Go back
COVID Immunity - natural vs vaccine

COVID Immunity - natural vs vaccine

Debates

j

Joined
18 Jan 05
Moves
11601
Clock
01 Oct 21

@shavixmir said
You do know Australia have had multiple extreme lockdowns, don’t you?
"Still" having and the collateral damage is being ignored.

j

Joined
18 Jan 05
Moves
11601
Clock
01 Oct 21

@shavixmir said
🚨🚧moronity of Gop alert🚧🚨
I know 2 people that ended up in hospital overnight and my son was of work for a few days both jabs. My friend that went to hospital, with heart problems and was told 100% vax, and also told " you would not believe how many people we are seeing from this. I also know many with no side effect. To this day I know of no-one that knows anyone that has had covid. Lots of stories but nothing about anyone I know.

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22644
Clock
01 Oct 21

@jimmac said
Studies from Israel show that the long term benefits, of course for the vast majority that survive, from having covid are far better than the vax alone. Though I am reading that both is still best but who knows. I mean who knows not WHO knows, Lol.
What is your source of information.
Saying it isn't proving it. Prove it!

j

Joined
18 Jan 05
Moves
11601
Clock
01 Oct 21

@metal-brain said
What is your source of information.
Saying it isn't proving it. Prove it!
I am actually agreeing with you to a fair degree here. What exactly, that you do not already think, that you are wanting me to prove.

AverageJoe1
Catch the Train 47!

Lake Como

Joined
27 Jul 10
Moves
54603
Clock
01 Oct 21

@jimmac said
I live in Victoria, the " current " police state, I would rather live a dangerous freedom than living under a dictator, thats for sure.
I have a friend on the Forum. I've never seen that freedom word written on the forum.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89790
Clock
01 Oct 21

@metal-brain said
What is your source of information.
Saying it isn't proving it. Prove it!
🚨🚧moronity of Gop alert🚧🚨

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
Clock
01 Oct 21

Keep your nose out of other people's lives and all of this stuff goes away.

AverageJoe1
Catch the Train 47!

Lake Como

Joined
27 Jul 10
Moves
54603
Clock
01 Oct 21
1 edit

@eladar said
Keep your nose out of other people's lives and all of this stuff goes away.
This goes over a lib’s head, to them there is nothing abnormal about spending all of their time being involved in what other people are doing. I would present it that way instead of being involved in their business. Each person they are in contact with simply must be transformed, and must give up some of their stuff. Jesus said 10%, but they think more. Why cant they leave us alone?

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
01 Oct 21

@quackquack said
We disagree. The vaccine is incredibly safe (so much so that's traveling to a vaccination site is literally more dangerous then the vaccine). The vaccine gives more protection than just antibodies and that protection benefits everyone not just the person getting the vaccine.
One size fit all rules are used all the time. There is a age where you can legally drive (even ...[text shortened]... ule is that if you don't get a vaccine you will (and should be) prevented from enter certain locals.
It's a clear rule, but not necessarily rational.

I know it's the extreme example, but giving a healthy 12 year old boy 2 doses of vaccine 6 weeks after he recovered from COVID invites a risk of myocarditis that is greater than the second dose's benefit. Myocarditis is not the same as not having a drink or cigarette.

A pandemic does not excuse the need to cost-benefit analyses, especially when you're talking about mandates.

mchill
Cryptic

Behind the scenes

Joined
27 Jun 16
Moves
3283
Clock
01 Oct 21
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

@sh76 said
It's a clear rule, but not necessarily rational.

I know it's the extreme example, but giving a healthy 12 year old boy 2 doses of vaccine 6 weeks after he recovered from COVID invites a risk of myocarditis that is greater than the second dose's benefit. Myocarditis is not the same as not having a drink or cigarette.

A pandemic does not excuse the need to cost-benefit analyses, especially when you're talking about mandates.
A pandemic does not excuse the need to cost-benefit analyses, especially when you're talking about mandates.


I think this highlights the difficulty in trying a craft a set of rules that will meet everyone's needs. Between the anti-vaxers, and multiple variants of this virus, it's a bit like trying to hit a target that not only moves, but changes speed and direction too.

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
Clock
01 Oct 21

@mchill said
A pandemic does not excuse the need to cost-benefit analyses, especially when you're talking about mandates.


I think this highlights the difficulty in trying a craft a set of rules that will meet everyone's needs. Between the anti-vaxers, and multiple variants of this virus, it's a bit like trying to hit a target that not only moves, but changes speed and direction too.
The true problem lies in big government and big business start viewing citizens as serfs.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
01 Oct 21

@mchill said
A pandemic does not excuse the need to cost-benefit analyses, especially when you're talking about mandates.


I think this highlights the difficulty in trying a craft a set of rules that will meet everyone's needs. Between the anti-vaxers, and multiple variants of this virus, it's a bit like trying to hit a target that not only moves, but changes speed and direction too.
I'm not worried about appeasing the anti-vaxxers, but I am very worried about trying to stop people from making rational, fact-based healthcare decisions. Refusing to double-vax a healthy 12 year old who recently recovered from COVID and tests positive for antibodies is quite rational.

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
Clock
01 Oct 21

@sh76 said
I'm not worried about appeasing the anti-vaxxers, but I am very worried about trying to stop people from making rational, fact-based healthcare decisions. Refusing to double-vax a healthy 12 year old who recently recovered from COVID and tests positive for antibodies is quite rational.
So you have issues with people making decisions for themselves?

m

Joined
07 Feb 09
Moves
151917
Clock
01 Oct 21

@eladar said
So you have issues with people making decisions for themselves?
When some people walk around saying...
- COVID is a hoax
- vaccinations are government control
- I'm wearing the armor of God
And then they mingle in society and impact the freedom of everyone else......
And increase the chance of a 5th or 6th wave....

Yes, then I have some issues.
People making their own decisions is one thing.
Making smart decisions is another matter.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
01 Oct 21

@eladar said
So you have issues with people making decisions for themselves?
Of course I do, when those decisions hurt other people. So do you.

Of course, I do agree that restrictions to benefit other people should be narrowly tailored and limit freedom only to the extent necessary.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.