I will never accept this as normal practice
It goes against all laws of logic

Originally posted by @venda
Not a true analogy Padge.
Each pairing in a challenge is a "match."
The winning clan is the one that wins the most "matches"
How the points are allocated is a different issue.
Goals(games)?
So each "game" is 1-0 or 0-0
That's not how the football league(or any other league) works

if you can explain how your clan got these points from these figures I will not try to change things
73 50 31 495 408 107 254 " 588 "

Originally posted by @padger
No
I will never accept this as normal practice
It goes against all laws of logic

So do your rantings

Originally posted by @padger
No
I will never accept this as normal practice
It goes against all laws of logic

Sigh. 😴

Originally posted by @shortcircuit
So do your rantings

If you can explain from these figures how you arrived at your total points I will not go on about how stupid the current system is
172 76 57 964 756 228 807 "1305"

Originally posted by @mghrn55
Sigh. 😴

You cannot explain how the total figures are accomplished
Therefor you can have any figure you like because you can't explain it can you ?

Originally posted by @padger
If you can explain from these figures how you arrived at your total points I will not go on about how stupid the current system is
172 76 57 964 756 228 807 "1305"

Couldn't be bothered.
Scoring system is arbitrary by design by site administration.

If the clan members oppose it enough, site will consider amending it.
If not, we have what we have.

The cheats have been dealt with.
Clan feature is back to normal with the occasional whine.

Originally posted by @mghrn55
Couldn't be bothered.
Scoring system is arbitrary by design by site administration.

If the clan members oppose it enough, site will consider amending it.
If not, we have what we have.

The cheats have been dealt with.
Clan feature is back to normal with the occasional whine.

You cannot solve it because it is rubbish
If you cannot back up a theory with a solid answer it proves that the theory ( in this case the clan scoring system ) is rubbish

Originally posted by @padger
You cannot solve it because it is rubbish
If you cannot back up a theory with a solid answer it proves that the theory ( in this case the clan scoring system ) is rubbish

There's nothing to solve.
Over !!

Originally posted by @mghrn55
There's nothing to solve.
Over !!

Why waste your time trying to explain anything to the thickest moron on here.
Must be brain damaged only logical explanation.
The term bell end does not even come close.

Originally posted by @roma45
Why waste your time trying to explain anything to the thickest moron on here.
Must be brain damaged only logical explanation.
The term bell end does not even come close.

Ha ! Captain Pugwash has woken up
He surely will explain how the end result is obtained or is he just as puzzled as the rest of us
If you cannot prove the last number
Why not just have any number you can think of ?