Go back
No farms, no food, no future

No farms, no food, no future

Debates

A Unique Nickname

Joined
10 Jan 08
Moves
19081
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Metal-Brain said
In a rural area a garden may require fencing to keep out the deer unless you only grow garlic or something else deer do not like to eat. That is one of the upsides to urban farming. You don't have a deer problem in the city.

Fencing is expensive. Deer can jump a very high fence in the day time, but they don't at night when they usually raid your garden.
How do you know deer don't like garlic? Fortunately we don't have many deers in Ireland.

Cliff Mashburn

Joined
09 Jan 22
Moves
1139
Clock
53d

@A-Unique-Nickname said
I've grown some of my own food in the past yes but now it's impossible, being a homeless bum.

And it doesn't require as land as you think, have you ever heard of urban farm? People in apartments with no 'land' creating space for food production. But for year round self sufficiently of course it's extremely difficult, and mass farming is needed but not at the dam ...[text shortened]... make a profit. Something that if we're going to live on this planet for much longer needs to change.
A family of 4 would need almost a hundred acres of land to be self-sufficient and grow their own food. Growing some vegetables on top of your apartment would be enough for an occasional salad.
"According to the Food and Agricultural Organization, the minimum amount of land needed for self-sustainable food in North America or Western Europe is 17 acres per person. This number assumes absolutely no land degradation, crop failures, or waste."

A Unique Nickname

Joined
10 Jan 08
Moves
19081
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Cliff-Mashburn said
A family of 4 would need almost a hundred acres of land to be self-sufficient and grow their own food. Growing some vegetables on top of your apartment would be enough for an occasional salad.
"According to the Food and Agricultural Organization, the minimum amount of land needed for self-sustainable food in North America or Western Europe is 17 acres per person. This number assumes absolutely no land degradation, crop failures, or waste."
We eat too much, that's why we're fat. And I disagree with the food and agricultural propaganda. In reality it's much less land... Anyway, I understand it's a fairytale that's not going to happen, however there's nothing to stop people growing enough to supplement their consumption so there doesn't need to be as many polluting farms.

Great Big Stees

Joined
14 Mar 04
Moves
186902
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

Where I live, in southwestern Ontario (Canada) because of our “close” proximity to a major corridor between Toronto and the USA (Detroit) there are some big time manufacturing concerns setting up shop here. Now these same manufacturers not only need land but folks to work in those plants. As a result, (oh and we are a cash crop farming, for the most part, area) a lot of very good farm land is being gobbled up to build these plants and subdivisions. Add the fact that acreage pricing is going through the roof and the farms around here are in the 300+ acre ranges, it’s hard for a farmer not to be tempted to sell, oh and a lot of those same farms are being run by, probably the last generations to want to continue farming. The outlook is not especially promising for…well farming.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9629
Clock
53d
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@divegeester said
The bottom line is that farmers across Europe are protesting at EU over regulation.

Why can’t you see there’s a big problem.
I think you are framing the problem incorrectly. The protests are not the problem. The problem is that western farming practices are not profitable, and they need to adjust their methods. They don't want to adjust, because change is hard. So they protest.

The US solution is bad too. After tariffs Trump's administration just decided to pay the farmers the difference to return them to profitability, to the tune of tens of billions per year

Cliff Mashburn

Joined
09 Jan 22
Moves
1139
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
I think you are framing the problem incorrectly. The protests are not the problem. The problem is that western farming practices are not profitable, and they need to adjust their methods. They don't want to adjust, because change is hard. So they protest.

The US solution is bad too. After tariffs Trump's administration just decided to pay the farmers the difference to return them to profitability, to the tune of tens of billions per year
Farm subsidies have been around since the 1920's, but keep blaming Trump, it seems to be working for you.

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121016
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
I think you are framing the problem incorrectly. The protests are not the problem. The problem is that western farming practices are not profitable, and they need to adjust their methods. They don't want to adjust, because change is hard. So they protest.

The US solution is bad too. After tariffs Trump's administration just decided to pay the farmers the difference to return them to profitability, to the tune of tens of billions per year
I don’t think I’m “framing” the problem at all; I just posted the facts.

You have you liberal pro EU anti farmer opinion on those facts and I have mine.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9629
Clock
53d

@Cliff-Mashburn said
Farm subsidies have been around since the 1920's, but keep blaming Trump, it seems to be working for you.
Payouts not subsidies. While y'all were complaining about student loans, trump invented a new welfare program will cost way more.

https://www.politico.com/news/2020/07/14/donald-trump-coronavirus-farmer-bailouts-359932

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9629
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@divegeester said
I don’t think I’m “framing” the problem at all; I just posted the facts.

You have you liberal pro EU anti farmer opinion on those facts and I have mine.
"farming isn't profitable" is an opinion?

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121016
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
"farming isn't profitable" is an opinion?
It’s a version of part of the opinion of farmers right across the EU countries and the UK apparently.

Did you not get that from your reading around the links I posted?

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22654
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@A-Unique-Nickname said
How do you know deer don't like garlic? Fortunately we don't have many deers in Ireland.
I grew some and they never ate any of it.

https://naturesmace.com/blogs/blog/do-deer-eat-garlic

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22654
Clock
53d

@divegeester

Is this why?

https://allnewspipeline.com/The_Elite_Plan_For_The_Great_Food_Reset.php

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121016
Clock
53d
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Metal-Brain said
@divegeester

Is this why?

https://allnewspipeline.com/The_Elite_Plan_For_The_Great_Food_Reset.php
Why what ?

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22654
Clock
53d

@divegeester
It’s All About Control: The Elite Plan for the Great Food Reset - When People Are Starving It’s Easier To Keep Them In Check, Prevent Them From Protesting, And Control Them

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
53d

@wildgrass said
The problem is that western farming practices are not profitable, and they need to adjust their methods. They don't want to adjust, because change is hard. So they protest.
Western nations like the United States and France and Japan heavily subsidize farmers. So they often have little incentive to be efficient and diversified - which is good advice in life, but particularly in farming.

If gummint insurance will pay you for a failed corn crop, you'll plant 100% corn every year, even if you should be planting a variety of things that will actually grow in your (possibly arid & run-down) land and which you can sell. It's all about what makes you the most money.

Dairy farmers love it when the government buys over-production in milk, but hate it when government tells them to control their manure pollution run-off. So farmers protest in both directions: Give Us More Support! But Give Us Less Regulation! That doesn't mean they are right. It just means they are businessmen like anyone else.

Government should be protecting all our rights - which when it comes to farming means reigning in pollution and preventing environmental disaster but not a lot else.

No human endeavor has changed the face of the planet more than agriculture. It's important to pay attention to it.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.